I'm not as down on Noah Smith as many, but this is honestly a pretty bad review. He basically admits to having trouble understanding it owing to it being disor

I'm not as down on Noah Smith as many, but this is honestly a pretty bad review. He basically admits to having trouble understanding it owing to it being disorganized (a point he repeats frequently). But then he complains about people who criticize him for not making good faith attempts understanding what they're saying. Then he spends way too much of it trying to criticize anyone who would tell him it's bad and even spends an entire paragraph talking about how he suspects Graeber is a public intellectual who bristles at criticism before going on to pre-emptively bristle at any potential criticism of his review. Not his best work, to be sure.