4 ms·
In fairness, "systemic" is not well-defined, and it's routinely used as a weasel word. For example, if we're talking about police shootings of Black Americans,
by throwaway894345 6y ago
In fairness, "systemic" is not well-defined, and it's routinely used as a weasel word. For example, if we're talking about police shootings of Black Americans, and I invoke "systemic racism" to imply that police are prejudice against blacks in their killings and thus America is a racist ethnostate, you could point out that police kill whites and blacks at comparable rates when accounting for crime rates, at which point I would retreat to "'systematic' refers to whatever system is causing blacks to commit crimes at elevated rates, i.e., legacy of slavery and racism" which is probably correct but supports an opposite set of moral implications and solutions.
In my experience, people who are willing to be honest, precise, and consistent in their terminology tend to have more reasonable and productive debates. They can often agree on many things with the people who are supposed to be their enemies and the disagreements are more understandable. Notably, most Americans probably agree that this law is heinously unjust.
EDIT: People are fixating on the example and assuming that crime rate disparities are manufactured or a result of law-enforcement bias, but that doesn't hold up to the criminology literature, which controls for LEO bias in a number of ways, including by comparing data sources against victim surveys. So while it's fair to argue that criminologists are failing to account for something, we're not talking about ignorant people making stupid extrapolations. If we're going to go off-topic, then let's at least make it a productive, enlightening digression.
- frazbin 6y agoI'm not coming into this as an expert, but I smell a weasel in the phrase 'crime rate', because law enforcement is discretionary and also/therefore racist... I mean it is not by accident. There was a concerted effort to consolidate white power after the civil war, and police were always part of that. Divide and conquer.. restrict where they can live, police their neighborhoods, put them in jail. Criminalizing blackness and then calling 'blacks' criminals was literally and explicitly part of the plan. Obviously not part of everybody's plan, but it's a continuation of the devil's bargain in our constitution: loyalty from the south in exchange for chattel slavery in our city on a hill. It's disgusting but ofc history is dead people, we can choose to recreate these institutions or dismantle them... but... Being honest, precise, and consistent in your terminology isn't too helpful if you choose to ignore american history. 'Systemic' racism is the appropriate term because it must be understood as a whole for the parts to make sense. Your misunderstanding kinda illustrates this. Cause really the remedy for police killings and for high "crime rates" among "blacks" are in fact the same, and relate to the manner and amount of policing.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> but I smell a weasel in the phrase 'crime rate', because law enforcement is discretionary and also/therefore racist This is why homicide rates are useful. For most cases, it is pretty obvious a crime of some sort occurred.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoOkay, but you can't extrapolate homicide rate to find the rate of e.g. drug use. This is a complicated issue with many interwoven contributing factors. There's no one magic figure you can point to that explains or disproves everything.
- throwaway894345 6y agoIt doesn't disprove anything, but it puts the onus back on those who claim that the police are racist, that we live in a racist ethnostate, and that we've improved very little with respect to institutional racism since the antebellum period.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> it puts the onus back on those who claim that the police are racist, that we live in a racist ethnostate, and that we've improved very little with respect to institutional racism since the antebellum period. No, it doesn't.
- throwaway894345 6y agoYou're mistaken.
- hansvm 6y ago> but I smell a weasel in the phrase 'crime rate', because law enforcement is discretionary and also/therefore racist > This is why homicide rates are useful. For most cases, it is pretty obvious a crime of some sort occurred. Tldr; homicide conviction rates are subject to other artifacts and can't support either side very well without additional data. Law enforcement is discretionary not just in deciding what counts as a crime but in who they decide to investigate and other tactics employed. Not that this hugely affects any relative statistics, but the murder false imprisonment rate is estimated at 4-11%, and false imprisonment (as far as we can tell from subsequent DNA exhoneration and whatnot -- this might not be representative of all murders) disproportionately affects black people. Not that this necessarily says anything about broad crime racial statistics, but it could throw any direct comparisons off. More importantly though, 30-40% of murders go unsolved, and it's probably not reasonable to assume that distribution to reflect the distribution of successfully convicted murders (if for no other reason than the race<->income correlation). That's such a huge monkey wrench in any comparative statistics that murder conviction rates without any additional information don't strongly support either side of things.
