2 ms·
Isn't this exactly what some of those twin studies have done? Looked at pairs of identical twins where one was adopted into a family of wildly different socioe
by nostrademons 16y ago
Isn't this exactly what some of those twin studies have done? Looked at pairs of identical twins where one was adopted into a family of wildly different socioeconomic status?
Anyway, the article (and the studies) did say "Over the long term", as in leading into adulthood. While I'd have trouble believing that being raised in a bad inner city ghetto has no effect on your adulthood, I wouldn't have trouble believing that many intelligent, hard-working kids (the ones who don't get shot, at least) manage to escape the ghetto.
I'm reminded of something I've often heard about homeless people. People can end up homeless for all sorts of reasons, most of them not their fault. But the ones who stay homeless are almost invariably mentally ill. If you have the coping skills of a normal human being, homelessness is a rather unpleasant few months that you can eventually put behind you. But if you don't have those coping skills, that's when it becomes chronic and you get stuck on the streets.
Also the studies did say only 40-50% of the variation was attributed to genetics. The other 50% is peer group. People generally have a tough time going friendless, yet that's often what's required to escape a bad situation.
- jerf 16y ago"Isn't this exactly what some of those twin studies have done? Looked at pairs of identical twins where one was adopted into a family of wildly different socioeconomic status?" I know there is a non-zero number of such studies, but I don't know how many there are vs. relatively similar socioeconomic situations, nor do I immediately know where to go to answer that question in any reasonable period of time. Info welcomed.