3 ms·
It's an eighteenth century document that can be maddeningly vague at times. A lot of people (on HN at least) seem to think it's a problem that the First Amendm
by krapp 6y ago
It's an eighteenth century document that can be maddeningly vague at times.
A lot of people (on HN at least) seem to think it's a problem that the First Amendment only applies to Congress, letting companies like Google or Facebook censor speech as much as they like.
The Second Amendment isn't even written in complete sentences, and we need a room full of scholars to figure out just what exactly they meant by "A well regulated Militia,"
The Third Amendment just seems absurd in the modern day.
Maybe we don't need the Electoral College?
Maybe the President's powers to draft executive orders and pardon people undermines the legislative and judicial branches and should be done away with, given how often they've been abused?
It must be possible to have a more efficient census than through the process required by the Constitution.
It should be possible, in a nation of immigrants, for an immigrant to run for President.
There is no Constitutionally guaranteed right to vote. Amendments related to voting, yes, but nowhere is voting considered to be a right, as opposed to a privilege.
Do we really need to explicitly make the justice system an exception to the Thirteenth Amendment and banning slavery?
That's all I could think of off the top of my head, not being a constitutional scholar. But it stands to reason that a document as old as the Constitution should be updated more often than it has been.
- ed25519FUUU 6y ago> Maybe we don't need the Electoral College? As someone who designs distributed systems for a living, I can say very confidently that the electorate system is a very good idea indeed. Why risk the entire system if a single small part is corrupted?
- ihumanable 6y agoYou could still let the states run the elections and remove the Electoral College. All the redundancy with none of the downsides of the Electoral College.
- jessaustin 6y agoIn a simple majority system, a close result will entail a nationwide recount. With the Electoral College, recounts are only necessary at the state level. Smaller tasks are easier and faster.
- lifeformed 6y agoWhy is ease of recounting prioritized over fairness and accuracy?
- jessaustin 6y agoThe Electoral College is neither unfair nor inaccurate. Also, eliminating it would require a constitutional amendment, which could only be proposed by 2/3 majority votes in either the Senate or in a hypothetical "Article V" convention and then passed by 3/4 of the states. So, this reform that supposedly hurts small states requires two levels of approval from small states. That ain't happening. Protests against Electoral College are a distraction from possible and substantial reforms, like ranked-choice voting and ending interstate crosscheck and similar disenfranchisement efforts.
- ColanR 6y ago> stands to reason that a document as old as the Constitution should be updated more often than it has been That constitution was based off of about 2000 years of legal and political theory stretching back at least as far as the Roman Republic, and even the Greek democracies, and written with most of the intervening political history in mind. To say that 200 years makes that much of a difference needs a lot more justification than "it stands to reason". People say technology is a factor in why we should update the document: I would respond that the human nature which necessitated the clauses assembled in that document haven't changed. Technology has simply accelerated the negative (and positive) effect of the same human tendencies the constitution is already attempting to protect against. I would suggest that the maxim that's been mentioned on here recently, "don't tear down a fence until you understand why it's been put up" would apply. And the understanding of why the constitution is the way it is requires a breadth of reading that includes Seneca, Plato, and many others. Not to mention the documented discussions between the folks who wrote it.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThe founders wrote reams upon reams of text discussing the issues of government. We know damn well what they meant by things like "houses, papers, and effects" and "shall not be infringed"