- rirarobo 6y agoI would like to point out that there is a plethora of literature and research which defines and studies "systemic racism", not to mention many people who have spent their entire careers on the topic, and have done so while being "honest, precise, and consistent." The way you have worded your comment implies that those who use the term are doing so to weasle out of honest debate, and I think this is a very uncharitable characterization. Furthermore, the dialogue you've used to exemplify the debate does not seem to honestly reflect what any reasonable expert would actually say. At best, it's what a person might say if they were poorly informed and had an incomplete understanding of systemic racism. Really, this makes me question whether you are being honest with yourself about your own understanding of systemic racism, and the body of work upon which we draw when discussing the topic. I feel that if you had a more accurate understanding, your response to the parent comment would be quite different in its priorities, so I would highly recommend you reflect on this, and perhaps read a bit more deeply on the subject.
- throwaway894345 6y agoYou're conflating two distinct claims: * "Everyone who uses this term is arguing in bad faith" * "Many people who use this term are using it in bad faith" My claim was the former. No doubt many people use it in a precise sense, take care to define it well, and don't move semantic goalposts. But many do, and this is (in my opinion) a big reason why the debate around the term is so low-quality. > Really, this makes me question whether you are being honest with yourself about your own understanding of systemic racism, and the body of work upon which we draw when discussing the topic. How can I be "dishonest with myself about my understanding of 'systemic racism'" when I don't know what the claimant means by 'systemic racism'? What about asking someone to define their terms connotes disearnesty?
- rirarobo 6y agoI feel like you've misunderstood my point. It was not my intention to conflate those two claims, I assumed when reading your comment that you are referring to some subset of people, not all people. As I mentioned, the type of interaction you described sounded less like someone arguing in bad faith, and more like someone who is under-informed. Yes, many people are in fact under-informed on this topic, especially since many are learning about it for the first time as a result of recent events. Accordingly, I would expect that there are many more people fitting this description, than there are people who argue in bad faith. This on its own would be a reasonable explanation for experiencing low quality discussions. So, you could have originally replied with something along the lines of, "to be fair, many people have only just learned of systemic racism, and as a result, casual discussions on the topic are often low quality and just muddy any debate." But why focus on these low quality discussions in the first place? Don't they exist for nearly any topic? Are they really the highest priority when trying to have a constructive discussion? This was the main point of my comment, to point out that your reply focused on the existence of low quality discussions, and in turn does more to perpetuate the idea that "systemic racism" is not well defined nor well founded in general, than it does to contribute to better understanding. Rapind's reply also points this out, that very low quality arguments are similar to strawman arguments, and even if it wasn't your intention, solely focusing on them can actually hinder the discussion. If you acknowledge that better definitions of "systemic racism" exist, but you omit them and focus on poor definitions instead, you are contributing to the low quality of the debate yourself. In regards to being honest with oneself, I mean being aware of your own understanding and it's limitations. How would you describe the depth of your understanding on this topic? Do you have resources you can share with others so they can better understand what you mean when you discuss systemic racism? Perhaps you can recommend a favorite book or specific author that you think covers the topic comprehensively and in good faith? Do you feel like you know what an expert means when they're using the term, as well as the common misconceptions faced by non-experts? Are you asking yourself these questions before you ask them of others?
- coffeemaniac 6y ago> In fairness, "systemic" is not well-defined, and it's routinely used as a weasel word. For example, if we're talking about police shootings of Black Americans, and I invoke "systemic racism" to imply that police are prejudice against blacks in their killings and thus America is a racist ethnostate, you could point out that police kill whites and blacks at comparable rates when accounting for crime rates, at which point I would retreat to "'systematic' refers to whatever system is causing blacks to commit crimes at elevated rates, i.e., legacy of slavery and racism" which is probably correct but supports an opposite set of moral implications and solutions. Why would this support an opposite set of implications and solutions? Seems to me that you really cannot "control for" the legacy and current existing reality of slavery in the US, you have to abolish it entirely. Only at that point will we be able to even talk about controlling for the past effects it's had on the economic mobility of black populations within the country.