2 ms·
> Employers are allowed to test students to see what they can do, but not evaluate them based on whether they went to school or where. This would never work. P
by Spivak 6y ago
> Employers are allowed to test students to see what they can do, but not evaluate them based on whether they went to school or where.
This would never work. People who went to high-prestige schools want to signal that to their employer and when barred would find other ways to signal like "Interned in Dr. Blah's group at the MIT media lab" or "Secretary of the Princeton chapter of the Phi Beta Kappa."
> Make student loan debt dischargeable in bankruptcy.
This is a fine solution iff you want to make the market exclude all academic endeavors that aren't high-probability profitable. This would basically destroy all specialized scientific research, education degrees, agricultural science, all high-level maths, biology, ecology, zoology, environmental research. When people want the market to decide these thing I imagine they think that "those silly liberal arts degrees" is what will get cut but forget that science doesn't pay either.
- jefftk 6y ago> "Interned in Dr. Blah's group at the MIT media lab" or "Secretary of the Princeton chapter of the Phi Beta Kappa." Both of these are about what you have done, and not what you can do. I'm proposing limiting interviews, at least entry-level ones, to relevant skills, abilities, and knowledge. "Read this judicial decision and tell me whether you think it was correctly decided and why." etc. > destroy all specialized scientific research, education degrees, agricultural science, all high-level maths, biology, ecology, zoology, environmental research The government should fund students in these directly, as we do with grants in graduate level education.
- philwelch 6y ago> This would basically destroy all specialized scientific research, education degrees, agricultural science, all high-level maths, biology, ecology, zoology, environmental research. Why? All of these fields existed prior to student loans becoming non-dischargable. As it stands, in many fields there is a massive grad school bubble where there are many more grad students and Ph.D’s than tenured positions. As for education degrees, those have the same basic instrumental role as engineering or business degrees—they’re a form of professional training and accreditation. A lot of minor public universities started off as teachers’ colleges in the first place.