4 ms·
> There's a paradox, though. If we say e.g. YouTube is not allowed to remove content, that's actually a restriction of freedom of speech. In particular, YouTube
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> There's a paradox, though. If we say e.g. YouTube is not allowed to remove content, that's actually a restriction of freedom of speech. In particular, YouTube's freedom of speech.
Putting aside whether or not this is nonsense to begin with, it certainly doesn't apply to China, which is a government. A law requiring companies serving the US market to not comply with censorship by China is restricting what China can do, not what those companies can do. The companies then have a problem if they exist in two jurisdictions which now have conflicting laws, but they can solve it by moving out of whichever jurisdiction they please.
- Imnimo 6y agoWhat's to stop the companies from claiming they just happen to want to remove the speech of their own volition? If the CEO of TikTok says he doesn't want "free Tibet" on his platform because he wants to be on good terms with China, not because China specifically told him to censor it, is that his freedom?
- RandoHolmes 6y agoactions speak louder than words here.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> What's to stop the companies from claiming they just happen to want to remove the speech of their own volition? The fact that they would have no choice if they were subject to China's jurisdiction. You can't choose to do something you're being forced to do, therefore if you do it, it wasn't your choice.
- joshuamorton 6y agoI have at least two options: comply or exit the jurisdiction. It is my choice to do the former.
- jimothyhalpert7 6y ago> The fact that they would have no choice if they were subject to China's jurisdiction. Wouldn't the reverse be true in the US? Assume that actually supported China's radical opinions, while being subject to US jurisdiction - wouldn't they be forced out of business? Isn't that what's going on now? > You can't choose to do something you're being forced to do, therefore if you do it, it wasn't your choice. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frankfurt_cases https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frankfurt_cases
- joshuamorton 6y agoWould you say that an EU law restricting companies from complying with a US warrant is restricting the companies, or the US? (In practice the way this is done is with data location rules, that EU data must be stored in the EU, which is clearly a restriction on the way the company operates)