9 ms·
Hate to say it, but the terrific first amendment in the US only applies to the government. Companies and individuals can kick you out for saying things they don
by phkahler 6y ago
Hate to say it, but the terrific first amendment in the US only applies to the government. Companies and individuals can kick you out for saying things they dont like.
There are laws against certain kinds of discrimination by companies, but those are not the first amendment.
Just wanted to clarify that so we dont pretend companies are upholding constitutional rights on a regional basis. They are not accountable to it anywhere.
- User23 6y agoCongress and state legislatures can and should fix this.
- pwinnski 6y agoShould fix... how? Companies should be compelled to provide a platform for free expression, and forbidden from removing any content, no matter how objectionable? It's unclear to me what you're suggesting.
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoI think it's clear what parent commenter is suggesting. And that no medium if privately owned has the right to moderate itself and must carry any and all speech and productions. Just because it's unreasonable and makes no sense doesn't mean people don't want it or widely support it on HN.
- ethanwillis 6y agoI think the difference is mediums that have reached a certain size and cultural influence that they are effectively modern public forums. If all public discussion is on happening on these private platforms then they a civic duty to not suppress speech. What's happening is people conflate "not suppressing speech" with "supporting hate speech." They don't support anything. They're nothing more at this point than a public space maintained by a private entity. Private entities I'll add that are essentially subsidized by taxpayers due to not meeting their obligations of paying their taxes, and no I'm not talking about minimizing tax obligations[0]. [0] - https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/19/21144291/facebook-irs-lawsuit-9-billion-taxes https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/19/21144291/facebook-irs-law... And nobody ever said "no matter how objectionable." We still have limits on obscenity.
- pwinnski 6y agoObscenity as a legal term is complicated. Culturally, even more so. One person's "obscenity" is another person's "vernacular of the street." What is obscene in Kuwait might be an everyday greeting in Sydney. Primarily, you are arguing for compelling corporation to expend effort and expense to carry content deemed objectionable by officers of that company, and I'm not sure you've thought that through. You might think politically-[whatever] voices are being silenced--absent evidence--but if the US government decides to violate hundreds of years of established norms and force websites to cease censoring content, it won't be just content you favor that explodes. And if the US government can force Facebook and Twitter to carry content they don't like, then what legal standard separates them from Hacker News, for example?
- ethanwillis 6y agoI'd rather leave the definition of obscenity to the courts than to a private company. If a company wants to editorialize their content and provide moderation when they deem fit then they specifically should lose their protections under section 230.
- pwinnski 6y agoThat is completely the opposite of how section 230 works, and section 230 is the entire reason websites like Hacker News are allowed to exist. Your argument has now gotten even worse, not better! If a company loses Section 230 protections, the safest move is to disable user content completely. No comments anywhere. The next-safest move is to be extremely heavy-handed editorially, since any comment left alone could be the basis for a company-ending lawsuit. Whatever views you believe are being censored now, I guarantee you they would be actually censored completely without Section 230. Read Section 230[0]. It's the foundation of the modern internet and says almost exactly the opposite of what you're suggesting. Read 230(c)(2)(A) twice. [0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/230 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/230
- mixedCase 6y agoNot the GP, but I'm thinking you could have a system where instead of centralized control, as a user you can subscribe to blocklists provided by the company as well as community-made ones. These would be tasked with the regulation of legal speech, and providing a framework for these lists would be a requirement to be protected under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act if you meet certain requirements; while illegal speech can still be controlled under traditional centralized moderation. Not sure how legislation would define the requirements for something like this. What would metrics would signal that a platform to have to comply with the regulation? (MAUs?, revenue?, surely having moderation, but should certain kinds of moderation like removing botspam count?) Should a provider be able to silently set-up default lists for new users or should they be prompted? Should the company be required to break down blocklists among different topics (spam/pornography/depictions of violence/a goose with a campfire in the background) and how should the boundaries of topics be defined if so? What kind of functionality should be considered the bare minimum for a framework to build community-curated blocklists? Mind you, I still am not sure regulation is the way to go. But the truth is that these platforms wield a scary amount of power over the psyche of people to extents that would've made the Stasi drool all over the place, and it does have the ability of corrupting democracy far more than biased TV channels and newspapers since it's no longer Fox News or CNN presenting you something, it's your own acquaintances that get some of their voices artificially boosted while some others are silenced; literally distorting a huge amount of voters' own grasp on reality.
- throwaway122378 6y agoI'm sick of this response. These social media companies individually can reach billions of people with the ability (proven) to sway their thoughts and emotions (see Facebook, WHO, Reddit). Free speech must apply to public forums like this
- smt88 6y agoI'm sorry you're sick of the First Amendment. Private companies have it just like you do. The remedy is to break up the big forums, not to take away the rights of their owners.
- kube-system 6y agoIf we’re still talking about TikTok here, the concern is that they don’t have the right to free speech — that the rights on their platform is coopted by a government power.
- platz 6y agoThis simply isn't an issue regarding the first-amendment; not sure this thread needs to go into the philosophical dilemma on this here.
