3 ms·
Abusing Open Records to Attack Academic Freedom
- jerf 16y agoBollocks. You joined the political fray, now you reap the results. Academic freedom is not condition-free; the tradition that demands "academic freedom" also says academics should stay out of what they ought to consider "mere politics". I read the original op-ed, and while this is selective quoting it is selective to prove my point: "Mr. Walker’s assault on collective bargaining rights... Mr. Walker’s conduct has provoked a level of divisiveness and bitter partisan hostility the likes of which have not been seen in this state since at least the Vietnam War... Scott Walker is not Joe McCarthy. Their political convictions and the two moments in history are quite different. But [McCarthy comparisons made anyhow]..." This is a very partisan piece. I could probably rewrite it without much work to be a much more neutral-POV historical piece with the same basic content, but as it stands now it is not neutral-POV. (In fact I agree with the underlying premise that the Republican party's priorities have shifted over time, but consider it uninteresting. All political parties shift over time; the further back in time you go, the less related to a modern party it is. Abraham Lincoln was a Republican, but... so what? It doesn't count as credit to the modern party, because they're only related via historical continuity, not by methods, persons, or platform. Democrats have shifted too, or should we pretend they are violating their core principles by not vigorously fighting for southern segregation?) Academic freedom is the freedom to be free of mere politics in the pursuit of your academic studies. It is not a blank check to participate in political discourse from a privileged position above all others, with a unique defense not available to the rest of us. You have chosen to step out of your academic shield and function as a citizen. That said, this is certainly a major overreaction from the Republican party. I don't see what they think they are going to get out of this. But this whole "I'm a noble academic under attack" is just BS, you simply do not get to run into a room, start lobbing "McCarthyite!", "Radical!", and a laundry list of other thinly-veiled plausibly-deniable political attacks worthy of any modern political speech writer around in a still-current political debate, and expect there to be no reaction from the political world. You jumped in with both feet. Stop whining. (And yes, I know the entire linked piece is itself just the next level of political game, and that, itself, is shameful. This is not how academics should behave.)
- MaysonL 16y agoActually, it wasn't the op-ed that occasioned the response, the Republicans launched their request prior to the publication of the op-ed. It was in respones to this blog post: http://scholarcitizen.williamcronon.net/2011/03/15/alec/ http://scholarcitizen.williamcronon.net/2011/03/15/alec/ about the The American Legislative Exchange Council.
- jerf 16y agoOK, that's even more nakedly partisan. Still an overreaction from the Republicans, but less of one.
- anigbrowl 16y agothe tradition that demands "academic freedom" also says academics should stay out of what they ought to consider "mere politics". Does it, now. I assume you're referring to the 1940 statement of principles, linked below. But your argument doesn't hold much water, since Cronon's comments are not made in the name of the U of Wisconsin or presented as teaching materials in his class. In expressing his personal views on politics, he can go as far as he likes. http://www.aaup.org/AAUP/pubsres/policydocs/contents/1940statement.htm http://www.aaup.org/AAUP/pubsres/policydocs/contents/1940sta... By the way, my support of his dual freedoms - to be an academic and also to express his political views - does not mean I agree with said views.