2 ms·
> If the Constitution says "Congress shall make no law..." and Congress still makes a law, what are you going to do, throw Congress in jail? That's nonsense. W
by hammock 6y ago
> If the Constitution says "Congress shall make no law..." and Congress still makes a law, what are you going to do, throw Congress in jail? That's nonsense.
Well.. you could depose them. Or declare independence from them. That has happened a few times in history.
The Constitution is a social contract. The people say "we'll give you (government) these abc powers, if you promise to use them this xyz way." When that contract is broken, no one gets thrown in jail - its rather more severe. The legitimacy of the government is called into question, or dissolved.
- kelnos 6y agoIn an ideal world, yes. In our actual world, the Constitution was ratified by a very small number of representatives from the population. And those representatives were drawn from and selected by white male landowners who owned some minimum threshold of land. IIRC that counted for less than 10% of the people living in the proto-US.
- hammock 6y agoSo your solution is to throw Congress in jail? Or do you have another proposal?
- kelnos 6y agoHuh? How are you reading that in my comment? I explicitly think that throwing Congress in jail would be silly, and actually unjust. But I didn't at all address that. I was merely pointing out that the US's "government for the people by the people" was laughably not at all that back when it was founded. "The people" didn't give the government abc powers; a single-digit percentage of them did. Beyond that, suggesting that an armed insurrection could ever be successful at deposing the US government... that's a silly fantasy.