8 ms·
All forms of signing email are generally solving the wrong problem
- upofadown 6y agoAll you have to do is to ignore email that is signed by entities you don't know and/or don't like. It is as simple as that. The mystery is why people accept anonymous email at all.
- superkuh 6y agoAs an independent email server operator for almost a decade I can tell you the big three email providers are boiling that frog.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoIf someone were going to register a domain to use for e-mail, what would you recommend? Does the name chosen or TLD make a difference or is IP address the sole determinant of "reputation"? I imagine the situation is like with search, the filtering algorithms used are kept secret, probably because they are biased toward protecting or improving the company's revenues.
- lioeters 6y agoBoth the registered domain and shared/dedicated IP address are factors in determining email reputation. For example, see: https://www.mailgun.com/blog/domain-ip-reputation-gmail-care-more-about/ https://www.mailgun.com/blog/domain-ip-reputation-gmail-care... I've never heard about TLD being a factor, but who knows? It's possible.
- TwoBit 6y agoI don't see how that is simple unless the set of people you intentionally exchange emails with stays pretty constant.
- bawolff 6y agoPretty unconvinced that (the lack of) revokable authorization is the problem with email. But for the sake of argument, lets say it was. DKIM+whitelist solves that problem, so dkim would still be solving the right problem.
- Sebb767 6y agoDKIM is not solving the wrong problem, DKIM is solving an underlying problem. The suggestions to use reputation, accounts etc are still fine and good, but step 0 is to check whether that guy on the other side is who he says he is - and that's where DKIM comes in.
- brightball 6y agoDKIM is great but the keys need to be rotated at some interval. Most services will setup a CNAME so they can do this for you at least these days.
- throwawayinfo 6y agoI'm a big fan of rotating keys monthly just to force automation. Maybe that's the answer?
- brightball 6y agoI think that’s a great idea. When it comes to DKIM keys, since there’s no expiration it’s very common for manually managed to be setup and forgotten.
- stiray 6y agoYes but then again (i consider this their trolling of diy) google forces you to set up reverse resolve regardless of dkim. They effectively lock out (or should I say, spam out) anyone that doesnt have ISP preparing to do that and it complicates migration to another ISP. And prevents you running multiple domain mail server on single ip. It is true, that reverse resolve generally in EU isnt such a problem, but it does make issues for USA users.
- citrin_ru 6y agoYou don't need to be an ISP to change reverse DNS mappings, you can ask your ISP (or do this via UI provided by the ISP). Most cloud providers allows to configure reverse name, the same for DCs which offer servers for rent or provide co-location. Broadband ISPs offer this for business customers (unless they face no competition and get away with being customer unfriendly). Though it is not a good idea to host a mail server on a broadband connections - they usually blacklisted because of history of spam. > And prevents you running multiple domain mail server on single ip No it is not. You have to have a pair of mappings: IP -> hostname -> IP, but practically nobody checks that domain of hostname matches domains used in emails. Most mail providers send mail with multiple domains in mail form using shared pool of servers which do not use customer's domains in their hostnames.
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoS/MIME is excellent. I know its currently more suitable for an organization than individuals, but, I think with a bit of glue it would work fantastically at internet-scale.
- bawolff 6y agoWhat's your proposed solution to the PKI-is-hard if your not an org problem?
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoLetsEncrypt starts signing email certs. That part is easy.
- tialaramex 6y agoISRG (the charity behind Let's Encrypt) has been pretty clear in the past that they aren't interested in doing that. Do you have some particular reason beyond wishful thinking to believe that will change? If you want to build a CA that issues S/MIME certs you can already do that. If you want to leverage ACME you can even do that (using https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-acme-email-smime/ https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-acme-email-smime... for example). Perhaps you can persuade S/MIME client implementations that your certificates are universally trustworthy, and then you've got the makings of a PKI for S/MIME. But I would not hold my breath.
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoSure, so, setup your own email cert issuing ACME compliant CA. Still easy.
- tialaramex 6y agoYou're the one who wants this, so it's you that will need to set up a Certificate Authority and then get it trusted everywhere for S/MIME. I genuinely wish you good luck with that.
- paxys 6y agoThere are two (well, lots more than two) different problems with email. DKMS solves spoofing. That isn't a more or less "wrong" problem than spam. The latter just needs a different solution (and Google etc. have become pretty good at it).
- xapata 6y agoEasy solution: enable a configurable monetary barrier. People who want notes from strangers can set it low, people who don't can set the price higher. Hey, Basecamp, can you make that feature for me?
- aeternum 6y agoInterestingly, this is where the proof-of-work idea for Bitcoin likely came from (hashcash). Basically prove you've done X amount of CPU work in order to send me an e-mail.
- plantain 6y agoI run a web service with email validation, and a nontrivial number of users' validation emails bounce with a request to click some link to pay some money in order to email the user. Sometimes I get the same responding to support requests from users. I suspect these same users wonder why such a large fraction of their online interactions/signups don't work...
- xapata 6y agoStrange. You'd think they'd be aware of the features of the email service they signed up for.
