4 ms·
All money spent causes pollution if you trace it back far enough. As a first approximation, environmental impact is directly proportional to cost.
by xnx 6y ago
All money spent causes pollution if you trace it back far enough. As a first approximation, environmental impact is directly proportional to cost.
- ironmagma 6y agoThat’s an oversimplification, if nothing else because you can spend money to save money. Likewise you can make a monetary expenditure to prevent other more environmentally costly expenditures.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoIt's not a bad approximation. More flights, bigger houses, bigger cars, more toys, faster computers. They all cost more and all have a bigger environmental impact. There are a few things where spending will decrease your emissions, loft insulation, possibly replacing your petrol car with an EV, definitely replacing it with an e-bike. Even if there are savings made what do people do with their reduced energy costs? Mostly buy more products/services.
- ironmagma 6y agoTo some extent yes, but that is different from the claim, which is about "all money." But also, you're neglecting things like cheaper parts tending to be worse for the environment. Comparatively expensive wood, for instance, would likely cause fewer problems than cheaper plastics. Plus, that's true by virtue of the cheaper parts breaking sooner and needing to be replaced. It's certainly not a universal that luxury goods are eco-friendly, but it is true that eco-friendliness is a factor that requires a premium to be paid for it.
- thomasahle 6y agoI don't think that's necessarily a very good or helpful approximation. It's very cheap to send vaste chemicals into the sea. It's more expensive to capture them -- and while it might pollute to build a good capture system, it'll _very_ quickly be outweighed by not sending the stuff into the sea.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoDue to the lack of externalities being reflected in the cost of fossil fuels, I don’t think that is true. Environmental impact due to fossil fuels is proportional to energy consumed, which is probably roughly proportional to mass times distance traveled. I’m sure there’s lots of different types of environmental impact not priced in such as excess heat caused by paved surfaces, air pollution caused by particulates from tires and brakes and fuel exhaust, water table pollution caused by waste seeping down through the earth, etc.