5 ms·
YouTube without YouTube Red is not worth the trouble. The YouTube Red / Google Play Music decoupling has me worried for the future of the product. I'm both ups
by echelon 6y ago
YouTube without YouTube Red is not worth the trouble.
The YouTube Red / Google Play Music decoupling has me worried for the future of the product. I'm both upset Google Play Music is going away and that it might risk YouTube Red.
- xmprt 6y agoThey're still investing heavily into YouTube Premium (no longer Red) now so I don't see them getting rid of it anytime soon.
- metiscus 6y agoIt's also still too early in the google ADHD cycle to kill it. Probably just reaching mid life at this point.
- google234123 6y agoNah, YouTube Premium makes sense. It's basically TY without ads. Why would that be too hard to maintain?
- xmprt 6y agoYou hit the nail on its head. Google usually discontinues products which have high maintenance cost so even if it turns out that YT Premium makes less money than people watching ads (and I highly doubt the average person watches more than $10 worth of ads in a month), they'll still keep it.
- adambyrtek 6y agoNot really, for example Reader had really low maintenance costs. In fact at some point it was maintained by some of its former developers in their 20% time with no official head count.
- metiscus 6y agoI think it is a side effect of what keeps google from turning into IBM. Ossification is a perennial problem for large corporations especially traditional growth companies. They make their few big things then iterate on them. The "ADHD" shown by google, while it is annoying to users to have a perfectly serviceable piece of software discontinued unceremoniously, probably keeps the internal structure from becoming rigid and failing to adapt. I think they are probably slightly too far over on the side of kill stuff and move on but I'm not a multibillion dollar company.
- CydeWeys 6y agoHaving zero headcount is the death knell for a project about to be cancelled. It only had low maintenance costs because the team was disbanded, presumably because it wasn't worth paying to maintain.
- google234123 6y agoThe story behind reader is more complicated than that.
- ulfw 6y agoIt’s Google. The level of investment isn’t correlated to the propensity for cancellation. Remember the most expensive ever Google product? Plus? Right...
- boringg 6y agoOr do you mean glass?
- google234123 6y agoWhat? I'm pretty sure Cloud, Geo, and Search have more total investment than Plus.
- tmpz22 6y agoPretty sure self-driving will be the biggest loss, theyll make money from it and have relevance but itll be way less than they put into it so early
- eru 6y agoDo you know how much money Google has ever invested in Waymo ever? I tried to search for a number, but couldn't come up with much. Obviously, this number would be very important in judging whether self-driving will be a loss for them.
- tmpz22 6y ago> Google had spent $1.1 billion on the project [1] The wikipedia also mentions Waymo raising ~2B and ~3b rounds that IIRC Google participated in as well. I'm surprised its so low honestly. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waymo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waymo
- eru 6y agoThanks. I should have thought to check on Wikipedia! If you are willing to wait and just judge by eventually realised revenue, Waymo might still turn out to be a loss. But if you judge by current valuations (which reflect informed investors best guess of future revenue streams), then even after a recent major decrease we still have 30 billions USD. That looks pretty decent for an investment of 1.1B + ~3B total.
- akurzon 6y agoHonestly I wasn't aware that Google Play Music was still around until I got an email telling me it would discontinued. I've been using YouTube Music since I signed up for YouTube Premium a few years ago, and I've been pretty happy with it.
- baskire 6y agoAgreed. Been debating switching to Spotify. But not having ads on YouTube has been amazing.
- eru 6y agoI've used both Spotify and Pandora for a while, and generally found Pandora superior.
- d3nj4l 6y agoYT Music is included in YouTube premium, you don't need to switch to spotify.
- mrweasel 6y agoIt seems to be the other way around for me. I could not buy Youtube Premium, unless I first signed up for Youtube Music.
- baskire 6y agoYouTube music sucks. Now that google play music is canceled. I either continue paying for yt red and stick with the worse music platform. I switch to prime music. Or I ditch yt and google music all together and use Spotify. I still don’t get why google deprecated me as a customer. Google’s churn is exhausting. Starting to want the “Microsoft” & “Apple” experience of it just works.
