4 ms·
>Yes, why? Because 1 person can kill the 100s of others on board really easily. That's not true of any other means of transportation. Edit: People keep sugg
by LatteLazy 6y ago
>Yes, why?
Because 1 person can kill the 100s of others on board really easily. That's not true of any other means of transportation.
Edit:
People keep suggesting you could achieve the same result by:
* Blowing up the security queue \ lobby etc
* Blowing up a train\bus etc
* Blowing up a stadium
But this doesn't seem to be true. It's actually a lot less true than I thought.
A 747 carries 450+ people. An Airbus A380 carries over 850 people. A terrorist can kill them all with a single bomb. Plus people on the ground if they're over somewhere populated.
Compare that to the 7/7 bombings: 4 bombs, all large, detonated on very crowded trains (and one on a bus). They managed to kill 56 people total. Partly this is because jets are full of jet fuel, partly it's because anyone who survives ground attacks gets medical attention. Partly it's because you don't have to free fall 30k ft as well.
If the same 4 bombers took the same 4 devices onto planes, they'd might well have killed 1000s of people.
It's a surprising difference in effect. I hadn't realised it was this big a difference. But it's very clear. Blowing up a crowd or a ground based transport system is much less lethal than blowing up a plane.
- alasdair_ 6y agoIf the reason for all this stuff is that a single person can kill hundreds of people, an obvious solution would be to only have the security procedures on flights of more than 100 people.
- LatteLazy 6y agoI think we already do. Small planes (2 and 4 seater) don't require any of this do they? And private plane's passengers (up to about 20) can pretty much drive onto the runway and go. It's only public, over 20 seater planes that have requirements. And that's right around the number where it becomes a tempting target...
- tpxl 6y ago1 person can kill 100s of others in the airport lobby really easily.
- LatteLazy 6y ago1 person might injure 100s with a bomb (in an airport lobby or a stadium or a train station etc), but most will survive because they will get medical attention rapidly and won't fall 30,000 without a parachute. The 7/7 bombings in London killed just 56 people (including 4 bombers) with 3 bombs in packed tube trains underground (plus a bus). Compare that to a half full 747 where you would get 100% casualties. And that's without crashing the plane into something... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7_July_2005_London_bombings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7_July_2005_London_bombings
- vkou 6y agoGetting a large bomb into the pre-security line at the airport is much easier then getting a small bomb onto a plane. Literally any asshole wearing a backpack can trivially do it. They don't even have to be smart, or lucky. And nobody's going to hijack another airplane to crash into something, because since 9/11, cockpit doors have been reinforced.
- LatteLazy 6y agoPer my link above, 4 well placed, large bombs used in london killed 56 people. That's the same as a 737 at less than a third full. Also, you should consider the lockerbie bombing: 11 ground casualties from an airliner that was blown up 31,000 feet above their small, spread out village. Now imagine the same thing, only over a packed park of London\NYC\Tokyo and from 5000 feet instead of 30,000... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pan_Am_Flight_103#Lockerbie_residents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pan_Am_Flight_103#Lockerbie_re...
- Proziam 6y agoIf a terrorist were actually strategic about maximizing damage they would always inflict far greater harm and never be stopped. You can fit probably 50lbs of tannerite (ammonium nitrate and some aluminum) and ball bearings into a large suitcase and walk into any airport lobby in the world. They would never need to make it past a single layer of security to reach a line with hundreds of people in close proximity. But then you could also do this with trains, large hotels during business conferences, etc. Any security expert will tell you that real evil isn't something you can protect people from. Fortunately, 99.9% of people aren't genuinely evil. Although, it does make it clear that these security measures aren't about us, they're about protecting expensive property and reducing their liability once we get into that property.
- trothamel 6y agoNot to mention thousands more on the ground.
- DennisP 6y agoThat's not so easy anymore, now that the cockpit doors are secure, and passengers know better than to cooperate. There have been several cases where passengers disabled real or apparent terrorists.
- wongarsu 6y agoDerailing a high speed trains typically kill around 100 people, which is about the typical passenger count for a 737.
- LatteLazy 6y ago100 tends to be the worse case scenario for derailments, usually on trains carrying 1000s, but I take your point. However, most derailments are not caused from onboard the train, they're caused from interference on track (usually negligence rarely intentional), so there would be little point checking passengers.
- occamrazor 6y agoDerailing a train is _very_ difficult for a passenger.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIt's pretty easy for anyone who can get on the tracks though.
