4 ms·
> As far as I know there’s no basis for this ever having been done in human history Two seconds of googling. The Wikipedia article for progressive taxation[1]
by vlovich123 6y ago
> As far as I know there’s no basis for this ever having been done in human history
Two seconds of googling. The Wikipedia article for progressive taxation[1] suggests that the Roman Republic had a form of wealth tax:
> The tax rate under normal circumstances was 1% of property value, and could sometimes climb as high as 3% in situations such as war. These taxes were levied against land, homes and other real estate, slaves, animals, personal items and monetary wealth
Then we have the wealth tax Wikipedia article itself[2] that lists 8 instances in recent history of wealth taxes.
Then you say:
> Not to even mention California’s proposed plan to keep collecting taxes after the person flees the state
How is this any different from how taxes are owed today? I'm pretty sure all back taxes you owe a state remain even if you move states. Otherwise you could just rack up a huge tax bill & move states to escape.
Even federal US tax liabilities are applied on world wide income & has treaties with many countries to enforce these laws for expats.
> It’s also unethical. Taxing people based on how much money they have left over after paying all of their other taxes is just wrong
Aside from stating a personal tautology you haven't really elevated the discussion much & then everything else flowed from this premise rather than evaluating the argument on its merits. I'm sure there's a compelling argument against this that could be made against a wealth tax independent of constitutional issues, but you haven't made it.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_tax
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_tax
- haram_masala 6y agoThe problem with a wealth tax is that it's essentially retroactive. Instead of taxing income and capital gains at the time they're accrued, you tax them later - long after the individuals who accrued them have had the chance to make rational decisions based on that tax rate. This seems inherently unfair to me, a form of bait and switch, especially combined with the intention to hunt down former California residents up to a decade after they've left the state (thereby further denying them any opportunity to make rational decisions).
- vlovich123 6y agoHow is it a bait and switch? Seems like that kind of framing would apply to the introduction of any new tax which seems immature to me. I do hope the 10 year thing takes into account how long you’ve been in the state and how much you earned within the state. Remember. You’re only getting taxed on the amount over >30mil in assets (first 30 million isn’t taxable). That’s quite a lot of money before a very small tax begins to be levied. I do hope there’s also allowances for income tied up in illiquid investments (eg private business investments). I would also worry about taxation on net worth that hasn’t been realized (eg private company that does a valuation that suddenly puts you over the 30 mil threshold). These seem like important nuances that could quickly torpedo any benefits.
- sokoloff 6y agoWhat can look like a very small tax is not at all small when applied repeatedly (annually). As an example a popular “Just two cents” plan takes a third of the value of a taxed base in 20 years and by 35 years, the government has received over half.
- thoughtstheseus 6y agoDoes your example assume the asset will grow in value? Wealth taxes get big as they compound, but that also shows the compounding value of assets.
- sokoloff 6y agoThat is simple math assuming no change of the taxed wealth value (which could go up, down, or stay the same). IMO, "small" wealth taxes "get big" because they take repeated bites at the same apple. Government take [via wealth tax] in the example above is the result of 1 - (1 - taxrate) ^ years. 1 - (1 - 0.02) ^ 20 = 0.3323 ; (20 years => 33%) 1 - (1 - 0.02) ^ 35 = 0.5069 ; (35 years => 51%)
- jdlshore 6y ago
- sokoloff 6y agoI don’t think anyone is objecting to California levying property tax on property in California, similar to the Roman property tax. (Property taxes are a form of wealth tax indeed, but when someone proposes a “wealth tax” today, they probably specifically do not mean a tax based on property value, but rather on net wealth.) Taxes on net wealth and particularly net wealth held outside California by non-residents of California represent a material different case in my mind and one which I’d hope would not be found constitutional.