4 ms·
Possible detection of a black hole with a mass thought to be impossible
- DrBazza 6y ago142 solar mass black hole: https://www.ligo.org/detections/GW190521.php https://www.ligo.org/detections/GW190521.php
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 3JPLW 6y agoYes, that was this event.
- jagger27 6y agoWell that was a silly bet. Of course we were bound to find something in between a just formed black hole and a supermassive black hole.
- 3JPLW 6y ago> Of course we were bound Absolutely, the question was only how frequently it happens. The bet was within the first 100 detections — with one side only saying they're rarer than that.
- betterunix2 6y agoIt was less "should not exist" and more "should only form when black holes merge," and apparently the "black hole mergers fill the mass gap" hypothesis is now supported by evidence. Nobody was claiming that there is some physical reason black holes of such mass could not exist, only that the best understood process of black hole formation should not allow for such masses (but other processes can).
- cgriswald 6y agoThe title is bad, but... > Chris Belczynski, an astrophysicist at Warsaw University, previously felt so sure that such a large specimen wouldn’t be seen that in 2017 he placed a bet with colleagues. “I think we are about to lose the bet,” Belczynski said, “and for the good of science!” LIGO has existed for decades and by 2017 had already detected a merger. My guess is he considered black holes in this range rare enough that we were unlikely to detect any. If he believed they were impossible the article certainly doesn’t elucidate on that fact.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 3JPLW 6y agoThis was a key feature of the bet. It's within the first 100 gravitational wave detections. They're betting against an unknown distribution. Neither side was saying that they wouldn't be found.
- gizmo686 6y agoIs there a sampling bias involved? I presume that different masses of black holes result in different frequency waves, and that LIGO is not uniformly sensitive to all frequencies. Depending on the actual numbers, this would make these intermediate sized mergers either over or under represented in our data.
- enkid 6y agoWould there be a reason we wouldn't expect these mergers to happen very often? I mean, LIGO doesn't detect black holes that often considering how much space it is surveying. Would there be time for the small black holes to accumulate into a large black hole?
- imglorp 6y agoLIGO only detects mergers, and then only in a certain low mass range. The article hints that these are most likely to happen in a star-dense area (duh, right?) like a nebula.
- thunderrabbit 6y agoWhy are LIGO and Virgo not mechanically capable of detecting the collisions of supermassive black holes? Is it because the amplitude is so big it "pegs the needle" above its limit?
- privong 6y agoLIGO and VIRGO are sensitive to gravitational waves within a specific frequency range. The bulk of GW energy is emitted at a frequency that is twice the orbital frequency of the objects emitting the gravitational waves. Supermassive black holes are sufficiently large that they merge before they could have an orbit compact enough to emit gravitational waves at high enough frequencies for LIGO and VIRGO to detect them. Less massive compact objects are smaller and so can reach higher orbital frequencies before merging.
- 7373737373 6y agoThere seem to be projects for lower frequencies/longer wavelengths underway: https://youtu.be/GlmMxmWHEfg?t=3733 https://youtu.be/GlmMxmWHEfg?t=3733
- thunderrabbit 6y agoCool!
- thunderrabbit 6y agoOh wow so it's exactly the opposite of my guess. Thank you for your explanation. It now makes perfect sense to me that more massive objects wouldn't revolve quickly enough to create high frequency waves.
- hatsuseno 6y agoYour reasoning is on the right track, but it's the wavelength specifically that's outside of the range for both Virgo and LIGO. As far as I understand the subject, we're running into physical limits for their detection using that kind of experiment. Instead, research is attempting to infer the mergers using pulsar Doppler shift measurements.
- mmazing 6y agoWhile this is interesting, the article and graph within are misleading and clickbaity. This black hole is big enough to fall into a mass RANGE that shouldn't exist, but isn't the largest found (which I feel the title of the article implies). Supermassive black holes are on the scale of BILLIONS of solar masses. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_massive_black_holes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_massive_black_hol...
- fastball 6y agoDoesn't really make sense that the range wouldn't exist either, unless I'm confused. Obviously black holes are colliding otherwise we probably wouldn't have supermassive black holes, so it doesn't seem unexpected that two smaller black holes would collide and form one bigger than the limit imposed by pair-instability supernova, except as a statistical improbability.
- graerg 6y agoIt's not clear how the gap between solar-mass scale black holes and supermassive black holes was traversed; was it a build up from small black holes, or did they start out as seeds of a few million solar masses in the early universe? What about the dearth of intermediate sized black holes (tens of thousands of solar masses)? Is this just because they are just hard to see to begin with, or is there really a gap? This is intimately related to the Salpeter time, which is how long it takes to grow black holes if they accrete at the Eddington limit, and can also be inferred from the quasar luminosity function. IIRC this favors the massive seed scenario, but there's no shortage of clever explanations around it.
- a1369209993 6y agoBlack holes get less dense as they gain mass - assuming I didn't drop a factor of 2 or τ, a 1 solar mass black hole has a density of 147 quadrillion tons per cubic meter. A black hole of 100 million solar masses had density of only 14.7 tons per cubic meter (for reference, lead is 11.3 Tn/m3 and osmium is 22.6 Tn/m3). So a sphere of 100M (actually >81M) solar masses of osmium would collapse into a black hole without even having to compress under it's own gravity first. You'd need 384 million solar masses for something with the density of water.
