12 ms·
Yeah, health insurance in the US is kind of the opposite of insurance. It covers every-day expenses more-or-less but effectively will not cover unexpected larg
by aidenn0 6y ago
Yeah, health insurance in the US is kind of the opposite of insurance. It covers every-day expenses more-or-less but effectively will not cover unexpected large expenses (because the insurance companies will put the full force of their legal resources into not paying large claims).
- duxup 6y agoThat greatly depends on the type of insurance / plan (or at least it did...). Cheaper plans absolutely apply to what you describe, or at least did a while ago, other plans do not. Even knowing can be hard. But your description is way too general.
- aidenn0 6y agoAll 4 employer provided health insurance programs I've used worked that way, though only the last two were post ACA.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThat’s not true at all. Other than ACA mandated well visits and vaccines, insurance forces you to pay for everyday expenses via deductibles and copays until you reach your out of pocket maximum. And then insurance will take over for large expenses. And by and large, they do pay for the largest expenses, such as medications for anemia and cancer treatment and NICU situation.
- learc83 6y agoThat isn’t true at all. It used to be true because health care plans had lifetime limits to coverage, but the ACA removed those limits. The ACA also ads out of pocket maximums. They might still be high enough to cause problems for some people, but it’s a lot better than it used to be. As far as not paying, your chances of them just deciding not to pay are low. It’s definitely not high enough to support your claim that they effectively don’t cover large expenses. Here the ACA also helps because insurers are forced to spend at least 80% of premiums on healthcare costs and quality improvements for customers.
- jeffbee 6y ago> your chances of them just deciding not to pay are low What's your data on that? The US government says that private insurers deny 20% of claims. Last year my insurer tried to say that it was medically unnecessary to get an MRI after I'd had a tumor removed from my brain. You see, I'd also had an MRI before the surgery and according to the quack on the insurance company payroll who "reviewed my case" more than 1 MRI in a year just can't be justified. Your chances that an American health insurance firm will deny your claim, or at least attempt to, are very high. Virtually all of the staff at these firms are dedicated to not paying claims.
- mywittyname 6y ago> The US government says that private insurers deny 20% of claims. Most insurers deny every claim. Hospitals employ pretty large teams (of nurses, mostly) whose job it is to go through these denials and justify the medical care a patient received while in the hospital. If the insurance company doesn't think the treatment was necessary, they won't pay. If they can find a technicality, such as, a patient came in for a belly ache, but had a heart attack, they won't pay. I'm willing to bet this 20% figure only represent denied claims not absorbed mostly, or entirely by the hospital. I've been pushing the person whom I get this information from to write a book, because most Americans are completely ignorant about how fucked the health insurance scheme is in the US. That $6,000 asprin on your hospital bill is there to cover all the aspects of your treatment that the insurance company will successfully deny.
- learc83 6y ago>The US government says that private insurers deny 20% of claims. 20% are denied at least once, not 20% are never paid. There's a lot of gray area in what is medically necessary, and there's a lot of outright fraud. Plus many claims are denied because someone didn't fill them out correctly, deductibles weren't met, premiums weren't paid etc... The back and forth is part of the process. It's not great but... > more-or-less but effectively will not cover unexpected large expenses This is completely unwarranted. >Your chances that an American health insurance firm will deny your claim, or at least attempt to, are very high. Virtually all of the staff at these firms are dedicated to not paying claims. Some amount of the 20% denied first time are fraudulent, so assuming you have a legitimate claim, you have a less than 20% of them denying something the first time it's submitted, and a much smaller chance of them refusing to pay eventually. >Last year my insurer tried to say that it was medically unnecessary to get an MRI after I'd had a tumor removed from my brain. You see, I'd also had an MRI before the surgery and according to the quack on the insurance company payroll who "reviewed my case" more than 1 MRI in a year just can't be justified. Did they eventually pay? Did your doctor think it was medically necessary, and did you refile?
- poulsbohemian 6y agoExcept that it doesn't even really cover every-day expenses... Yes, if you have a catastrophic event it will kick in, but realistically if you are a healthy person, you are paying hundreds per person per month for coverage, plus will pay out of pocket for most of your care in a year before hitting that $5K+ deductible. It's simultaneously too expensive to not have insurance AND too expensive to go to the doctor. I'll never quite understand why I have to pay out $XXX for a blood test that might give me preventative feedback about my health, yet once I finally get heart disease, cancer, diabetes, etc, magically the health system and health insurance system kick in. The whole system is perverse.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> It's simultaneously too expensive to not have insurance AND too expensive to go to the doctor. Because healthcare is too expensive for Americans. Adding insurance doesn’t make the healthcare stop being expensive, it just helps distribute the costs more evenly across the population. Like universal taxpayer funded healthcare would. In order to bring healthcare costs down, the supply of healthcare and number of sellers of healthcare in the market would need to increase.