- kube-system 6y agoCorrect, it is an issue regarding the lack of Chinese speech rights. The US constitution is irrelevant in China. Human rights, however, are natural rights.
- smt88 6y agoI'm not still talking about TikTok. I support banning Chinese social networks or any network where China has censorship power (either explicit or through back doors). I was responding narrowly about the idea that "free speech" demands that the US govt can force companies to choose what to publish. Forcing a company to stop operating here is an entirely different concept.
- dreamcompiler 6y agoThis. The writers of the constitution understood that if you didn't like doing business with a company you could just take your business to their competitor. If you don't like your bridge club or church, pick a different one. But if your government is infringing your rights, it's very difficult for most people to pick a different government.
- Moru 6y agoBut when the private companies overshadow government, there is no competition to take your business to. If Facebook has all my friends, I have to choose my principles or my friends. So far principles won for me but not many can do that offering. And my friends are slowly coming around again :)
- phatfish 6y agoAlmost as if government regulation relating to monopolies and "too big to fail" corporations actually means something? Maybe a competent government would actually advocate and enforce laws to stop one company controlling your life.
- Proziam 6y agoThis is one of the areas where liberal and conservatives alike are often in strong agreement. I find it curious that we haven't seen a protest over this issue that carries enough weight to illicit some serious change. It doesn't strike me as a difficult one to get 100k people to march for, and if the NRA/GOA backed it you could easily get 20-30k individuals who are well armed (and still peaceful) to join in like they did in Virginia. I must be missing something because I cannot imagine why everyone is so tolerant of companies having nation-state level ability to ruin lives, and to routinely face no consequences when they do so.
- Domenic_S 6y agoLots of bad effects can happen. Imagine you live in a place with one internet provider (most of us) and no cell service. Then imagine that because of something you said, that internet provider cancels your account and doesn't want to work with you anymore. Especially in covid times, that's basically barring you from working. Or say you live in a small town with one grocery store, and they don't like your BLM tshirt so one day they ban you. Private company, they can do that. But now where do you buy food? Or your Brand X car breaks down, but Brand X decides they don't want you in any Brand X dealerships anymore, but the problem is your car needs a specific diagnostic tool only available to Brand X dealers. The examples are endless
- cataphract 6y agoDoesn't the "terrific" 1st amendment (not sure in which sense you're using the word) cut against the type of regulations that the gp advocates for? To the extent that banning pro-Tibet messages is expressive editorial conduct, the government's banning of such companies for engaging in such conduct would violate the 1st amendment protections against viewpoint discrimination. Put another way, by preventing the government from regulating private companies in such a fashion, the 1st amendment can actually weaken free speech (though I would argue that the actual problem is fact that the big tech companies are so dominant that few viable alternative venues, with different editorial practices, exist). The result is that when the government tries to reform the editorial practices of the tech companies, it has to do so through awkward means (like saying that they are not enforcing their own rules or threatening to strip them of their protection against libel and other causes of action). Anyway I'm pretty sure that if they condition civil liability protection on their following editorial "best practices", like what current bipartisan bills to reform section 230 do, the courts will not play along.
- kube-system 6y agoThe person you are responding to didn’t make a first amendment argument, or say anything about the US. They are saying that people outside of China should take a stand against China’s lack of respect for speech rights, rather than playing along with it for profit.
- ideals 6y agoThe USG doesn't respect speech rights of it's citizens either so idk where this grandstanding keeps coming from that we're still the champion of free speech when every night police beat and pepper spray people for exercising those rights.
- kube-system 6y agoThat is also a problem — however it is neither related, nor diminishes the significance of the topic at hand. And the suggestion that the USG and CCP’s respect for speech rights are somehow comparable is just silly. All of the western world has a significantly better respect for speech rights than the CCP does.
- mas3god 6y agoChina is far worse in that regard, pressure flipping against the US is a common Chinese troll argument.
- hatchnyc 6y agoI have come to disagree with the sentiment. The constitution prevents congress from restricting free speech because it is a document written about what congress can and cannot do, not because the authors wanted to argue that restricting freedom of speech was a job that should be left to individuals and businesses. It is only in response to someone mistakenly arguing to assert their 1st amendment rights in a context where it isn't applicable that this rebuttal even makes any sort of sense--which is not the case for the OP, who didn't mention the 1st amendment or even the US at all. Even here, it is a pedantic argument, such a declaration is a mere technical mistake. In liberal democracies we value freedom of expression.
- lmkg 6y agoThere's a paradox, though. If we say e.g. YouTube is not allowed to remove content, that's actually a restriction of freedom of speech. In particular, YouTube's freedom of speech. I'm not generally in favor of taking corporate personhood to logical extremes, but I'm kind of OK with companies having values and being able promote those values. Being able to promote some speech over others is part of that. The First Amendment applies to the government because the government is a privileged party. Its role in society is dislike that of any private citizen or enterprise, and the restrictions we place on it reflect that uniqueness. It only makes sense to extend the First Amendment to other parties that have a unique role. Which we do, e.g. Common Carrier restrictions on the movement of goods, and a variety of special requirements on telecommunications companies. If we want to say that social media platforms have become a core aspect of modern democracy and need to be regulated as such, there's an argument to be made. But applying it to private businesses in general is overreach in my opinion. There's another line of reasoning that "First Amendment" is a stand-in for the societal value of freedom of speech. While it doesn't legally apply, we invoke it to mean that freedom of speech is the first-est of amendments, i.e. is the freedom that we rank more highly than any others. This still gets into the same paradox though. A company shouldn't be forced to equally support all viewpoints because then it's not a freedom, but we can certainly express dissatisfaction that a private party is acting in a way counter to the values of our society.
