4 ms·

This may be considered blasphemy, but I continue to use i3-gaps on my 43" 4K monitor in 100% floating mode. It actually works quite well. Of course for my small

This may be considered blasphemy, but I continue to use i3-gaps on my 43" 4K monitor in 100% floating mode. It actually works quite well. Of course for my small displays I use tiling mode.

boogies 6y ago
Does i3 allow you to easily toggle floating on each window (regardless of the main mode that new windows default to) like dwm?
- aardvark179 6y ago
  Yes, shift-super-space is I think the default key binding to switch the current window.
  - boogies 6y ago
    That’s exactly what it is in dwm (except that dwm defaults to using alt as the MOD(ifier) instead of super, but changing that takes only a one line patch). And you can also just use MOD-leftmouse-drag to move a window or MOD-rightmousedrag to resize (either of which change the window to floating mode if it isn’t there already), or use MOD-middlemouseclick to toggle its floating state.
yearoflinux 6y ago
Why don't you use one of the olden and golden wm's for that? i3 doesn't have alt-tab
- jcelerier 6y ago
  sure it does bindsym $mod+Tab exec --no-startup-id rofi -show window
  - approxim8ion 6y ago
    Rofi is great, but it's still adding several extra keystrokes for something that alt-tab essentially does in 2 (alt, hold tab till you get to a window you want, release to go to it. on rofi, you'd have to press alt-tab to invoke the window dialog, then type a portion of window name or navigate down to it, then press enter) .
    - jcelerier 6y ago
      > (alt, hold tab till you get to a window you want, release to go to it. madness :) I could never manage to get to my window like that, it's alt + tab tab tab tab tab tab tab until I get where I want when on windows vs alt + tab down down down down on rofi so I don't see a lot of difference
      - approxim8ion 6y ago
        Haha, fair enough. Also turns out tab tab tab tab works on rofi -show window (my fault for not using it much hence not knowing) so maybe it's not all that different after all!
approxim8ion 6y ago
Imo if you're only floating, Openbox is even lighter than i3 and works great. Super configurable too- the config file is just XML. I really enjoyed my time on it but I like tiling too much. Window-snapping wasn't enough.
- boring_twenties 6y ago
  Ick. I use xmonad, despite not knowing any Haskell. I basically just copy pasted little snippets from all over the place and changed random characters until it started working. Pretty sure I still prefer this state of affairs to XML.
smabie 6y ago
If you're only using the floating mode, I would recommend trying cwm.

This may be considered blasphemy, but I continue to use i3-gaps on my 43" 4K monitor in 100% floating mode. It actually works quite well. Of course for my small displays I use tiling mode.

boogies 6y ago

Does i3 allow you to easily toggle floating on each window (regardless of the main mode that new windows default to) like dwm?

aardvark179 6y ago
Yes, shift-super-space is I think the default key binding to switch the current window.
- boogies 6y ago
  That’s exactly what it is in dwm (except that dwm defaults to using alt as the MOD(ifier) instead of super, but changing that takes only a one line patch). And you can also just use MOD-leftmouse-drag to move a window or MOD-rightmousedrag to resize (either of which change the window to floating mode if it isn’t there already), or use MOD-middlemouseclick to toggle its floating state.

yearoflinux 6y ago

Why don't you use one of the olden and golden wm's for that? i3 doesn't have alt-tab

jcelerier 6y ago
sure it does bindsym $mod+Tab exec --no-startup-id rofi -show window
- approxim8ion 6y ago
  Rofi is great, but it's still adding several extra keystrokes for something that alt-tab essentially does in 2 (alt, hold tab till you get to a window you want, release to go to it. on rofi, you'd have to press alt-tab to invoke the window dialog, then type a portion of window name or navigate down to it, then press enter) .
  - jcelerier 6y ago
    > (alt, hold tab till you get to a window you want, release to go to it. madness :) I could never manage to get to my window like that, it's alt + tab tab tab tab tab tab tab until I get where I want when on windows vs alt + tab down down down down on rofi so I don't see a lot of difference
    - approxim8ion 6y ago
      Haha, fair enough. Also turns out tab tab tab tab works on rofi -show window (my fault for not using it much hence not knowing) so maybe it's not all that different after all!

approxim8ion 6y ago

Imo if you're only floating, Openbox is even lighter than i3 and works great. Super configurable too- the config file is just XML. I really enjoyed my time on it but I like tiling too much. Window-snapping wasn't enough.

boring_twenties 6y ago
Ick. I use xmonad, despite not knowing any Haskell. I basically just copy pasted little snippets from all over the place and changed random characters until it started working. Pretty sure I still prefer this state of affairs to XML.

smabie 6y ago

If you're only using the floating mode, I would recommend trying cwm.