5 ms·
What does the choice of "High Quality, Low Cost" look like in practice? (Because I'm not seeing how to make that happen, other than "burying the actually high c
by sokoloff 6y ago
What does the choice of "High Quality, Low Cost" look like in practice? (Because I'm not seeing how to make that happen, other than "burying the actually high cost someplace where it's spread out and hard to see, so it looks like low cost".)
- throwawaygh 6y ago> burying the actually high cost someplace where it's spread out and hard to see, so it looks like low cost "spread out" implies taxation, but something similar can be done via endowment. For example, a college with an existing $100MM endowment can educate at least a few hundred students for free in perpetuity. With a billion dollar endowment, a college can educate a couple thousand for free. In fact, Berea College does exactly this: 1600 students, 1.2 billion endowment, and provides effectively free college to nearly every student. Ranks alongside places like Denison University. So, Low Cost (to consumer), High Quality, but definitely not Universal (there are only so many billion dollar endowments to go around).
- Justsignedup 6y agoLow cost, available to everyone: the quality goes down as they need more capacity for less pay. High Quality, Available to everyone: Will cost a lot because we'd need a lot of high quality teachers, and attracting them will be expensive. Low Cost, High Quality: Only the best will get accepted, and the colleges will make their money in other ways using the work the students provide (like how medical school research departments are big money-makers)
- afiori 6y ago> Low cost, available to everyone: the quality goes down as they need more capacity for less pay. A partial solution to this is to simply shrink the spread of services the college/university offers. eg they could simply offer education and training.
- Justsignedup 6y agoWe had this. This was vocational schools. They were fantastic for most of the US. Focused entirely on just the skills you need for specific fields. Hair, Mechanic, Electrician, Plumber, etc. And they would be the perfect vessels for re-training when certain industries shut down. Interestingly enough: They were cheap and universal (because they were cheap).
- stevefan1999 6y agoelitism
- noetic_techy 6y agoWithout government backed student loans for literally anyone who wants it, you suddenly dry up the money for colleges. They are forced to compete on degree cost and quality alone, and degree ROI will likely start to get factored into the price. College used to be relatively low cost long ago and easily accessible to the middle class, even lower middle class. Yes, the colleges will be hurting and screaming if they took that money away but they did this to themselves. Their entire business model is based on never ending government subsidy, essentially free money. At this point it will require a reckoning but this is always the case when you set up systems like this with good intentions and bad outcomes. You see almost the same phenomena with Uber vs traditional taxi's. The government forced taxi's to buy medallions to operate a certain number of drivers because they didnt want the streets overrun with taxi's, with each medallion costing hundreds of thousands and even up to a million dollars in places like NYC. A taxi driver essentially had to have a second mortgage to operate. Along comes Uber and that whole government backed system gets crushed and starts to look ridiculous and artificially inflated in price. Yes, the taxi drivers got screwed, but it was the "good intentions" of the medallion system to keep the number of taxi's low that screwed over the consumer with higher cost rides compared to a market driven approach with companies like Lyft and Uber competing to the bottom. Let the market do the same for colleges. They have fancy campuses now. There have been other ideas where student loan ROI is factored in and the college themselves must cover the cost of the loan if your degree turns into a lower paying job and the percentage of your loan payment exceeds some percentage of your income. Either way they have skin in the game that's EXACTLY whats needed.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoThere are already very affordable college options - the reason many schools charge more is because of demand and exclusivity. This is another example of sensationalism. According to an article on Forbes -> "The average student loan debt for members of the Class of 2018 is $29,200" Is that really so egregious? Isn't it more likely that semi-skilled labor jobs disappeared increasing the demand to go to college for a good job? I don't think the loans are enough to justify the increase.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- renewiltord 6y agoStop guaranteeing student loans, permit universities to take a percentage of student filed tax for lifetime of student. Perfectly aligns interests of student and university: creates annual recurring revenue from all students, if student pays tax to IRS portion goes to university. Since US taxes world income, this ensures university is reimbursed. University will stop offering low quality degrees that do not offer utility and focus on current needs of economy.