5 ms·
What is the practical* justification / value of knowing the name of every air traveler? Literally how is safety in any way increased (or any other benefit obta
by gumby 6y ago
What is the practical* justification / value of knowing the name of every air traveler? Literally how is safety in any way increased (or any other benefit obtained for that matter) for anyone, either traveler or non-traveler.
I can’t even reason about cost or burden to benefit trade offs without knowing a benefit, and I have never seen any clearly stated. Just vague handwaves (“obviously this makes us safer” or circular justification.
* I am not asking for legal justification, which is itself unclear as explained elsewhere on John’s site.
- mschuster91 6y ago> What is the practical* justification / value of knowing the name of every air traveler? Literally how is safety in any way increased (or any other benefit obtained for that matter) for anyone, either traveler or non-traveler. Having a giant government database that documents precisely the travels of all citizens. This can be cross referenced to put names to de-anonymize cellphones and SIMs that have been bought in cash.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoI figured the idea was to join the list of travelers with the list of people who have somehow been red-flagged as a terrorism risk. Your physical scanning will fail some fraction of the time, your electronic system will fail some of the time, but it’s less likely that they will both fail. I’m not saying I agree with this idea - perhaps a dedicated attacker could get around both systems. And I haven’t put much thought into the downsides of this system, so I don’t have an opinion of whether the tradeoffs are worth it.
- jgust 6y agoWith the ease and prevalence of identity theft these days, it seems almost trivial to do for any determined actor.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoPresumably the facial recognition system described in this post is meant to help address that issue.
- dahdum 6y agoIt's another layer of security, raising the difficulty and lowering the chance of success.
- liability 6y agoThe premise is somebody might be so dangerous they can't be allowed to fly, but simultaneously so innocent there is nothing the government could arrest and convict them for. It's total bullshit. The politicians who created this system should be prosecuted for subverting the constitution, but there is no conceivable way for that to happen.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoI’ve read articles about how the government will engage in elaborate sting operations to entrap people with some level of extremist sympathies into participation in terrorist plots [1]. From that perspective, it isn’t the case that the government will instantly throw someone in jail if they suspect them of being a potential terrorist. It wouldn’t be a good look if one of these people went and actually did some terrorism while the government was busy constructing the fake terrorism to convict them. An intelligence agency can probably figure out that someone is associated with terrorists before evidence is available to convict them beyond reasonable doubt. Maybe it’s even appropriate that the legal standard to get secondary physical screening during air travel is lower than the legal standard to get thrown in jail? I welcome any opinions on that question - I feel it’s in the background of the original post and this discussion. [1] https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/terror-or-entrapment/Content%3foid=12242075&media=AMP%2bHTML https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/...
- liability 6y ago> Maybe it’s even appropriate that the legal standard to get secondary physical screening during air travel is lower than the legal standard to get thrown in jail? No. That's a subversion of due process and politicians who support such systems are enemies of the American people.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoIt does seem a little odd, to me. If somebody tries to bomb a place, and the government screwed up the chain of custody on the evidence, of course they shouldn’t be imprisoned (see cases like Mapp V. Ohio). In addition, they have a right to a trial by a jury of their peers. Throwing someone in jail for years is the most severe of civil rights violations if unwarranted, justifying a very high standard of evidence. Perhaps the evidence our suspect bombed a plane wasn’t quite strong enough for “beyond reasonable doubt”, but they did lose a civil case from the victim’s families under “preponderance of evidence”. Whence cometh the opinion that “beyond a reasonable doubt” must be the standard of evidence before someone is searched before boarding a plane? When attempting to board an airplane, where different levels of physical screening take different amounts of time and resources to perform, and it’s not practical to fully screen everyone, we ought to apply the same legal standards of a criminal conviction to differentiate different levels of screening? Even if there’s “clear and convincing” evidence the person bombed a plane before, we ought to let them through anyway without even patting them down? Do we need a jury of peers at the ready at every checkpoint to make this determination? Would you also apply this same standard before someone could be restricted from admittance to the halls of congress, to Fort Knox, or to a warehouse in a major city storing many tons of seized fertilizer? For reference, here’s a full list of the standards of evidence in the US, ordered from weakest to strongest: 1. Some evidence 2. Reasonable indications 3. Reasonable suspicion 4. Reasonable to believe 5. Probable cause 6. Some credible evidence 7. Preponderance of the evidence 8. Clear and convincing evidence 9. Beyond reasonable doubt https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burden_of_proof_(law) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burden_of_proof_(law)
- throwawayffffas 6y agoIt's law enforcement over-reach, by requiring identification on all flights they make air travel an unappealing option for wanted people at the expense of everyone else. It does not make anyone safer, just their job easier.
- eanzenberg 6y agoFlying used to be a great way to escape a crime that was just committed. By knowing the name and id of every traveler, we can stop criminals from fleeing their crime scenes.
- gumby 6y agoBut if they have just committed a crime the system wouldn’t know to look for them, would it? However assuming that it takes a while for the suspect to decide to skip town, it’s perhaps useful. The next question is whether it’s worth spending the money on these machines, hiring people to run them, and inconveniencing the innocent travelers (presumably 10^9 X the number of perps collared) is worth the occasional arrest. Ignoring false positives of course. And especially when there are plenty of other ways to skip town. I have a separate problem with scope creep. But thanks for suggestions use case that can actually be considered. Is this reason ever used as a justification for the TSA?
- liability 6y agoComing soon to a dystopia near you: cars that won't start until you let it scan your drivers license. Just think of all the criminals using cars to flee the law!
- gumby 6y agoAnd buying groceries, to stay alive while evading the authorities. Can’t be too says, you know!
- pfortuny 6y agoNext of kin.
