3 ms·
I don't buy the argumentation of the article. It centres around 'opinion power' the ability to set a political or cultural agenda and steer democratic discourse
by Barrin92 6y ago
I don't buy the argumentation of the article. It centres around 'opinion power' the ability to set a political or cultural agenda and steer democratic discourse, and argues that holding platforms accountable makes them more legitimate wielders of opinion power, which the author claims is a mistake.
I think there's some things wrong with this. First off I don't think Facebook or Google exercise a lot of opinion power, in particular given their dominance. Yes, the article is right to point out they support climate change action, or fight certain internet regulation, or gay rights but this is very, very mild, often non-partisan civic stuff and often just financial self-interest.
I don't see Facebook or Google going around wielding the power of legacy media over politics, having a clear political slant in how they operate, or whatever. They mostly stay out of it, again probably for business reasons.
More importantly though I think the article romanticises smallness, citing Barlow's cyberspace independence, advocating for less concentration, transparency and so on. It's the usual anglosphere-centric argument. Just give people transparency and get rid of all the big bad guys and the enlightened citizens of the cyberspace will find their way out of it, nothing new about that.
I don't think this is realistic. People will use large social networks and platform giants because they provide the best service, they're not going to dig through transparency reports or statistics about algorithm influence, and this means corporate responsibility is necessary. The author may not like it, but large firms are the principal actors in our society, and they need to be held accountable, even if that gives them a seat at the table.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]