3 ms·
Corporation tax tax seems totally unfit for purpose, it just means small companies pay tax and multinationals can dodge it. As a revenue raising effort I think
by mhh__ 6y ago
Corporation tax tax seems totally unfit for purpose, it just means small companies pay tax and multinationals can dodge it. As a revenue raising effort I think DST is superior.
The issue is that it's difficult to have a frank discussion about tax policy in the UK, because a lot of people basically view tax as a way of sticking one to the capitalists rather than actually doing good. We tax cigarettes to stop people smoking, we tax businesses because why? Their employees pay tax, NI, and their customers pay VAT. The public have a very naive view of business - some business's are exploitative, yes, but the reason why potentially unsavoury companies like Uber are doing well is because they are simply superior to their competitors. I don't want my own moral standards applied to every business transaction, let alone the Twitter mob.
- gruez 6y agoDST?
- metiscus 6y agoI believe it means Digital Service Tax but I could be mistaken.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoWe tax businesses because businesses benefit from public infrastructure - health care, education, physical infrastructure - and they're expected to make a contribution just like everyone else. In fact the UK is very bad at taxing corporations. It subsidises low wages with tax credits, which incentivise corporates to pay people poorly. London is also one of the capitals for money laundering (including crime proceeds) and offshore tax evasion - about to become even more so after Brexit. So the world would be a better place if basic moral standards were applied to all business transactions. Sadly they aren't, and that causes huge social and political distortions, as well as inconveniencing smaller businesses at the expense of large multinationals.
- mhh__ 6y agoAs I said, businesses already pay tax and should not go untaxed but why profits specifically? We have business rates for land, fuel duty for vehicles, VAT for customers, NI contributions etc. We also have a basic form of carbon tax for some businesses although it's not particularly fleshed out. By moral standards I mean people second guessing consenting economic transactions e.g. no one seems to ask people driving on Uber whether they want to be employees or not, because the Tories don't care and some elements of the Labour party view all employment as slavery of one kind or the other.
- LatteLazy 6y agoCorporation tax is paid by small Ltd company owners (usually employees). It replaces NI at a higher rate. Similarly dividend tax is paid by the same people replacing income tax. Neither are paid by big companies. They should be renamed, as currently they do a job, but are very misleading...