- _jal 6y agoThis reasoning is a classic example of "we must do something; this is something; therefor, we must do it." You identify a danger, but do not tie the 'solution' of ID to how it mitigates the danger, what the tradeoffs are, and why it is a superior solution to other options.
- LatteLazy 6y agoNo one asked whether this was the right solution. They only asked why a solution is needed. That's a fair question, but it's not what I was asked :)
- gknoy 6y agoI think we disagree on whether a solution is needed, though. No one's going to be able to use an airplane as a missile again, since cockpits are locked. No passengers will sit idly by while someone with a knife tries to do something, and any benefit of securing planes is completely dwarfed by the giant crowd of vulnerable people in the not-yet-screened lines. Not only does this solution not solve the problem (unless you consider the problem to be "get re-elected" or "make my election contributors money"), but it centralizes vulnerabilities and makes any destructive event both more dangerous and easier to carry out.
- wlesieutre 6y ago> any benefit of securing planes is completely dwarfed by the giant crowd of vulnerable people in the not-yet-screened lines Sounds like a problem, we'd better start screening people before they get in line for screening
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoBut it is true of other means of transportation! Blow up a movie theater on friday (without pandemic), poison the air in a cruise ship, blow up a subway, and so on. Heck, do enough damage to the right section of highway during a busy time and I'm guessing you can do a number. Pretty much anywhere that can hold a large group of people is a place you can kill hundreds.
- LatteLazy 6y agoSee my comment below, it's actually very hard to kill people with bombs, even when you really pack them together and use multiple devices.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoPossibly, but that isn't impossible. The Oklahoma City bombing killed 168 people, after all. If I can come up with a bunch of situations that seem likely, I'm sure other folks can too. Folks that actually know how to do stuff and are motivated to do so.
- sjansen 6y agoCongratulations on being added to a bunch of government databases! ;-)
- IncRnd 6y agoThat makes no sense and is similar to saying, "more people can fit into a truck compared to how many can sit on a motorcycle, therefore show your ID to get into a truck." A person can kill hundreds or thousands of others, regardless of there being any transportation - thats MORE people than can be killed on a plane.
- throwawayffffas 6y agoYou could go through security without providing id. If I recall correctly that's the case in most EU airports I have been to. I have been asked for id only by the airline at the gate after security or by border control on international flights.
- leetcrew 6y agoa bomb in a major train or bus terminal would be similarly devastating. a regional jet does not itself carry many more passengers than a train or double-deck bus. the thing that makes planes special is that, if hijacked, they can be flown into a large building to cause many more fatalities. even if someone is able to smuggle a weapon onboard, this is considered to be much more difficult than it was in 2001.
- LatteLazy 6y agoInterestingly bombs in major stations are much much less effective. The 7/7 attack in London killed "just" 56 people with 4 devices used on packed transport systems. A single device on a 737 could reliably kill 150 people in one go. Bombs in crowded locations seem to be quite ineffective compared to bombs at 30k feet...
- leetcrew 6y agoI saw your other comment after posting this. I checked against a wikipedia list of recent terror attacks and I am mostly convinced. the only attacks with comparable death counts from a single bomb seem to be car bombs, which I gather are considerably more difficult to source material for and deliver in a developed country.
- LatteLazy 6y agoYeah, I always thought this too. Like, maybe planes are more "glamours" target that's slightly better in numbers terms? Then I commented here and had to back it up and the numbers are crazy. I'm a bit surprised governments have signed off on the increase in size from 747s (450ish) to A380s (850ish).
- zimpenfish 6y ago> People keep suggesting you could achieve the same result by: A single well placed and timed explosion on London Underground could easily take out 100s. Hell, Euston or Kings Cross on a Friday is the same. With multiple bombers, you get easily get into the 1000s. Plus if you pick your Underground target(s) sensibly, you could cripple a large portion of London's public transport for months. With 4 bombers in a football stadium, you could probably get 1000s without even thinking about it.
- LatteLazy 6y agoDid you read the rest of my comment? 3 such explosions plus another on a bus failed to get 60...
- zimpenfish 6y agoYes but they are not as crowded as stations - especially if there's a hiccup in the schedules; cf [1] and [2] [1] https://news.sky.com/story/thousands-of-train-passengers-stranded-as-all-lines-blocked-at-london-euston-11780331 https://news.sky.com/story/thousands-of-train-passengers-str... [2] https://london.web2ua.com/london-is-crippled-by-commuter-chaos-as-overcrowding-closes-kings-cross-after-thousands-of-rail-passengers-are-daily-mail-1894/ https://london.web2ua.com/london-is-crippled-by-commuter-cha...