4 ms·
>Bear in mind that the Constitution was written in a context where the governed people successfully held their government accountable at the business end of the
by krapp 6y ago
>Bear in mind that the Constitution was written in a context where the governed people successfully held their government accountable at the business end of their hunting rifles.
No they didn't, look up Shay's Rebellion and the Whiskey Rebellion as examples. The US government has never been successfully "held accountable" at gunpoint.
- ColanR 6y agoI was referring to the American Revolution. The 'holding accountable' was the revocation of Britain's authority over the colonies.
- joshuamorton 6y agoIn what way was the British Government "held accountable"? British leaders in Britain weren't held accountable, and many of the eventual founders were high level bureaucrats in the British government of the American colonies.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoThey lost the territory and all of its resources that allowed those within it to eventually overtake their status as the world's most powerful nation.
- joshuamorton 6y agoNote that in the broader context the claim was that we should throw politicians in prison, or face punishment for doing illegal things. Britain as an entity certainly faced consequences from US independence, but they didn't behead the queen (which *did happen 20 years later in france).
- ColanR 6y agoIt seemed pretty obvious to me when I wrote the original content that I was referring to the American revolution as the 'holding Britain accountable'.
- joshuamorton 6y agoPerhaps, but I don't think that they were punished. The difference I'm getting at here is subtle, but it's the difference between declaring independence and replacing the existing government. Both happen through revolution of some form, but one breaks away from a government you dislike. THat's not punitive. One replaces it and usually punishes the old one. Declaring independence from a distant seat of government is vastly different and vastly easier than trying to overthrow the local government.
- ColanR 6y ago"held accountable != "punished" or "punative". I'm not talking about punishment or punative action. I'm talking about accountability, where being 'held accountable' could be a synonym for 'held responsible'. In this case, the way I used the phrase, Britain was 'held responsible' by simply being told to 'go away'.
- joshuamorton 6y agoBut being "held responsible" and being "held accountable" are very different. Holding someone responsible means to blame them. Holding someone accountable means giving them consequences. Many people blame the government for all sorts of things. Only a very small number of those things is the government ever held accountable for. I agree that many people blamed the British Government for their problems, indeed that was the impetus for the revolution, but accountability of the British government was limited to none.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ColanR 6y ago
- boogies 6y agoOne terrorist at least disagreed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oklahoma_City_bombing#Impact_according_to_McVeigh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oklahoma_City_bombing#Impact_a..., and considering his arguments context (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruby_Ridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruby_Ridge) I think there was a grain of truth to his claims (though they don’t justify killing babies of course). (The Oklahoma City bombing was the biggest terrorist attack next to 9/11 and yet never discussed in any history class I’ve taken, while the latter is discussed in virtually every class on any subject on its anniversary. Probably an interesting reflection of xenophobia (probably among other things) I think.)
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>The Oklahoma City bombing was the biggest terrorist attack next to 9/11 and yet never discussed in any history class I’ve taken No government sponsored curriculum is going to open the door to the very tough questions that the first two parts of that trilogy naturally raise. It's the same reason people are never taught about the Indian wars or Jim Crow south except that "they existed". If people learned about how many times the government straight up violated treaties it signed and how many times state governments intentionally used the forces at their disposal to disenfranchise blacks then people wouldn't trust the government. The career arcs of the kind of people who think these things should be learned don't tend to put them on the committees that set state curriculum.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoLook up when those events happened vs when the Constitution was written.