3 ms·
I don't know whether PP algos work or whether they're fair or what the trade off between fairness and effectiveness should be. But I am amazed the number of co
by LatteLazy 6y ago
I don't know whether PP algos work or whether they're fair or what the trade off between fairness and effectiveness should be. But I am amazed the number of commentors here who think the devs behind the algos are not smart enough to normalise data for police numbers in an area!?
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoThis is HN, where everyone knows better than everyone else, especially in areas where they have no experience whatsoever.
- wdevanny 6y agoIt's a difficult problem area. I would bet naively normalizing the data would introduce many new concerns. Does the amount of crimes reported scale linearly with police presence? If not, your data is now going to be skewed. How do you count police numbers in an area? Man hours, individual officers, or something else? Keep in mind that not all officers are going to be responding to the same type of crime and so police hours are not interchangeable. IMO machine learning algorithms are brittle and prone to breaking in unexpected ways. In the past, organizations who should have known better and should have been smart enough have produced bad machine learning systems. Policing is a highly sensitive area. It's okay to be very concerned.