44 ms·
> There's no choice in a democracy but to have something like the pardon power. Not necessarily. IIUC the American President's pardon power is based on the Bri
by triceratops 6y ago
> There's no choice in a democracy but to have something like the pardon power.
Not necessarily. IIUC the American President's pardon power is based on the British monarch's pardon power. The role of President was conceived (consciously or unconsciously) as an elected, non-hereditary monarch. He had many of the same powers - veto, commander of the military.
> Not having a pardon power allows bad judges to throw anyone they don't like into jail with no recourse by anyone.
That would require every judge in every court up to the highest court to be bad.
- yyyk 6y ago> IIUC the American President's pardon power is based on the British monarch's pardon power. Perhaps, but there are parallels in other democracies. >That would require every judge in every court up to the highest court to be bad. Technically, only the highest court would need to be bad, and it can order the others around.
- salawat 6y agoActually, it's merely a prerogative granted via holding the role of the Chief Executive. You get discretion to enforce or grant amnesty etc, because it's your job to set the priorities. The pardon power, however, was never traditionally treated lightly, as it's use practically guaranteed you'd be right ticking off a potentially very large swathe of the populace by upsetting the smooth operation of the other branches. It was a check, undoubtedly, but one best used only wisely if for no other reason than to reassure the populace there was a commitment to faithfully executing the laws of the land, rather than everyone being at the mercy of a capricious and unstable tyrant/nepotist/other type of person you wouldn't want to see in the highest position of authority in the country.