6 ms·
This is really a ridiculous article if you can call it that. "iPhone won't play patent- and DRM-free formats like Ogg Vorbis and Theora." Why do I care that a
by axod 18y ago
This is really a ridiculous article if you can call it that.
"iPhone won't play patent- and DRM-free formats like Ogg Vorbis and Theora."
Why do I care that a few cents of the price of my iPhone went in licensing the mp3 format from "Thomson Multimedia and Fraunhofer IIS-A".
As a user, it plays mp3 files. Which is all anyone cares about.
If it only played DRM files I'd have a problem with it and wouldn't buy it.
Looks like there could be a long wait for the new iPhone in the UK as it seems to be pretty scarce.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoI have quite a few ogg files. Converting to mp3 before using on an mp3 player is very annoying. Plus, libogg is BSD licensed, so why not include it?
- axod 18y agoit'd be a nice to have, sure, but I don't think it's a deal breaker. Majority of people are likely to have mp3s. It's nice not to add too much complexity and potential for bugs/issues...
- chrisbolt 18y agoBecause it doesn't have a chip to decode ogg, so it would have to use the main CPU which would quickly drain the battery.
- jrockway 18y agoMaybe. I have Rockbox on my 4G iPod, and the battery lasts plenty long playing Ogg (and FLAC) files. It may be an hour shorter than MP3s on the stock firmware... but you only pay for what you use. If you don't have Ogg files, you don't drain the battery.
- jws 18y agoogg has not been legally tested. The developers read through what they believe to be the relevant patents and declared themselves clean, but no one knows what those patent holders think and what patents may have been missed. Only when a company with deep pockets releases ogg vorbis in a high volume device will we see who is waiting to come out of the woodwork and start a patent suit. For the tiny and shrinking set of people that want ogg vorbis, it isn't worth the legal risk. (Sidebar: I don't mean to imply that vorbis is vanishing now, but as storage gets cheaper I expect mp3, aac, and vorbis to drift away in favor of lossless formats which are not subject to the body of psychoacoustical patents. I rip at 192kbps AAC or 256kbps mp3. Lossless encoders end up around 750kbps. I never fill my 8G iPhone. Using lossless on a 32G device would be a no brainer decision.)
- gommm 18y agoamen to lossless support on the iphone, I'm tired of reencoding my flac files