3 ms·
Too much mass... but if it is spinning maybe it can be bigger. Neutron stars spin extrodinarily fast. And what if the singularity forms in the core, but the s
by sandworm101 6y ago
Too much mass... but if it is spinning maybe it can be bigger. Neutron stars spin extrodinarily fast. And what if the singularity forms in the core, but the spinning shell remains outside to form an acretion disk of neutronium? Boom? Or does it heat/slow fast enough that the star just winks out into a bh?
- Retric 6y agoNeutron stars resist gravity due to the internal pressure just like planets and other stars. Which is why they end up spherical. Put a tiny black hole in any of them and you get the same issue as trying to build a house on thin air. The only way it could be stable is a tiny body which is supported based on the structural integrity of the material. This is why asteroids can have very odd shapes. PS: As to spinning, Neutronium really wants to blow up. Neutron stars are stable due to gravity and internal pressure. Start spinning them around a black hole and you just get a normal accretion disk
- sandworm101 6y agoWell, some neutron stars are spinning at a substantial portion of c, the record being 1/4 c. In an object the size of a city, that some serious force pulling against collapse.
- ben_w 6y agoThe event horizon is like a waterfall, only instead of water it is causality. To a first approximation (because time and space melting into each other in a wildly non-Euclidean environment isn’t something I can do justice to), unless the neutron star is spinning so fast it is a torus with a black-hole-sized gap in the middle, a black hole inside a neutron star will doom it.
- raattgift 6y agoThe horizon is not anything like hard surface. You can't stack things on top of it. The near-horizon exterior gets extremely dynamical when you put lots of matter there, and the result is almost always a lot less matter there and a bigger horizon area, typically within timescales comparable to the light-crossing time of the horizon diameter. Things really do fall into (rather than onto) black holes, even if some classes of observers might struggle to witness the details and even though it is tempting for ease of calculation or ease of theorizing to treat matter as being smeared onto the horizon rather than crossing through (and/or redefining) it. Stress-energy can find itself inside a black hole horizon with no noticeable local effects for some time. One could in principle collapse a perfectly uniform shell of ultrarelativistic matter around some victim, for example, such that the victim is inside the horizon -- that is, the victim's outgoing radio signals cannot reach the rest of the universe -- hours before the matter reaches the victim. Neutron stars require "signals" (QCD and other interactions) exchanged among its deepest components in order to stabilize the entire structure, and the system can find itself in a configuration wherein signals from region A cannot reach region B, so signals from B are wrong to stabilize region C and so on, and the result can be some combination of implosion and explosion. This doesn't fit well with the analogy of going over the edge of a waterfall. As to your neutron-star-matter torus around a BH, it's hard to contrive even a toy a stress-energy tensor where the generating non-interacting matter doesn't stray onto plunging geodesics, and I struggle to imagine how real interacting matter with inelastic collisions could be more stable. Another salient feature of even the toy version of such system is that there would be enough moving matter in the torus for it to be subject to self-gravitation. Consequently, you're into the task of combining at least a pair of substantially different metrics in the limit where you can't just linearize, resort to perturbation theory, or drop in a Darmois-Israel junction -- that is, you're into the realm of a full numerical relativity task and a full relativistic hydrodynamics task. A taste for what this involves can be had at https://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/181055/Core-Collapse-in-CFC_ https://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/181055/Core-Collapse-in-CFC_
- ben_w 6y agoIt sounds like you’re agreeing with my points, but being rather more precise in your examples? For example, waterfall of causality was meant as an analogy, a point of no return made of time rather than stuff, not a literal waterfall.
- whatshisface 6y agoEven classically, the spinning would pull apart the equator, but the poles would fall. You could get a disk of nuclear matter (add electrons and that's a galaxy) or a buzzing cloud where everything just misses the black hole as it orbits (like the stars in the galactic core), but if it's a solid mass with a continuous velocity field, the poles will fall in.
- Retric 6y agoThe largest observed angular velocity is 0.24c which sounds like a bigger issue than it is. The centripetal force from that is still significantly weaker compared to the 10^12 to 10^13 m/s^2 you get from surface gravity. You can largely ignore relativity at 1/4c so centripetal acceleration ~F=V^2/r. F ~= (0.24 * 300,000,000 m/s)^2 / 16,000m = 3.2 * 10^11 m/s^2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PSR_J1748%E2%88%922446ad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PSR_J1748%E2%88%922446ad Which means the Star has a significant bulge but the minimum and maximum surface gravity ends up well within the range for neutron stars. PS: I am sure someone has done a fairly detailed analysis of the forces involved but a quick search did not find anything.
- Aperocky 6y agoIt's about equilibrium, a sphere is a stable equilibrium, a spinning shell is not (plus, how does orbit on say 45 degree North work?)
- speeder 6y agoWhat you describe is actually a controversial thing. You are describing a "naked singularity", it doesn't matter what exactly is spinning, but the theory is: anything with a singularity in the middle, that is spinning fast enough, would become a torus, and the singularity would be exposed. Problem is, IF, those are possible (noone is sure yet), they create a huge problem for physics: as far as we know, singularities destroy information and what comes out of them is random, if naked singularities are possible, ANYTHING is possible, and if ANYTHING is possible, physics is meaningless. Seemly in the 70s Stephen Hawking gave a mindblowing talk about that, and Ringworld author was present on that talk.