4 ms·
Would be curious on any Brits' opinions on if this (failure to support revolutionary technology) happens more there, and if so then why. Recognize biases of hi
by ethbr0 6y ago
Would be curious on any Brits' opinions on if this (failure to support revolutionary technology) happens more there, and if so then why.
Recognize biases of hindsight, but it seems like private equity markets in Britain aren't interested in technology at the requisite scale.
There's an incredible historical tradition [1], but the majority tend to be either developed with the help of a (1) few angel investors (and the luck and smaller scale that entails) or (2) government contracts (and the politics that entails).
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_British_innovations_and_discoveries https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_British_innovations_...
- growlist 6y agoI've come to the conclusion that many of the powerful in the UK view the nation primarily as a means for personal gain of one kind of another, and have no particular attachment to the UK's history, culture, and people, indeed, many of them seem to view the English (in particular) with barely disguised contempt.
- someperson 6y agoThis statement is meaningful even if you replace UK with US, but the US is still where most of the revolutionary technology comes from
- ethbr0 6y agoThe US does lack a tradition of monarchy and/or a hereditary landowning class. Which is probably not nothing in subsequent social evolutions.
- brudgers 6y agoSince 1066.
- growlist 6y agoCorrect.
- Gravityloss 6y agoI think Paul Graham went to the UK once to try to find technology investors. Once. (Can't find that essay right now.)
- ethbr0 6y agoSpeaking to something I have little experience with, but 'old, @&$@-you money isn't adventurous' would seem to apply.
- ativzzz 6y agoMakes sense. If I had old f you money, I'd be more concerned about preserving it for multiple generations than growing it significantly.
- Nursie 6y agoComparatively, venture capital of the silicon valley sort is hard to come by, from what I can see. There is also a weird preoccupation with the London startup scene; politicians decided they were going to nurture it and help fund things there. Which is fine, but they ignored the Cambridge area which is where a lot of the actual innovative tech in the UK gets developed, in favour of (effectively) a bunch of cool-sounding app vendors.
- TorKlingberg 6y agoNow pg lives in England. He was born here though, so I guess it's for family reasons.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoI just watched the movie Johnny Dangerously with one of my kids. If you're alluding to Danny Vermin (Joe Piscopo's character), I'm very amused.
- DrScientist 6y agoA few observations from person experience of working in small startups, and large companies. Being part of companies that were sold, and being both ends of attempted takeovers, all in comparison to what I've seen in US companies. 1. In terms of sensible investment, what I've seen is that success breeds success - one success creates wealthy individuals with experience that can lead or by part of the next round. 2. UK markets are quite conservative, cautious and by and large dominated by people who don't understand science and technology, compounding the problem. They tend to want to drip feed money rather than go for the big win. 3. Following on from 1 & 2. There is a culture of selling early, rather than building really big, and if you don't have anyone big in the UK to sell to then it goes abroad. 4. UK government appears to welcome, nay have pride in, the acquisition and destruction of some of the UK's biggest companies by opportunists. 5. UK business leaders typically lack global ambition, nay ego/hubris. 6. UK stock market is rather short term, preferring dividends to inward long term investment - the sort of investment typically required to grow. So what you get is lots of interesting small to medium size companies - often started in concert with the strong UK academic sector, and/or diaspora from previous successes - and very few transitions to global players. ARM was one of the few - that's why it's so disappointing to see it sold first to Softbank and now possibly NVidia. The only silver lining is any change is likely to create a diaspora eager for new opportunities - so in the case of ARM - lots of experienced well off engineers ( more able to take a risk ) in one of the worlds best academic centers of excellence.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago>2. UK markets are quite conservative, cautious and by and large dominated by people who don't understand science and technology, compounding the problem. Haha, me laughing then crying in underpaid German conservatism that dwarfs the British one. You guys don't know how good you have it. Brexit aside, London is still Europe's biggest tech capital by a long shot and devs there can make way more than anywhere in Europe bar Switzerland.
- DrScientist 6y agoI think software is a little different than other tech/science companies. Typically they need less upfront investment ( unless you go the buy customer route a la Uber etc - but the jury is out on whether they will ever pay back their investors ), and can grow much quicker and so are less constrained by institutional investors. London is certainly very good for things like Fintech which employs a lot of software people on good salaries in London. But then city investors understand Fintech. My experience is mostly hard science tech, rather than software per se. I'd consider quite a lot of the software 'tech' companies to really be business model innovation companies rather than 'software' innovations ( ie software that's really hard to write ). The tech bubble classic example in London was lastminute.com - a holiday clearing house website - who's founders didn't understand the technology side. One technical area the UK is strong in is ML - Googles deepmind started in London, and machine learning for Apple, Amazon, and Microsoft all worked on up the road in Cambridge. Again seeded by small companies bought by larger foreign companies.
- banjo_milkman 6y agoThere are multiple examples of revolutionary technology from the UK: 1) ARM - dominates embedded systems, >90% of cellphones and IoT, sold to SoftBank, now on the way to NVidia 2) DeepMind - arguably global leader in AI, now part of Google 3) Illumina/Solexa - >90% of global DNA sequencing market, biotech leader, sold to Illumina for $600, Solexa sequencing now the basis for a $50bn market cap Britain has the problem that too much of the country is focused on finance + the services that surround it, the country bends over backwards to support those industries through deregulation/not enforcing rules (LIBOR scandal et al), intervening with foreign governments to protect banks (see HSBC 'too big to jail') while pretending it is lassez-faire & does not have an industrial policy. The ironic thing is that the financial industry could help develop these seeds of technology into behemoths but have misguidedly focused on inflating land values + developing dodgy financial instruments. Another problem is culture - many Brits have the ambition of making $ millions of money and then retiring to a country house. Not many Zuckerbergs have emerged from the UK.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- DrScientist 6y agoI'd agree with the influence of the city - for example when large UK companies are faced with takeover governments seem more interested to supporting the city as being 'open for business' than protecting the industrial base.