4 ms·
You definitely get to supress infrastructure when you have enough people willing to protest. I don't get it, are you trying to imply that protests should have
by sudosysgen 6y ago
You definitely get to supress infrastructure when you have enough people willing to protest.
I don't get it, are you trying to imply that protests should have no disruptive effect? That is a good recipe for complete political dysfunction. Civil disobedience is based upon disruption. It is our right as citizens.
Besides, if an ambulance or doctor needed to go through a protest, the vast majority of the time just asking gets them through.
- jariel 6y ago"You definitely get to supress infrastructure when you have enough people willing to protest." No - you don't. This is illegal, and it happens only by virtue of force. You absolutely have no right do do this - you just have he power to do it 'if you have enough people'. So yes, if you have an aggressive mob, you can get away with illegal things, that doesn't mean it's lawful.
- jlawson 6y agoYou have a vote. Use it. You also have a voice. Use it. You have no right to undemocratically wield power over others by physical force. You have no right to force others to suffer to compel them to your will which they did not choose.
- sudosysgen 6y agoLimiting the political engagement of your citizens to only voting in a two party system is madness. When people stop being engaged, and stop voting, and your country turns to shit, I can say that I warned you. No, seriously, this is insane. You want to, functionally, ban protests. There is absolutely no way you can have a functional country if you can't even have peaceful demonstrations.
- jariel 6y ago"You want to, functionally, ban protests." You have a misunderstanding of what is legal, what is not, and what a peaceful protest is. Blocking traffic is already banned. That's 100% illegal in all cases. 'Protests' which infringe on the rights of others are just another form of fascism. 'My Fascism is Worthwhile' is not a civic or moral argument. You can protest peacefully, vote, engage in other forms of civic obedience, but you can't do it at the expense of others, full stop. As soon as someone starts trampling on your rights for a cause you don't agree with you'll scream 'victim' and then maybe have a different perspective.
- sudosysgen 6y agoWalking in the street is not fascism. This is seriously ridiculous. Are you going to claim that the Hong Kong protests, or the Climate Protests are fascists because people were walking in the streets?
- jlawson 6y agoFunny, I never said "only voting". I also said you have a voice, use it. You seem to have completely ignored that paragraph. Perhaps you'd like to take a shot at actually responding to what I wrote. It is absolutely possible to protest without hurting innocent bystanders.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIf your standard for "hurting innocent bystanders" is to mildly inconvenience some people by causing them to seek an alternative route, then no, it's not possible to have an effective protest under that standard. The right to protest is generally accepted to mean that people are allowed to walk in the street in an effort to be heard. I responded to what you wrote, and your arguments fall flat. Even during massive protests with millions of people ambulances get where they need to get and doctors go where they need to go.
- jlawson 6y agoWhen you're blocked on the highway, you cannot leave. You're confined. No matter how sick you are, how hungry the baby is, how hot the car is getting, how low on gas or how late you are for work. Stop being disingenous about what you're advocating. You're advocating confining people to their cars on the highway. Including old people, little kids, sick people. To force them to listen to you.
- msla 6y ago> If your standard for "hurting innocent bystanders" is to mildly inconvenience some people No, the standard is potentially killing people.