10 ms·
The takeaways seem to be disconnected to the article. Do we have evidence that the phone calls mattered a hill of beans? That sounds like a post-hoc justifica
by patio11 16y ago
The takeaways seem to be disconnected to the article. Do we have evidence that the phone calls mattered a hill of beans? That sounds like a post-hoc justification to cover an employee's sudden unexpected possession of reliable market data.
I love tradition as much as the next guy, but I think there is virtually no advantage to employees from our cultural norm that comp information is as sensitive as health information. The advantage to employers is, ahem, fairly straightforward: they get to pay systematically lower salaries to people who don't realize that e.g. failing to say one sentence when you're 22 costs you almost a hundred thousand dollars by the time you are thirty. (The contents of that sentence is essentially "Your offer plus $5k.")
- eroded 16y ago> failing to say one sentence when you're 22 costs you almost a hundred thousand dollars by the time you are thirty. Wow. As a CS-grad about to take a full-time job offer, I'd surprisingly never thought of this at all. But how easy is it to say "Your offer plus $5k"? What could be the possible consequences of this?
- Afton 16y agoThere is virtually no downside to this. Your university/college has coop advisors and employment offices. Go and get some advice for salary negotiating.
- SamReidHughes 16y agoYou'll get a mark on your permanent record.
- paulbaumgart 16y agoWorst case, their reply will be "no", and then you can still decide you want to take the original offer. More likely, they'll agree to give you some more money. I'm no expert on the state of the art in salary negotiation books, but http://www.amazon.com/Negotiating-Your-Salary-Make-Minute/dp/1580083102 http://www.amazon.com/Negotiating-Your-Salary-Make-Minute/dp... is decent for getting you in the right mindset.
- patio11 16y agoDecision maker: Alright, let's talk numbers. What is your desired salary? You: I don't know, you're in a much better position to judge my worth to the firm than I am. Decisionmaker: But in terms of an actual number? You: [Polite nothings. Repeat as necessary.] Decisionmaker: Alright, how would $80k do? You: That's interesting. Would you do $85k? Decisionmaker: OK. That is literally how simple it is, and your downside risk is "Alright, in that case, $80k is alright" and nobody will remember this conversation 2 weeks from now except your checking account. You can do more complicated things, like demonstrating value to the firm, or treating any no as a suggestion that you negotiate some other aspect of the offer instead, but the simplest way to improve outcomes at negotiation is to actually negotiate. The marginal $5k gets compounded at every annual raise you have, virtually certain to be calculated by an HR drone's spreadsheet by multiplying a contentious number by a very non-contentious number (your current salary -- now $5k larger). It will increase other benefits you receive, such as employer match to your IRA. If you actually treat questions about salary history at face value when switching firms, it will also act as an anchor for your pricing for the rest of your career. (Giving out salary history? Yeah, that's another thing that can't possibly help you. Anyone asking you for salary history is saying, in as many words, "Please give me a reason why I should give you less money.")
- smcl 16y agoRight in that scenario the salary was a question "how would $80k do?", in my experience employers have rarely been so cavalier. They're a little more firm, i.e. "The offer is £80k" I'd be interested to see if anyone had a good comeback for that
- mlinsey 16y agoThe comeback is identical.
- lemming 16y ago"90k and we have a deal."
- aphexairlines 16y agoIt's also often in a letter/email, not a phone conversation where you might mention that +5k as a natural reply.
- jonah 16y agoWell, it's like buying a car or a house but in reverse. The employer isn't going to pay you more than they have to so they'll make an offer at the low end of the reasonable range. Unless it's some minimum wage job, there is a range of valid salaries and they probably have budgeted 10% or more higher than their initial offer. Now, you may have to convince them you're worth getting paid higher in the range for that role but you should definitely counter-offer. Also, my general rule of thumb while negotiating is to counter with a number higher than you'd be happy with and then negotiate to something near the middle of the two. (I learned all this the hard way in my first job, but fortunately my manager was awesome and I got a 50% raise after a year.)
- krobertson 16y agoAbsolutely ask for more. They never come in with their highest offer. You ever go in buying a car offering the highest you'll pay right off the bat? They won't retract the offer or anything. And even if they did, you probably wouldn't want to work for them in the long run, so would be doing you a favor.
