4 ms·
Is that even legal? I thought the US or most states at least like most other countries have laws against undermining the ability of employees to organise.
by Barrin92 6y ago
Is that even legal? I thought the US or most states at least like most other countries have laws against undermining the ability of employees to organise.
- scarmig 6y agoHah. In the US, there are laws, but their effectiveness depends on enforcement. Additionally, there's an entire industry of employer-side law firms focused on union busting, who advise employers on how to do as much as possible without crossing the legal line or getting caught when doing so.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI would be curious to know what European labor laws are like. I'm also curious about what kinds of tactics these companies resort to which are sufficiently legal. Can anyone recommend good labor books?
- ciceryadam 6y agoGenerally you need to have a minimal number of employees that form the committee of a new union. You register at the Court, inform your employer. Anyone who wants to be represented by the union can join you. The employer must inform you about organisational changes / salaries / etc. You can add your union to a confederacy of unions, biggest of which has a place at the tripartite table during Labor law updates - so it's the state, employer groups and labor unions deciding about yearly wage increases.
- scarmig 6y agoTo paint the American landscape a bit more, the majority of what are called "union avoidance" activities are legal: since employers are employing the workers, they have a captive audience, and use that to the full extent of their ability, usually with the help of outside legal consultants. A lot of what goes on is surveys, videos, forced informational sessions, etc. Much of it can be compared to targeted public relations. Even when an employer stays within the full bounds of the law, they're usually substantially advantaged over the labor organizer: full information about the workforce and a captive audience goes really far. So where do the violations of law come in? A lot of it comes from very murky, subjective boundaries: employers can't threaten to shut down a plant or time wage increases in a way to interfere with a union organizing campaign. But a lot of what union avoidance specialists' work involves is consulting at exactly how to do the above in a legal way. It will end up in court, and if the consultants did their job right, the employer will win. Beyond that, you get into activities like firing workers purely because they're involved in union activities: here the labor avoidance consultants will sometimes help with building a paper trail to target workers viewed as problematic. Another illegal activity is spying, either on union meetings or workers and organizers when they're off premises. Oftentimes, employers want to do this on their own volition, and union busting consultants actively work to curtail this (or at least make sure any firings happen in a legal, documented way).
- lordofgibbons 6y agoIf you've ever worked in retail, one of the first "training" videos they show you is an anti-union informational video. One of the big points of the videos is to report union organizers to management ASAP. This kind of training is extremely common for low wage jobs in the U.S. If almost all large retailers are doing it, it mustn't be illegal, or not enforced.
- jwilber 6y agoSaw these videos during my first job (cart attendant at Target). This behavior happens at every big company, both in and outside of tech. I remember the video being incredibly weird - they basically posited unions as bad because nonmembers would feel socially isolated from member. Eg - in one clip two workers would be gossiping about info from a members-only meeting and the moment a nonmember walked up to them, they became quiet and it turned into this strange teen drama.
- ksrm 6y agoFound an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6bFEs4ZoXw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6bFEs4ZoXw
- notJim 6y agoThe House has passed a bill [1] that would make it illegal to make these meetings mandatory, btw. Obviously won't pass with a GOP senate, but could happen if the Dems manage to retake government. [1]: https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/2474 https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/2474
- fortran77 6y agoYes, but you can "track" it. It's the actions you take against it which may be constrained by law.