- Goronmon 6y agoI still don’t get why google deprecated me as a customer. Google’s churn is exhausting. I tend to attribute the product "churn" due to how promotions/raises are handled where releasing new products is heavily favored over maintaining existing ones.
- JeremyNT 6y ago> YouTube music sucks. Now that google play music is canceled. I either continue paying for yt red and stick with the worse music platform. I switch to prime music. Or I ditch yt and google music all together and use Spotify. I was worried about this too, but have you tried it lately after doing an import of your Play Music data? I've been a subscriber to Play Music nearly since its inception and none of the functionality I cared about seems to be missing from YT Music in its current form. Indeed there are a couple of YT Music features I am using occasionally (the lyrics for example). I think the impetus here is really just to unify all of their streaming content services under the YT brand, which if anything instills some confidence in me that they won't simply kill it off (Play Music was feeling like abandonware for a long time, being under the YT umbrella with an app under active development seems like an improvement). That said, there are plenty of other ways to get the actual music files. I treat this service as a way to discover playlists and new artists only, and if there's something I want to retain access to I acquire my own copy to ensure I will not lose access to it in the future.
- willis936 6y agoPlay music’s iOS app was riddled with bugs. The YouTube music replacement has all of the same features as play music with none of the bugs. The only regression is that to upload my own music I have to upload it to YouTube rather than a (supposedly somewhat) private personal library.
- mythz 6y agoI much prefer Google Play's UI & did not experience the "riddled with bugs" you speak of. Just because it has the same content does not mean it's the same App or offers the same UX, it going away does not make me happy. I've been with Google Play from the start and am more likely to switch now, if it weren't for ad-free YouTube I would have quit because of this.
- willis936 6y agoThe UI sucked and the app sucked. I’m glad google did something because the previous state of atrophy was unacceptable. It would have been nice if they simply maintained their services, but replacing them with equivalent ones is acceptable. Here is a list of the tiny sliver of the total bugs that I had experienced and knew off the top of my head six months ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22184669 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22184669
- james-skemp 6y agoUsed the Android version, but I agree Play had/has a much better interface. I know it's my age talking, but there are some people that still prefer to listen to entire albums. Make it easy for our kind to find albums, and then don't default to play a mix of singles after.
- brendoelfrendo 6y agoGoogle Play Music is being replaced with YouTube music, so it's not like Google is abandoning the product. It's more of a brand realignment.
- mrweasel 6y agoIsn’t it Youtube Premium now? For some weird reason Google sadly won’t let you buy ad free YouTube, unless you also have Youtube Music. I’m sure there’s a point to decision, but I don’t thing it has a basis in consumer demand.
- roel_v 6y agoI quite like the model - either you pay for Youtube or you don't. If you do, you get a bunch of stuff, some of which you might not use; but the total is still cheap, so who cares. I'd hate it if all-you-can-eat restaurants would make you decide up front if you want access to the desert buffet, too.
- rconti 6y agoFunny, every time I get an ad for YouTube Premium pop up at the bottom of my iOS client, the feature they tout is "videos keep playing in the background" which sounds like an anti-feature. I use "killing the YouTube App" as the most-convenient method of stopping YouTube videos because it's less work than dealing with the on-screen controls.
- josteink 6y ago> I'm both upset Google Play Music is going away and that it might risk YouTube Red. What do you mean? YouTube Premium (“Red” is a legacy name from waaay back) won’t go away. When Google Play Music dies, YouTube Premium will instead pay for YouTube Music (the new, “equivalent” service) which will still be around. Or am I missing something super obvious?
- surge 6y agoGoogle Play Music is being transitioned to YouTube Music, I already got migrated, and I'm now using and is fine/comparable to Play Music, just reskinned. The only annoying thing is its tied directly to my YT account, so all my playlists show up in YT too, but any music I play/like in YT also effects what it considers my preferences and its led to some odd stuff popping up in the personalized mixes. It is kind of neat that I can listen to anything that's been posted as a video. All that to say its not being decoupled, its being extra coupled. Your YouTube Red subscription comes part and parsel with YouTube Music since its the same thing.