- enjo 16y agoTell me about it. I came out of college in 2002 and was looking for a job in Dallas while my wife went to school. This was the lowest of the lows, right after the telecoms in Dallas had folded and just flooded the market with thousands of developers. Not that there were many jobs. Thankfully I had some rather unique experience, and that helped me find a job. I took the first number they offered ($48k/yr I think). That was a HUGE mistake, even in those times. After all, I had some fairly unique experience. My second mistake was a couple of years later at the same company. We were recently bought and I took that as an opportunity to negotiate my salary. They asked me what I was looking for, and while I had done my homework on market rates...I really undersold myself. A part of me hoped that they'd come to a more competitive number on their own. They didn't. It put me in the weird position of asking for a proper market-rate adjustment just 6 months later. I got exactly what I asked for the third time too, but this time it was much more fair. Over that period I probably lost $70k all told. Huge mistake.
- AgentConundrum 16y agoI took the first number they offered ($48k/yr I think). That was a HUGE mistake, even in those times. That's not the worst mistake you could have made though. For my first job, I was interviewing with a company that a college acquaintance was working for. Through a mutual friend, I had a rough idea how much this acquaintance was making... or so I thought. When the salary portion came up, the company recruiter asked me how much I was expecting. Being incredibly naive about such things, and thinking I knew how much they were willing to pay, I gave a number. What happened next is something I'll remember in every salary negotiation for the rest of my life. The recruiter apologized, and said that they simply didn't pay anyone that little, and she told me their company minimum and asked if I was ok with that. Sheepishly, I accepted, knowing that I had just completely screwed myself and I really was no longer in a position to negotiate for more.
- patio11 16y agoThe kicker? It is entirely possible your acquaintance was actually working for a number well below their we-absolutely-wouldn't-pay-you-below-this number. "Sketch reasons why this could happen" would make a good interview question, since it demonstrates life skills for dealing with large corporations.
- Murkin 16y agoThere is a somewhat questionable practise, that has proven very effective (by friends of course). After negotiating like patio suggested, you receive the offer and ask a few days to consider. You then contact back and say that currently there are two/three offers on the table that you are considering. And since each has its merits, you decided to choose based on compensation and ask if there is any wriggle room on their offer. Usually works perfectly, and even if it doesn't. You end up feeling that you really got the best they could do.
- abbasmehdi 16y agoDon't ever do that! Your offer will be retracted based on lack of interest unless you're a well known superstar.
- martincmartin 16y agoAs someone who has been on both sides of hiring, I think this is something you absolutely should do. When a company makes you an offer, it means all the people who interviewed you got together and decided they liked you. Mentally, the company has committed to you. For the hiring manager to lose you over a few thousand dollars a year will reflect very poorly on him/her. This is also the point where you have the highest leverage. Your leverage is always based around the idea that you might go to another company. When you're considering multiple offers, it's very credible that you might work for another company. Once you've been hired and you've been working there for a year, they figure the inertia of leaving your job and going to another company is big, and limit your salary raise.
- michaelochurch 16y agoI disagree on the threat of retraction, obviously. Most firms aren't going to risk their reputations by rescinding an offer unless there was something severe (failure to disclose a felony) involved. However, I think using post-offer leverage to negotiate extra pay is a bad idea. The leverage exists, but it's limited. I'd rather use it to get insight into (and favor in) project allocation than a measly few grand. Project allocation is the difference between having a successful career-- learning a lot, working with great people, getting the promotions-- and needing to find a new job in 12 months. A few thousand dollars is nothing in comparison. This style of negotiation is more subtle, and takes the form of a "reverse interview" than a line-in-the-sand "I want $10k more" statement, but I think the former is better at (a) presenting yourself well, and (b) getting you what you actually want, which is a successful career. I also tend to subscribe to the philosophy that the first 120 days of any job (including post-offer negotiation) are an extended interview. What you want to show is that you care about your work intensely and that you have the potential to reach very high levels, but also that you expect to be challenged and given appropriate work; not that you are a mercenary who makes career decisions based on a few thousand dollars.
- shasta 16y ago"but I think there is virtually no advantage to employees from our cultural norm" On average. For (perceived) good employees that have above average negotiating skill, there can be a big advantage to this system.
- steven5122 16y ago>>The takeaways seem to be disconnected to the article You can say that again. The takeaway should have been to find another job, who would want to work for a company like that?