- JoshTriplett 6y agoThat's a reason for the traveler's benefit; if that were a reason, it could be entirely voluntary on behalf of the traveler.
- mLuby 6y agoIt's so they can check to see if you're on a list of wanted criminals, which is already the job of many other government agencies. It doesn't have anything to do with the transportation safety; that's what the bag and person searches are for. TSA should be identity-agnostic. Leave IDs to Immigration.
- maest 6y agoAre names a good identifier to key on for those purposes?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mushbino 6y agoIt's not. One of my friends has a name somewhat similar to a person formerly suspected of terrorist activities. His first and last name are both different from the actual suspect, but his email is kinda sorta close. He gets detained and questioned for hours every time he flys.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoHas your friend applied for a redress number from TSA/DHS? https://www.dhs.gov/redress-control-numbers https://www.dhs.gov/redress-control-numbers
- ViViDboarder 6y agoWell, if they removed checking identities as it doesn’t relate to “transportation safety” they’d likely just replace it by a check from one of those other agencies.
- gumby 6y agoBut why?
- TheGRS 6y agoI'll state that I think the cons currently outweigh the benefits with most TSA practices, but the justification is verifying that you are who you say you are. AFAIK this is the only area we do this sort of strict verification in addition to numerous baggage and personal item checks. Well I guess we also do this if you're going to see an important government official or visit the NSA headquarters or something. Where it gets hazy to me is why this is a security add anymore. There was an initial scare of vetting that all travelers weren't secretly terrorists waiting to pounce on the cockpit. So you secure the cockpit (good, simple add-on there) and you add in metal detectors and X-rays for weapons and contraband (literally what we were doing pre-9/11). You need a passport to get into the country, so it's not like they don't have a record or a means to monitor suspected people coming into the country. Just seems asinine that they continue to do the ID checks and x-ray your entire body at this point.
- jbob2000 6y agoAirport security is one of the vestigial organs of the military industrial complex. The purpose of these ID checks and X-rays are to drive funding to the companies that make these machines. Now that these companies are sucking on the teet of Uncle Sam, there will be incredible amounts of whining at any attempt to remove them.
- gumby 6y agoI get your point but it’s hardly vestigial: the military industrial complex is not just still around but thriving.
- changoplatanero 6y agoI got invited to do a tour of the CIA headquarters and the security was less strict than what the TSA does to let you into the airport
- rriepe 6y agoI don't think they're convincing us but the employees. We think of security theater as theater because we're sitting in the audience. But you need the actors on board too. The name list, which naturally gives lots of false positives because it's just a list of names, gives agents something to do. It fills their day and makes them feel the persistent threat. Instead of "nothing happened last month, hmm, or the month before that" they actually get a calendar full of things. It's a really terrible setup if you have the same name as a terrorist, but without it they literally are just Thousands Standing Around.
- an_opabinia 6y agoIt prohibits a secondary market for airline tickets without violating the law. Otherwise, it is unlawful in most US jurisdictions and for most things to prohibit ticket resales. Sometimes the reason is really stupid. Like with liquids, it's as basic as selling more concessions.
- oh_sigh 6y agoThat is a really stupid reason, because it doesn't make any sense. Why would the security agencies care how many concessions are sold? Why would airports provide free drinking fountains with bottle-filling attachments if there was some governmental conspiracy to sell more water? The much more likely explanation is that there is some threat where the neer-do-wells would use X oz of something bad to mess up a plane or the passengers. Maybe X=5 and it is to prevent lone wolf attacks. Maybe X=21 and the argument is they would need to get 7 bad guys onto the plane to do it, which decreases the odds significantly that it could be pulled off without security agencies figuring out the plan.
- 112012123 6y agoWell, the liquid ban was added because some terrorists were caught trying to smuggle liquid binary explosives onto airplanes (with the plan to mix them in-air, then detonate them). Some airports are repealing the liquid ban now that they've developed screening machines that can accurately identify the contents of water bottles etc.
- bsder 6y ago> accurately identify the contents of water bottles "accurately" -- rolls eyes. Put a small bottle of silicone lube in your carry-on and watch the slapstick. Apparently silicone lube comes up as a totally unusual color on TSA carry on screens. At least in Austin, TX--nobody recognizes it (I bet SFO wouldn't have this problem). I had 4 fairly small, young ladies mulling over a bottle that I had forgotten about (normally my luggage is totally air travel optimized but I had been doing a lot of driving travel with my wife and didn't do a good enough purge). I was like, look, it's under the limits, but just throw it out. I'm not in a hurry but I also don't want to be held up forever and miss my plane over an $8 dollar bottle of liquid. In spite of the quite obvious labeling, one of the young ladies decided to get a bit snippy and demand what it was. Erm. Okay. It's written on the side of the bottle, but you asked for it. So, I got to explain in excruciating and visceral detail in my rather stentorian voice that small women like her and her cohorts often need a bit of help when they attempt to have sex with someone who has an enormous dong like mine. THAT was the purpose of the bottle that has the words "sexual lubricant" emblazoned on the side. All four of the women blushed to the top of their ears. Quite a few people in line chuckled. My wife rolled her eyes with her "I'm so put upon" expression. They finally threw the bottle out and waved me through. At the gate board, a Good Ole Boy Texan--hat, boots, and belt buckle-stopped us with a full drawl "That was great and they so deserved that. How bout I buy y'all a beer?" It was a good beer.
- kxyvr 6y agoIf I recall, the requirement was put in place after TWA Flight 800 crashed into the Atlantic. Although the plane likely crashed due to wiring problems resulting in a fuel tank explosion, a variety of institutions blamed terrorism and Clinton wanted to be seen as doing something to prevent another disaster. Richard Clarke writes about this in his book, "Against All Enemies": https://viewfromthewing.com/42388/ https://viewfromthewing.com/42388/