4 ms·
The choice is don't build for MacOS. In the long run Apple won't be happy with that and maybe they'll waive the fee.
by pmontra 6y ago
The choice is don't build for MacOS. In the long run Apple won't be happy with that and maybe they'll waive the fee.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoHow would that get them to waive the fee? If your app is open source and they wanted it that bad they could just build it themselves, or develop their own replacement for it, and anybody else can pound sand. They have you over a barrel and they know it.
- pmontra 6y agoSo let's Apple port, build and distribute open source for MacOS. I have no problem with that. Yet I bet it would cost Apple more than the money they do from the license they sell to OS developers.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBut they're not going to do that for your project, only the ones they actually care about. In fact they already do this. Your macOS comes with bash (the old one because they don't like the new license) and a slew of other open source software. The whole thing is built on top of BSD. So they take what they want and then make you pay them for anything else.
- pmontra 6y agoNo problem with MacOS having only the open source programs Apple care about. In that scenario if Apple want that developers keep buying their hardware they'll have care about a lot of software or hope that everybody will be happy to work in a Linux VM, possibly with a Linux desktop. Imagine a Mac with no docker, no GNU userland and dev tools (if they're a thing on MacOS), no vim, no Node, no Python, etc.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoHow is that supposed to help all the small time developers that are trying to get started on a side project and want to distribute it to their 200 existing customers who Apple doesn't care about at all?
- pmontra 6y agoThey're not the developers I was thinking about. I was thinking about the kind of open source projects that are installed by 100k-100M people. Misunderstanding sorted out, let's see. If I wanted to reach 200 customers on MacOS (real or leads) probably I can invest 0.5 USD per customer and see if I end up making some money because one of them hires me to do anything.
- cornstalks 6y ago> In the long run Apple won't be happy with that and maybe they'll waive the fee. I think you greatly overestimate how much Apple cares about this.
- viro 6y agoI think you underestimate how many power users use macOS. Most of their privacy and security marketing isn't really targeted at normal people. The avg. person doesn't really care that much.
- an_opabinia 6y agoIt’s pretty impressive that Ubuntu and Arch (Power User-only experiences in my mind) are considered an alternative to macOS by anyone at all. It shows the Linux desktop is actually delivering something very valuable despite the numbers. Although that the numbers don’t tell the whole story isn’t really saying much. What if it turned out that ease of use and OS-wide app consistency was the easy part all along? That building good APIs - which includes not changing them, making a good publishing experience - which includes not changing your rules every six months, and making your developers rich - which includes lowering fees - were the hard parts? Besides the average person does care about privacy and security. Keychain is a product everyone on macOS and iOS uses. Imagine if the OS forced Private Browsing to actually work.
- nobodyandproud 6y agoHow reliable is the security vetting in the Ubuntu store?
- dhagz 6y agoThe thing to remember is that, under all the chrome and Apple styling, macOS is rooted in BSD. So the power users who enjoy the *nix-y bits of macOS and are looking for a replacement will look for something that gives them more of that.
- 6y ago
- mattl 6y agoThey do waive it for non-profits, if they have the right paperwork. I'm sure Mozilla/Apache/WordPress/Free Software Foundations could get a $0 key if they wanted.
- throWaythxMod 6y agoI haven't been building Apps on their platform. Apple advertises to me daily. Not sure if related.