7 ms·
Recent work in philosophy has called into question the notion that the mind/cognition/identity is entirely independent from the body. https://plato.stanford.ed
by keiferski 6y ago
Recent work in philosophy has called into question the notion that the mind/cognition/identity is entirely independent from the body.
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/embodied-cognition/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/embodied-cognition/
Personally I think Western culture in particular has neglected the physical aspects of existence. The idea that our bodies are simply vessels for our minds seems more the result of cultural neglect than anything.
- dsiroker 6y agoWe are not claiming they are entirely independent, quite the contrary. The mind is an emergent property of the body. Just like music is an emergent property of sound waves.
- keiferski 6y agoBut if your mind and self is formed by and dependent on your body, how can you transfer it to a bodyless existence without losing that self? The mind as an emergent property of the body is also not an established philosophical or scientific fact, and is quite dependent on positivism, which has plenty of issues. It seems to me that at best, you’re creating a surface-level copy, but one inherently limited to contemporary scientific knowledge. Not to say that this isn’t interesting or useful, but it’s certainly not the same ‘self.’
- dsiroker 6y agoThe notion of self is an illusion the mind creates. (There are many benefits for doing so, not least of which is self-preservation which is helpful to producing progeny and so therefore is selected for during natural selection.) To answer your question directly: one can transfer an emergent property of a system to another system by sufficiently transferring the mechanism that produce that emergent property in the first place. A good analog would be emulating the hardware of the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) entirely in software [1]. [1] https://jsnes.org/ https://jsnes.org/
- keiferski 6y agoThe self is far more complex than the simplistic positivist notion of it. And again, this only works if you assume that at the time of the mind creation, your knowledge is complete. That seems fairly ignorant considering the history of science, not to mention the inherent limitations of empirical knowledge. The NES example is not really a good one because it’s a created object and knowledge of it is complete, therefore replicating it is possible. Even then, assuming all of this didn’t matter- I still don’t see how the mind maintains itself in a new body. It’s not as if a human mind is a static entity-it constantly comes into contact with the world through its embodied form and this reinforces and extends this notion of identity. Assuming you could emulate it on a computer, it would seem logical that the mind would change to adapt to its new body, thus no longer being the same self. Ultimately any “transfers” will actually just be the creation of new minds, which IMO is more interesting anyway.
- dsiroker 6y ago> The NES example is not really a good one because it’s a created object and knowledge of it is complete, therefore replicating it is possible. One could replicate the NES hardware without any knowledge of how it was built by reverse engineering it > Ultimately any “transfers” will actually just be the creation of new minds, which IMO is more interesting anyway. I actually agree but in the same way that you have a "new mind" when you wake up in the morning. The continuity of self is an illusion. "I" would be very happy to one day wake up having been transferred into a non-biological system the same way that "I" would be very happy to wake up tomorrow.
- keiferski 6y agoSure but the mind is reinforced by its constant embodiment. If you woke up in another body, or with no body, then that identity would seem difficult to maintain.
- simion314 6y ago>One could replicate the NES hardware without any knowledge of how it was built by reverse engineering it Not sure if one could do that if that person is not very familiar with similar projects. Give the NES system to a scientist from 1800 and tell me what they could conclude.
- jesselawson 6y agoThank you for saying this. It's always so strange to me that there are people obsessed with prolonging the inevitable, as if immortality itself could be an end-state.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoAll of life is prolonging the inevitable. This would seem to be an argument for suicide.
- joeberon 6y agoRecent? Buddha taught all this 2500 years ago
- Erlich_Bachman 6y ago> Personally I think Western culture in particular has neglected the physical aspects of existence. Do you mean eastern? The western culture is the one that has a lot of focus on the physical aspects and comforts of life. Arguably, many times too much focus on that which has been detrimental for many people's own psychological and spiritual well-being.
- keiferski 6y agoBy physical I meant bodily, as in, connected with the body. Our predominant mental model seems to be that our mind/head is the real person, while the body is just sort of an add-on. The intellectual is superior to the bodily; developing the mind while neglecting the body is completely acceptable (see: obesity statistics). And so on. This is mostly just a consequence of a society over-reliant on technology, I'd say.