4 ms·
You think Go has a bigger hype machine than Haskell and Erlang? The number of blog posts that have been written about how great Erlang is is comparable in total
by jeffbee 6y ago
You think Go has a bigger hype machine than Haskell and Erlang? The number of blog posts that have been written about how great Erlang is is comparable in total size to the amount of Erlang code that exists.
- valenterry 6y ago> You think Go has a bigger hype machine than Haskell and Erlang? In absolute terms? Yes In terms relative to the userbase? No In terms relative to how powerful or well-designed the language is? Certainly
- philosopher1234 6y agoWhat don't you like about go's design? I see this sentiment all the time that go is poorly designed. What I don't see all the time is why people have this idea. Is it because its not as strongly typed or mathematically obsessed as other languages? Is it because it doesn't add much that is deeply novel like e.g. Rust?
- fileeditview 6y agoI think people dislike Go because it is missing the fancy feelings. I am more convinced every year that a lot of programmers just love complexity. Simple things will be blown up and abstracted 3 times. This is still possible with Go of course but it is not as easy as with other languages. Go is like a rusty old hammer that will just work and there are not too many ways to hold it. I like Go for this. I think it has a great design. I can do most things from the top of my head. Code reviews are less painful. And I like that the language evolves more slowly and does not pile every crap idea on top of itself. I also know that a language doesn't have to fill every niche.. In the end Go is a productivity language. If you want to get stuff done it is an excellent choice. If you want to muse about the beauty or correctness of your code there probably are better choices.
- valenterry 6y agoI initially just wanted to let your post stay uncommented, but I also don't want people to get the wrong idea, so here is my comment to your last sentence: > In the end Go is a productivity language. If you want to get stuff done it is an excellent choice. Maybe for mediocre developers. And there are a lot of them and that is totally okay - everyone has been one at some point. But more experienced and developers who do their job with passion and strive to improve, will be limited by the language very quickly which makes them much less productive. Therefore, with good developers, go will reduce productivity in comparison to some other languages.
- fileeditview 6y agoWhat a nonsense. If you are limited by a language then maybe you just chose the wrong language for the job. I guess your argument about the vast ecosystem of go libraries and tools is that they are all created by mediocre programmers? Another note: most of us are "mediocre" and many of those who think they are somehow great, often turn out to be just "mediocre" themselves when put into a certain situation. And maybe you are truly a genius, only work alone and Go really limits you. You are free to choose whatever language you want. But don't project your outlier experience onto everybody or even onto teams of people with vastly different skill levels.
- valenterry 6y ago> Another note: most of us are "mediocre" and many of those who think they are somehow great, often turn out to be just "mediocre" themselves when put into a certain situation. Yeah I fully agree - there is nothing bad about that at all. But that does not change what I'm trying to say: once you grow more skills have more experience (which happens to most people), go starts to limit you a lot more than other languages. No "genius" needed. And it's not only me thinking that if you look at the other responses here. So, hype go as an easy language to learn? Fine by me! Hype it as a language that is more productive than others? I have to disagree.
- pjmlp 6y agoSurprisingly I have been getting stuff done 30 years before Go got invented, with more expressive languages.
- valenterry 6y agoI didn't say that I don't like go's design, but there are no features in go that justify the hype it gets. That's all. Rust for instance is not among greatest when it comes to language features either (the borrow checker is quite a thing though), but it combines lowlevel/performance with FP and language features that enable a high level of abstraction. I'm not really a Rust fun either, but that is a personal opinion and has nothing to do with my impression of if the hype is justified.
- csharptwdec19 6y agoNot person you're replying to but I'll bite. I think Go has some pretty good thoughts behind it's design. That is not to say that it is perfect by a long shot. Lack of generics is the main reason I've not actually tried to write any. But I've looked at some, and even helped debug a tiny bit. And that was the -nice- thing about it; the patterns are simple enough that you can learn it quickly. The drawback is that you have to write a LOT of code (or Interface hackery) to make complex things. And, on one hand, the syntax is still the same. On the other hand it's still more code to write. I think about C# a lot when I think about Go's simplicity; I'd argue there's a sweet-spot in C# where you COULD write code that is expressive and easy to understand but still more flexible. However, at this point there are 3.5 different ways I can think of off the top of my head to go through an Array/List in the language. In Go there's usually not too many ways to do the needful. That's an advantage for newcomers, but the proverbial ceiling isn't glass; it's hard iron, and you can't go above it.
- higerordermap 6y agoDude it is not because mathematical obsession or something we dislike Go. Consider checking whether an element `e` is in collection xs JS: xs.includes(e) Python: e in xs Java: xs.indexOf(e) != 1 C++: std::find(xs.begin(), xs.end(), e) != xs.end() It is already pretty verbose in C++. Go: contains := false for _,x := range xs { if x == e { contains = true break } } Some fanboys claim Go is readable. Readability is not about conveying what each line does in micro level, it is about conveying __Intent__. Go is nothing more than C as far as facilities to convey intent are concerned.