2 ms·
"What's the smallest laptop you can get that has a real number pad, with its own enter, +, -, x, and / keys?" An arbitrarily-small laptop of your choice, up to
by jerf 16y ago
"What's the smallest laptop you can get that has a real number pad, with its own enter, +, -, x, and / keys?"
An arbitrarily-small laptop of your choice, up to and including cell phones, plus one of these: http://www.amazon.com/Targus-PAUK10U-Ultra-Mini-Keypad/dp/B00008NG7N/ref=pd_cp_e_1 http://www.amazon.com/Targus-PAUK10U-Ultra-Mini-Keypad/dp/B0...
Not good enough? Tack a few more keys on and sell it for $30 instead. But I would be quite sure the average student would be happy to use the keypad and on-screen buttons for sin, cos, tan, e^x, and the two or three other things they actually use in school. For that matter most kids are going to be fine with the cell phone as-is, which, I might remind you, also frequently has dedicated numeric keys and enough other repurposeable keys to get you quite a ways.
(Still not enough keys? Try turning on num lock on your netbook's keyboard. Most still have them. Then bind the other keys to useful functions. It may not be optimal but with only a bit of practice it probably won't be a stopper. The keyboard is your slave, not your master.)
Yes, this won't permit very fast entry, but you and I (mmm, sweet sweet RPN) are not the norm. Go look at your average TI-82 user; IIRC, they are hunting and pecking those keyboards anyhow.
To be honest I swing the other way myself; eliminate them entirely. But at least 15 years ago when I bought my HP-48G for very similar amounts of money I was actually getting something. If we are going to be turning out these calculators, they ought to be $30, not $130.
- kenjackson 16y agoThere's no Mathematica app or equivalent for the iPhone?
- dfox 16y agoIt is not only about keyboard, but about general user interface. It's probably highly subjective, but Ti-89's OS is probably only CAS that I have ever seen that is really easy to use (at least for me). But on the other hand, while I used to have some kind of calculator always at hand, I mostly eliminated that recently as to minimize amount of stuff I'm carrying around and use my smartphone (Python on Symbian is pretty good approximation of scientific calculator, modulo some input problems) or random REPL windows instead.
- wtallis 16y agoWhy buy a netbook and an add-on keypad if the user interface is still going to be the bottleneck? The CPUs in current generation calculators are fast enough for basically any undergraduate use case. (With better software, the HP's 75Mhz CPU would be able to keep up with any computation task that makes sense for a device with a small screen.) Yes, they ought to be a lot cheaper, but I think your target of $30 isn't quite realistic. Good keyboards aren't cheap, and neither are chips with power consumption low enough for running off AAAs. Certainly, if you want a high-contrast high-resolution screen and a lot of RAM, you'll be looking at a lot more than $30.
- jerf 16y ago"Good keyboards aren't cheap... high-contrast high-resolution screen... lot of RAM..." You want those things. I do not disrespect that. It sounds like you are a serious user. But you're asking students who will effectively throw these things away when they are done taking their remedial college math courses to spend $100 for those things. Why should they do that? Also, we are talking TI, not HP; as I recall those keyboards sucked 15 years ago and I doubt they got better. Even then, the TIs felt like toys where my HP felt like a real tool.