- merricksb 6y agoDiscussion about this article last year: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20819902 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20819902 However there is an update to the article posted today: [Update: On September 2, 2020, researchers confirmed [1] that the colliding black holes had masses 65 and 85 times that of our sun. The resulting black hole was 150 times more massive than the sun.] [1] https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.101102 https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.12...
- pantulis 6y agowhat's the reason for discarding a merger between, say, a black hole and a supermassive star? I guess then the wave signature would be different.
- Iwan-Zotow 6y agoWhat state that supermassive star would be? If it is red giant, black hole would dissasemble and strip it right away. For black hole gravitation pull red giants are just some gases in the neighbourhood
- ISL 6y agoYour guess is correct. The signature is very different. In order to reach LIGO's frequency band, the objects must be very compact. If they are too large, they touch before they can orbit each other at sufficiently-high (audio!) frequencies. The Schwarzschild radius of the black holes in question are less than 100km in size, while the size of a star as small as our Sun is ~700,000 km in size. Moreover, the compact objects (neutron stars, black holes) that LIGO can observe are exceptionally dense ( > 3x10^17 kg/m^3), while stars have roughly the density of water (1000 kg/m^3) on average, and much less at their extremities. Compact objects can disrupt nearby stars long before they could touch, spreading the "merger" across many, many years (many, many millenia, I suspect), rather than the fraction-of-a-second typical of a LIGO black-hole observation. For a visual image of the interaction of a large/fluffy star with a compact object, have a gander at a few of these images: https://www.google.com/search?q=roche+lobe+accretion https://www.google.com/search?q=roche+lobe+accretion
- proce55ing 6y agoDifferent binary body systems have been modeled and the gravitational wave forms are compared against experimental data. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fspas.2020.00028/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fspas.2020.0002...
- brundolf 6y ago> For cores with a mass between about 65 and 130 times that of our sun (according to current estimates), the star is completely obliterated [via a pair-instability supernova]. Cores between about 50 and 65 solar masses pulsate, shedding mass in a series of explosions until they drop below the range where pair instability occurs. Thus there should be no black holes with masses in the 50-to-130-solar-mass range. > The million- and billion-solar-mass supermassive black holes that anchor galaxies’ centers formed differently, and rather mysteriously, in the early universe. LIGO and Virgo are not mechanically capable of detecting the collisions of supermassive black holes.
- scns 6y agooff topic but still "Impossible is Nothing" by Divine Heresy for nerds who like Metal: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFeoVCFdQ6k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFeoVCFdQ6k
- moralestapia 6y agoIs there an "upper" limit on the mass of a black hole? I would guess "no" but then again I'm not a physicist, maybe there's a surprise down the road.
- proce55ing 6y agoThe Eddington limit constrains the absorption rate of a black hole, but through mergers there's no theoretical upper limit.
- ptspin 6y agoAside from the useless limit of "all the mass in the universe"
- garmaine 6y agoNo. In fact, the entire observable universe is a black hole: the Schwarzschild radius of the mass of the observable universe is greater than the observable size, meaning by the technical definition of a black hole we are living within one: light from Earth sent into the darkest region of the sky will not escape the gravitational pull of the whole universe, even before considering expansion rates.
- ptspin 6y agoThe Schwarzschild radius for the mass of the observable universe is about 13.7 Billion Light Years while the observable universe is about 93 Billion Light Years across (radius ~46 Billion Light Years). So the universe is not itself a black hole (until you take expansion rates into account)
- garmaine 6y agoI think you have that backwards--you have to take expansion into account for the "observable" universe to be that large, since the age of the universe is only 13.7 billion years.
- browsergap 6y agoI don't get it. Saggitarius A at Milky Way center is 4 millions times Sol mass. So why is 100 impossible?
- wizardforhire 6y agoI’d like to point out and give props to this article for providing a picture of the actual hand written bet that led to this research! Humorous and rarely shared in science articles and gives some great context for the personalities involved! <3s!!!
- ncmncm 6y agoWhen two black holes with a near-circular orbit and similar size merge, they should both be going close to the speed of light about their common center shortly before the merge. (Right?) Do close orbits tend to become more, or less, eccentric? After the event horizon surfaces contact, does it become spherical in minimal time, or does it keep a complicated shape for an extended period? (E.g., until gravitational waves carry off enough energy?) And does the very large rotational momentum affect properties of the resulting black hole?
- Enginerrrd 6y agoI'd think binary systems made up of similarly sized objects where the orbits are in some sense "close" are almost by definition not eccentric. To get to that point from a previously eccentric orbit they convert the eccentricity to spin. Check out this out for an example with neutron stars: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-JZBmgOEfdo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-JZBmgOEfdo As to the second part, I'd think it becomes axially symmetric in very minimal time. I don't have a good answer as to why, except that my intuition says the GW signature of blackhole mergers at the point of the merger has a frequency that appears to get infinitely fast as it radiates away the axial asymmetry.
- ncmncm 6y agoThank you. Searching for "Hypermassive Neutron Star" turns out to be very informative.