3 ms·
My now wife was a completely self sufficient mother of two living in one of the best school systems in our metro area. We had been dating for a little while an
by scarface74 6y ago
My now wife was a completely self sufficient mother of two living in one of the best school systems in our metro area.
We had been dating for a little while and were definitely in the “pre-engagement” phase but knew where things were headed.
We both were laid off when the company we worked for went out of business. She already had a job lined up making less, but she couldn’t afford to be without health insurance. I had a contract lined up making more. I promised her if she took the job, I could make up the gap and I did.
A few months later, one week after I proposed, my contract abruptly ended. She said, forget about the ceremony, let’s go to the courthouse, get married so I could get on her insurance. I found another contract shortly thereafter.
Six months later, I had a full time job, and her hours were crazy (tech support for a carrier) and my (step)sons were missing her and it wasn’t helping our marriage. We talked about her quitting and finding something with better hours for the sake of all of us.
Fast forward seven years later. We are both working and she is back to making what she was before we got married. The hours weren’t bad, but it still caused a commute and our youngest son was going through teenage issues. Again we decided for her to take a lower paying job closer.
The job paid less, but had good benefits. That allowed me to leave a full time job to take a contract to perm job that would let me lead two green field projects. It would be a great career booster.
Four years later, that led me down the road of having a job making $100K more. Covid hit, her job would have involved her being in the school system. We talked, and again, it wasn’t best for any of us for her to be exposed. She quit her job before school starts back.
Of course by now we have the big house in the burbs. Our lives and her decision to make herself completely dependent on me was based entirely on her trusting me and taking me at my word. On the other hand, there is a direct line to my current income from here supporting me. How is it right for her to be left on the street penniless when she would be in that position solely because she trusted me?
- 01100011 6y agoIs there anything I proposed which would prevent you from voluntarily supporting her after a divorce? Do you often feel that the highly specific situation you find yourself in should be the basis for laws applied without cause to the rest of society? If you have an arrangement like that, put it in a contract yourself. Don't ask the government to force me to live by your rules.
- scarface74 6y agoIf we are getting divorced, how willing would I hypothetically be of supporting my wife? If I “wrote a contract”, should we have changed the contract every time that we made a decision for both of our benefit long term? Do you often feel that the highly specific situation you find yourself in should be the basis for laws applied without cause to the rest of society? It’s highly specific for married couples to work together and make choices that benefit the household as a whole, but puts one at a financial disadvantage if they separate? That’s kind of a sad outlook on life and marriage. Yes, I am on my second marriage. I know the realities of divorce. Is it also highly unusual for one spouse to stay at home or take a lower paying job because it is beneficial to the family as a whole? (No, people go into education all of the time for just that reason). Is it very specific for one spouse to take a job just for the benefits while the other is able to make more by being self employed or starting a business? If a couple is not working together for the benefit of the family unit as a whole, something is wrong.
- 01100011 6y ago>If we are getting divorced, how willing would I hypothetically be of supporting my wife? Beats me. > If I “wrote a contract”, should we have changed the contract every time that we made a decision for both of our benefit long term? That should be up to you. I'm not trying to tell you what you have to do. That's the point. > puts one at a financial disadvantage if they separate Why is this a given? Your wife is still entitled to half of your accumulated wealth during the marriage. That's not what alimony is. Alimony is the continued support you are forced to provide. The examples you state are not a given and should not be the default assumption of a marriage contract. > If a couple is not working together for the benefit of the family unit as a whole, something is wrong. That's your opinion and should not be assumed by the state. Why is half the wealth accumulated during a marriage not restitution enough?
- scarface74 6y agoIf your spouse stayed at home supporting your family while you worked and built your career, but you didn’t accumulate savings early on. Your income stream is a marital “asset”. She helped you build that asset. Besides that “accumulated” assets are just that, “accumulated” over a span as your income increases. Would you be okay if you were 50/50 in a startup, worked hard early on and then when the other partner saw that the result of the early work was about to make a massive amount of money but hadn’t yet, they pushed you out, split the early assets and were able to enjoy the growth without you? Wouldn’t you feel entitled to the income stream? The stereotypical example is the wife working, while the husband goes to medical school and when they graduate, they leave the wife. At that point, they haven’t accumulated much in assets.