3 ms·
Those are very wide search requests. There is no reason to think that more specific geofence requests would also be thrown out is there? There is another quest
by LatteLazy 6y ago
Those are very wide search requests. There is no reason to think that more specific geofence requests would also be thrown out is there?
There is another question here too: with more complex analysis like this, what is a good definition of a geofence? A 45min window around a busy intersection might catch a few 1000 people. But would the same geofence be OK if it was combines: who from intersection A in window1 was also at intersection B in window2? Presumably that would be OK if the number of people caught was lower compared to the number of criminals sought, and it would be much lower.
Finally, people should note that that data legally belongs to the company not the user. If Google agreed to cooperate (as mobile phone companies do) it would be entirely legal for all the data (and more) to be turned over and used, no questions asked.
- baybal2 6y agoWhy somebody even cares about that when PRISM is still up, and running?
- LatteLazy 6y agoAgreed. Until that is sorted, all this is just a weird little dance we do to distract from the fact the room is on fire...
- salawat 6y agoThat is far from a settled question. Third Party Doctrine has a built in escape hatch test of how destructive and pervasive surveillance method is to the public interest in not being subject to unreasonable searches. This is the fundamental territory of that escape hatch. It doesn't matter if it's "private". If it is too gratuitously invasive, it should not even be on the table.
- ViViDboarder 6y agoIn the article they state that they did try to reduce the window size as well but the court deemed it still too large. It’s possible that there is some size small enough to justify though. The real problem here is that most of these rulings are sealed with no defendant. So it’s great that we had a judge looking out for the public here, but it is apparently far from the norm.