- dexen 6y ago
- yourapostasy 6y agoThere are a few areas of regulated speech even in government-involved First Amendment scenarios [1]. It is true that private entities can kick out individuals for utterances found disagreeable. But what if those private entities are practically extensions of those in government positions, working closely with them? During the Framers' time, the proto-US did not have the equivalent of the Dutch East India Company, considered the most valuable company of all time [2]. At what point does a private entity grow so powerful that its private views applied in its selection of who to engage with turn into persecution of the kind that informed the separation of church and state principle [3]? I'd like to get a specialist historian's (specializing in the Framers' discussions) take on this, because I find it interesting that they were all very likely well aware of the Dutch East India Company, yet they did not find it a compelling enough entity to elevate to the level of the separation principle. So I have to wonder: what did they believe was the countervailing force against such a behemoth private entity's selection pressure turning into outright persecution? [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/amendment-1/government-restraint-of-content-of-expression https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/amendment-1/g... [2] https://www.visualcapitalist.com/most-valuable-companies-all-time/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/most-valuable-companies-all... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separation_of_church_and_state_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separation_of_church_and_state...
- bronco21016 6y agoIt’s really more nuanced than that though isn’t it? The issue isn’t so much that TikTok is censoring content. It’s that they’re censoring content at the request of a foreign government. I’m not a legal scholar by any means so I cannot really comment about the application of the constitution or other applicable law. However, it feels like it’s probably wrong to let another country censor the speech of US citizens, in the US.
- TempLogsForOne 6y agoThat is not technically accurate even though that fallacy/lie has been spread spread for a while now. The Constitution is the supreme law of the land … translation, it applies to everyone downstream from that, including politicians and the government of increasingly concentration of psychopaths (and no, that does not only apply to the current administration). In order to understand this concept that is either intentionally or stupidly being manipulated, one has to understand that the Constitution created the government and, relevant to this point, protects preexisting, God given rights, from violation by that government; the Bill of Rights as most would know them as. They are actually not a Bill of Rights as people today would understand from the term, but rather they are articles of the Constitution that protect those rights, essentially laws that the government of psychopaths cannot violate to infringe on those God given, preceding rights. So to your point, yes, the government may not infringe on the God given rights, but that also applies to all others whom are subject to the jurisdiction of the supremacy of the Constitution, aka, all people who are not subject to the primary jurisdiction of a foreign nation, aka guests. You cannot pick and choose which of the articles of the Constitution apply to the government and now; or would you propose that slavery by the government is not permitted, but it is A OK for everyone else to engage in slavery? I understand the compulsion to evade logical consistency to rationalize how one article of the Constitution does apply and another does not, but that is not accurate and is inherently fallacious, irrational, and inherent uncivilized, brutish, and animalistic.
- outtatime 6y agoWhat's your Bar number? I'm starting to ask people that because armchair lawyering is not helpful and I see it a lot.
- chrischattin 6y agoI strongly disagree. Free speech is a cultural ethic. In an enlightened liberal society, we have a shared value that self-expression is a fundamental human right. And, it is wrong to take away someone's human rights. The first amendment exists to ensure the government never violates that human right. But, companies and individuals have a cultural/moral obligation to protect/not violate that right as well, imo.
- jariel 6y agoTrue - but - we can still ban foreign companies who act in nasty ways. We 'divest from Oil' for god's sake we can at least 'divest from the CCP'. The CCP has a team in most (about 85%) of Chinese companies to ensure they tow the party line. They don't care about day-to-day operations, but when it comes to sensitive things, they report back to the CCP. Thanks to technology ... it's the most systematically totalitarian state ever devised. When writing 20th century dystopian novels, we never even conceived of the level of personal control. Imagine if the US president ordered a CIA or GOP organ inside every US company, directed the Fed to put money in certain banks, and directed the banks to make loans to specific companies on specific terms. And then read everyone's email, browser history, chat to make sure they 'complied' and flagged anyone who ever hinted anything other than the accepted truth. That's just scratching the surface. We should ban it.
- Justsignedup 6y agoThere are _some_ limits to that. If a company is deemed to be considered the equivalent of a town square, it can be given the same restrictions as the 1st amendment. For example Malls cannot ban protected speech in their premises. If a company is not deemed this by courts, they have the full right to ban you for non-protected reasons (excluding racism/sexism and so on)
- username90 6y agoSo basically China should be free to limit free speech all over the world? They are a big market and can therefore force companies to comply. This is what will happen if western governments don't intervene.
- t0mbstone 6y agoSo... amend the constitution? Maybe free speech actually SHOULD be free everywhere, private interests be damned?