3 ms·
But your counterpoints (drugs & junk food) are trivially disproven: for a lot of people, those are truly "worth it". Why, I still remember an argument I had her
by the_af 6y ago
But your counterpoints (drugs & junk food) are trivially disproven: for a lot of people, those are truly "worth it". Why, I still remember an argument I had here on HN, years ago, where I said real homemade burgers were way better than McDonald's, and had more than one people reply to me with "nah, sometimes I really want a McDonald's burger, I really enjoy them".
As for prostitution, you have to admit such a long tradition of existing -- the "oldest profession", as the saying goes -- is strong evidence that it's indeed worth it to a lot of people.
I'm not making a moral argument, by the way. Only your own personal convictions, or your religion's, can tell you that.
- lmm 6y ago> But your counterpoints (drugs & junk food) are trivially disproven: for a lot of people, those are truly "worth it". Where's this trivial disproof? Citation needed. > You have to admit such a long tradition of existing -- the "oldest profession", as the saying goes -- is strong evidence that it's indeed worth it to a lot of people. No. It's strong evidence that a lot of people momentarily decide to pay for it. That's not at all the same thing, because addiction exists and is fundamentally not a phenomenon of rationality. A lot of addicts explicitly recognise that the thing they crave won't, and doesn't, make them happy.
- the_af 6y agoCitation needed? I take it you don't trust my word? Because I provided one. As for your second point about addiction: you are entering the realm of the highly subjective, randomly deciding which things are addicting and which are worthy. I'm uninterested in that discussion. How do you even determine which things are capable of bringing people long term joy and which aren't? Are videogames worthy? Are movies? Is the fleeting less worthwhile than the permanent? Etc.
- lmm 6y ago> As for your second point about addiction: you are entering the realm of the highly subjective, randomly deciding which things are addicting and which are worthy. I'm uninterested in that discussion. How do you even determine which things are capable of bringing people long term joy and which aren't? Are videogames worthy? Are movies? Is the fleeting less worthwhile than the permanent? Etc. I'm not saying you have to agree with me about which things are or aren't worthy. All I'm claiming is that it is possible for something to be addictive and not worthwhile, and so to show that something is worthwhile you need to do more than showing that someone was willing to pay for it. Do you disagree with that much?
- the_af 6y agoYes, of course it's possible. However, in this case the evidence points to the contrary. Here's how I see this discussion so far: "But is sex worth it if you pay for it, or do you later feel it was a hollow experience?" "Well, prostitution's huge success points to the answer being: yes, it's worth it to a lot of people" "(Tangent about the nature of addiction and worth)" That's all there is to it, really.
- lmm 6y agoIt's not a tangent. It directly refutes "Well, prostitution's huge success points to the answer being: yes, it's worth it to a lot of people".