4 ms·
Make cars people want.
by edw519 18y ago
Make cars people want.
- josefresco 18y agoIt's kind of tough to succeed when your workers (with the same skills) get paid 2-3x what competing car companies pay. Profit margins are just as important to a company's success as demand. See Internet math of the late 90's for a perfect example of what 1000000 * 0 equals.
- edw519 18y agoProfit margins are just as important to a company's success as demand. On what planet? Wanna buy a buggy whip, a cassette player, or a 5.25" floppy disk drive? All marked up 100%, but still good prices.
- jcl 18y agoYou wouldn't happen to have better examples? These only reinforce his point -- which alternately worded is: "Demand is just as important to a company's success as profit margins".
- edw519 18y agoYou wouldn't happen to have better examples? No. These weren't "examples". They were caricatures. Because the statement is absurd. What difference do your margins make if no one wants to buy your stuff? We're all so good at tech and so used to eyeball driven apps that it's easy to lose sight of the single most important fact of business: sooner or later someone has to be a customer. I never entered the "labor vs. management" debate here because it's a complex issue that won't easily be resolved here (or anywhere else). Instead I offered a play on pg's "Make Something People Want," slightly modified for Detroit. I don't know whose fault it is (nor do I care), but face it: hardly anyone wants Detroit's cars. They've delayed the inevitable by bolting 4 door bodys onto pickup truck chasses for 15 years now without preparing themselves for $4 gas. Duh. Look out your window right now. After the first 100 Camrys, Accords, and Altimas drive by, do you see anything from Detroit that you'd rather have? Neither does anyone else. That's Detroit's biggest problem, so I'll restate my original, they need to "Make Cars People Want". I know this is Hacker News (thus the questioning about the applicability of this post). We must not forget that the business aspect is just as important as the tech aspect. No matter what your other financials are, without demand, you have no sales. Without sales, you have no business. Then all of this is just one big hobby.
- jcl 18y agoOK... It sounds like you are actually in violent agreement with josefresco's statement that both demand and profit margin are important. :)
- edw519 18y agoOf course they're both important. No accountant could possibly argue with that. But that's not what josefresco said. He said that profit margin is just as important as demand. I say it's not. Nothing "violent" about it. A huge corporation has violated the most basic business rules, including perhaps the biggest, "Make something people want." And we debate about it. But if GM was a web app and this was a "How do you like my app" posts, we would be shredding them here. You lost 75% of your equity in one year?!? You have no small cars to sell?!? We'd be telling them to go to barber college.
- hugh 18y agoThis debate is getting silly. Is profit margin more or less important than demand, or just as important? It's a meaningless question. If you have a nice fat profit margin but nobody wants to buy your product, that's no good. If you're selling lots of products but making no profit on it, that's no good either. But if you're like GM, and you're selling millions of units a year, each for tens of thousands of dollars, and you're still not making a profit, I think we can diagnose the problem as being in the margins, not in the sales. Seriously though, if you want to go on a whine about how bad American cars are, I suggest the comments at autoblog.com which are suitable for that kind of inanity. But for this site, I have to say that the sales figures don't support the idea that demand for GM cars is small.
- hugh 18y agoI should clarify: actually GM's problem is not that their sales are low or that their gross profit per vehicle is particularly low either -- their problem is that they have enormous fixed costs (including, but not limited to, pensions for retired employees) which makes them particularly susceptible to small sales downturns in a way that many other car companies aren't.
- jrockway 18y agoMaybe the car companies should try the XBox business model. Sell the cars at a loss, then only let them use special gas that is massively marked up. For $7.99 a month, you can have "airbag live gold" which automatically deploys the airbags during a crash. A great idea!
- mynameishere 18y agohttp://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=GM http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=GM Revenue (ttm): 180.41B 180 Billion dollars revenue suggests to me that they already understand the basics of the auto industry.
- edw519 18y agoFrom your own link: Stock Price History: 52-Week Change: -74.19% I wonder if their owners would agree with you.
- hugh 18y agoWhich is to do with their financial situation, not with their sales. Sales are down slightly, but GM still sells more cars than anybody on Earth (except maybe Toyota, I haven't kept up with the sales figures for this year). Every time they sell a car, it's because somebody has decided they want the GM product instead of any of the many other products they could have. There are weak spots in their product line (especially not having a decent entry in the small car market for the US) but their problem is that they have massive debt, not that their sales aren't strong.
- edw519 18y agoWhich is to do with their financial situation What could possibly matter more than their financial situation? Honestly, ownership actually paid management to lose 75% of their equity in one year? That's only a little better than playing the lottery. especially not having a decent entry in the small car market for the US What else is there now? Don't you think it's been management's responsibility (maybe their biggest one) to forecast the price of gas? Who does it affect more? This is like saying, "Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how did you enjoy the play?"
- hugh 18y agoWhat else is there now? I'm looking at a list of the top ten cars sold last month. Four models were small cars (Corolla, Civic, Cobalt and Focus), four were mid-to-large sedans sedans (Camry, Accord, Altima and Sonata) and two were big trucks (Ford F-Series and Chevy Silverado).
- albertcardona 18y agoThey didn't. Instead, they took market protectionism from the government, and lived (unhappily) in denial.