3 ms·

Github: Goodbye Priorities

42 points by lucahammer 16y ago

steipete 16y ago
I second the priorities feature; it gets more important as the project grows and more "noise" is added to the tracker. We'll see how the otherwise in every way better Issues adapts to it. e.g. https://github.com/pokeb/asi-http-request/issues https://github.com/pokeb/asi-http-request/issues is now sorted after creation date - really not the best way to sort the list.
curiouscats 16y ago
I agree, without the ability to easily prioritize the features I will have to abandon github issues. It was also extremely lame to "upgrade" everyone to version 2 and lose all the data the users had put into their issues for the priority order.
- tosh 16y ago
  It sounds like you should be able to recover the priorities using their API https://github.com/blog/831-issues-2-0-the-next-generation#comment-11400 https://github.com/blog/831-issues-2-0-the-next-generation#c... but I agree that the decision to upgrade everyone immediately was a bad move especially since it resulted in feature-regression.
barrybe 16y ago
I remember when Issues 1.0 came out, I tested it for only a short while before I found a blocking bug with vote counts. (The bug I found allowed anyone to downvote an issue as many times as they wanted). I wonder if the voting feature didn't get as much usage as it would have because it was buggy?
- tosh 16y ago
  I agree. I believe version 1.0 was very well thought through and just needed some polish instead of a relaunch. A shame that I did not mention the voting feature because I also used it quite a bit and found it useful especially for public open source projects to see what features people care about.
petervandijck 16y ago
Yes, I've had to create a "priority" tag. It's ok though. The biggest thing that's missing for me is the ability to add screenshots. That just hurts.
- paulirish 16y ago
  > screenshots Use Gyazo ( http://gyazo.com http://gyazo.com ) and then drop in the Markdown for the image. Works just fine. Also the UI for voting was very odd to me. There were priorities? I think labels can mimic priorities very nicely (I suppose without sorting though). I don't miss these features, myself.

42 points by lucahammer 16y ago

I second the priorities feature; it gets more important as the project grows and more "noise" is added to the tracker. We'll see how the otherwise in every way better Issues adapts to it. e.g. https://github.com/pokeb/asi-http-request/issues https://github.com/pokeb/asi-http-request/issues is now sorted after creation date - really not the best way to sort the list.

curiouscats 16y ago

I agree, without the ability to easily prioritize the features I will have to abandon github issues. It was also extremely lame to "upgrade" everyone to version 2 and lose all the data the users had put into their issues for the priority order.

tosh 16y ago
It sounds like you should be able to recover the priorities using their API https://github.com/blog/831-issues-2-0-the-next-generation#comment-11400 https://github.com/blog/831-issues-2-0-the-next-generation#c... but I agree that the decision to upgrade everyone immediately was a bad move especially since it resulted in feature-regression.

barrybe 16y ago

I remember when Issues 1.0 came out, I tested it for only a short while before I found a blocking bug with vote counts. (The bug I found allowed anyone to downvote an issue as many times as they wanted). I wonder if the voting feature didn't get as much usage as it would have because it was buggy?

tosh 16y ago
I agree. I believe version 1.0 was very well thought through and just needed some polish instead of a relaunch. A shame that I did not mention the voting feature because I also used it quite a bit and found it useful especially for public open source projects to see what features people care about.

petervandijck 16y ago

Yes, I've had to create a "priority" tag. It's ok though. The biggest thing that's missing for me is the ability to add screenshots. That just hurts.

paulirish 16y ago
> screenshots Use Gyazo ( http://gyazo.com http://gyazo.com ) and then drop in the Markdown for the image. Works just fine. Also the UI for voting was very odd to me. There were priorities? I think labels can mimic priorities very nicely (I suppose without sorting though). I don't miss these features, myself.