3 ms·
We should have listened to Ted Nelson the first time around. For Nelson, hypertext is not just hyperlinked text. It's a permanent repository of text with hyperl
by bitwize 6y ago
We should have listened to Ted Nelson the first time around. For Nelson, hypertext is not just hyperlinked text. It's a permanent repository of text with hyperlinks and transclusions, both being permanent references, and DRM to ensure the rightsholders of linked/transcluded text get automatically remunerated whenever their work is downloaded/read, and a microtransaction system to enable such remuneration.
Tim Berners-Lee thought he could nick just the "good bits" from this model -- or rather, the low-hanging fruit, punting the tricky-to-implement stuff until later -- but you really need all of the parts, otherwise you will have a broken, half-working (if that) system with seams showing all over the place.
It's time to realize that Project Xanadu was the correct way to view hypertext, and compromising on that vision has cost us dearly.
- type0 6y ago> really need all of the parts, otherwise you will have a broken, half-working (if that) system WWW won exactly because it was half finished - extendable and not despite of it, otherwise we would all be using Gopher now.
- bitwize 6y agoIt's one of those things like C that seemed like a good idea at the time, and only with the fullness of time do we come to realize its bone-deep irreparable flaws... but now we're stuck with it effectively forever.
- type0 6y agoWorse, it isn't that we stuck with it, but the public have lost control to WHATWG (el Goog & the Gang)
- dacodanelson 6y agoI am actually working on a follow-up about Ted Nelson and Project Xanadu. I know it never really came to anything, but it's really fascinating the way this brilliant, Memex-like system was what all the visionaries were talking about, and what we got was a giant directory of pseudo-printed pages.