2 ms·
>In short, humans are really bad at evaluating risk, especially in our current media environment which is has a very low Signal to noise ratio. Isn't this just
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
>In short, humans are really bad at evaluating risk, especially in our current media environment which is has a very low Signal to noise ratio.
Isn't this just a nicer way of saying that the unwashed masses don't have the same priorities the experts want them to?
We live in a democracy, shouldn't social consensus do the lion's share of work in defining what is and isn't good risk assessment? If the overwhelming majority of people would rather be scared of a rare disease than a car crash then doesn't that kind of define what our priorities are even if guarding against the latter looks better on the metrics?
- michaelt 6y agoThere are some questions that are clearly questions of fact. For example, "Which killed more Americans last year, car accidents or terrorist attacks?" There are some questions that are clearly questions of opinion. For example "Should we spend more money on reducing car accidents than we spend on anti-terror efforts?" There are also questions that straddle the border - for example "Should lives shortened by pollution count as deaths caused by cars?" While questions of opinion are the domain of social consensus and democracy, it's not particularly elitist to say the purely factual questions need a right answer rather than a popular one.
- epistasis 6y agoNo, elitism or "unwashed masses" has nothing at all to do with this. It's about making decisions based on gut or based on better information. We have news media that works far harder to promote emotional culture wars than promote information transfer, and we have people succumbing to tribalism, and that has nothing to do with whether one is part of some sort of "unwashed masses" or whether they are part of elite decision makers that control what sort of propaganda/news/media that hundreds of millions of people see. Information isn't some sort of perfect market where people see what they like the best, it is hugely influenced by what people create and what influential people promote.