4 ms·
My observation so far is that I am no longer voting any comments up or down since there's no feedback. Usually I would vote up a comment that was good and that
by petercooper 16y ago
My observation so far is that I am no longer voting any comments up or down since there's no feedback. Usually I would vote up a comment that was good and that didn't have the karma I felt it "deserved", and vice versa. Without that "putting things right" motivation, I seem to have stopped. Interesting as I wouldn't have predicted that outcome beforehand..
What would be interesting, though, is if posts didn't show karma too. In that case, I suspect I'd be more inclined to vote because I wouldn't know how well a post is doing and if I thought it deserved to be on the front page, I'd vote it up. All comments appear in a thread, though, so there is little reason for me to vote them up.
- cooldeal 16y agoThat's exactly what happened to me as well. There's no easy solution to this. I think one of the best I've seen is how Slashdot does it, but it's probably too much work for pg
- bdclimber14 16y agoI think this has substantially reduced group-think though.
- jnorthrop 16y agoI've actually found my experience is somewhat different. I'm reading more comments now and voting more often. I imagine your comment, as it now stands after 11 hours at the top, has plenty of votes behind it -- previously I wouldn't have considered voting for it since it already had plenty of "momentum," now, I can't tell, so I voted. Conversely I'm less inclined to just vote for a low total post to "promote" it. At the end of the day I find I'm treating each post more fairly without the count displayed.
- maushu 16y agoI believe changing the arrow to a plus (or another symbol... circle?) that would change colors (highlight?) when clicked would fix the "no feedback" feeling.