- m12k 6y agoAnother problem with email is that it's your responsibility to keep your contacts list up-to-date when people change their email address. By comparison Facebook doesn't have that problem - for example organising a high school reunion is much more likely to succeed if you contact people via Facebook than via email. I really hope email (or its successor) can copy more of the benefits that currently draw users into those walled gardens.
- emersion 6y agoFacebook's strategy to achieve this is to disallow people from having two different accounts. Things are different on e.g. Twitter where it's common to have two accounts for different usage (like email). Do you suggest disallowing people from having two different email addresses?
- m12k 6y agoNo, I'm suggesting that once I've authorized someone to be able to contact me, switching to a new email address should not break that.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> By comparison Facebook doesn't have that problem - for example organising a high school reunion is much more likely to succeed if you contact people via Facebook than via email. I see it the opposite way. People regularly drop off of social networks in favor of new ones or none at all. I know people who have had the same email address since the 90's.
- crispyporkbites 6y agoDKIM works well for what it does. Assuming that what the author describes as “revocable authorization” is a desirable feature (I don’t really get why a user wouldn’t just filter them with a block list or white list approach, but whatever) - how is this possible without a centralised provider? If it’s only possible with a centralised entity like Twitter, it’s not going to scale to last centuries like email will.
- em-bee 6y agobecause current filter tools are not specific enough or easy enough to use for that purpose. i basically only got the option to mark something as spam and let the algorithm figure out why. i'd like to sort email by these categories: signed emails with a known/whitelisted key. signed emails with a known/blacklisted key signed emails with an unknown key. unsigned emails with a known/whitelisted email address unsigned emails with a known/blacklisted email address unsigned emails with an unknown address. and finally emails with obviously fake addresses. whitelisted keys go to my inbox. those will be spam free. blacklisted keys are blocked/bounced/sent to spam. new keys go into a new contacts folder with a spam rating based on content. then i walk through that folder and accept or block keys. for unsigned emails the same is done based on the address. whitelisted addresses get a spam rating in a second inbox. blacklisted addresses get blocked and unknown addresses get checked manually. unknown keys or addresses can further be separated into: received only one email from this address or multiple emails. when i reply to an email the key or address gets whitelisted automatically.
- mrjin 6y agoThe author obviously has no idea why email signing are there. And what he was proposing, a authorizing system, or white-list system has been there for quite a while but why it is not enabled by default? It creates more problems then the problems it resolves. Just imagine how it going to work if you need to send a legit email to someone for the first time. If you are going to need authorization to do it, How do you get that required authorization? By calling the recipient or send them a letter so that they can add you to the list? Then what the point to send email in the first place?
- dgellow 6y agoI believe that Hey does something like this: 1. A stranger send you an email 2. Hey asks you if you want to whitelist the sender or not 3. If rejected, you won’t be bothered anymore by any of their emails 4. Otherwise you just get their email moving forward and can decide to reject them later if necessary https://hey.com/features/the-screener/ https://hey.com/features/the-screener/
- kwhitefoot 6y ago> It's possible that email clients could learn some lessons from this, for example by splitting your inbox into 'people and places you've interacted with before' and 'new contacts from strange people'. That's how I have Thunderbird set up. I have a rule that puts mail from anyone not in my contacts list into a folder called Unrecognized Sender.
- teddyh 6y agoHere we go again. I suggest that everyone in the comments with a pet idea read this: https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt
- spacedcowboy 6y agoI don’t know about signing, but my email domain (my surname.net) is now 30 or so years old. It gets^w got a lot of spam... A decade or so ago, I set up a catch-all account so <anything>@mydomain.net is redirected to an isp-account that I have as one of my email identities, In this case I used <account>@mac.com. It’s basically just a front-line imap repository, stuff I want to keep will move off it. Whenever I need to supply an email to an online site, I use <company name>@mydomain.net. The only time this hasn’t worked is with Samsung, who won’t let you sign up as ‘samsung@...’, generally it’s ok though. There is another rule on the mail server, send-to-trash. This accepts all email and just bins it. I can move <anything>@mydomain to this rule at the click of a button in a second or two on with a web-interface. I do this for: - unsolicited email sent to a random “name” at my address, this is actually fairly rare now that most of the obvious ones are gone - when the mail content doesn’t match the <company name> part, ie: where the address has been sold to an email-list. - when I want to expire the email address. Sometimes this is temporary, and I have an address I want to keep, but it’s current;y being spammed. Making the server send reject messages For a while usually helps. Usually. Using this, I’ve managed to keep the same email domain since college some 30 years ago actually useable and useful. YMMV :)
- Ayesh 6y agoI do this for about 10 years now too! It's very convenient to "expire" the email addresses that are sold off. Another thing I do is to use a spam@domain.com email when an annoying site tries to force me to login. All emails to this spam email address is sent to trash with a filtering rule, and I manually open my trash to click the verification link. With catch all emails, you need a string "... -all" SPF to make others reject bounce spam messages.
- GnarfGnarf 6y agoI've been using SpamArrest for about ten years, and I'm very happy with it. I always whitelist in advance any person or domain I expect to hear from. SpamArrest gives me a chance to hear from legitimate strangers. If a sender refuses to reply to the challenge email, then what (s)he had to say couldn't be that important.