3 ms·
We need more open source software modeled off of the blender system. Imagine if customers of all the major closed-software players also put aside some small am
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
We need more open source software modeled off of the blender system.
Imagine if customers of all the major closed-software players also put aside some small amount of funding to support full time developers of open source systems.
This benefits everyone, because it gives these customers some potential future leverage for lower prices, it gives the closed-software players some competition to keep them nimble, and it benefits the next generation of users who can’t afford the closed-software prices, but could get their fingers wet with less capable software.
- danudey 6y agoIn my experience, a lot of open-source systems are managed by terrible teams with their own priorities or ideas, regardless of what the actual community wants. For example, The GIMP has been notorious for this for its entire history, and it still is[1]. I remember ages ago, the discussion basically went like this. > "Thanks to The GIMP, people can ditch Photoshop and Windows and move to Linux and an open-source workflow!" > "But The GIMP doesn't support a lot of features, like CMYK color." > "Sure, but nobody actually uses CMYK color though." > "Literally everyone who designs for print uses CMYK color, like print shops, magazine editors, etc., and that's a huge market." > "Well it's open source, so if it's so important to you then fix it yourself!" > "But I'm a photographer and magazine editor, not a programmer, so I'm just going to keep paying someone else for software I can use, instead of switching to a free version of something that literally refuses to add the features I need." Cue tons of Slashdot comments talking about how non-technical people are so rigid-minded that they're not willing to learn anything new and just make excuses instead. Blender is an exception, not just because it's an open-source success, but because it's managed by a team who are building it for the people who need it, and not just to stick it to closed-source companies by making a pale imitation of a production app, an all-too-common scenario in open-source development. [1] https://medium.com/linux-gossip/the-gimp-has-a-marketing-problem-edced42b0158 https://medium.com/linux-gossip/the-gimp-has-a-marketing-pro...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThe size of the (potential) user base matters. Back in the early 2000's, I did several workshops on Ardour (DAW) in the same context that Ton and others were doing workshops on Blender (sometimes in the room next door). Without fail, the Blender workshops had 10x more people than the Ardour one. Everybody knows that to do computer generated imagery you need only a computer, and skill. There's a LOT of need for computer generated imagery. The use cases extend far outside the obvious ones for Blender. For a DAW, most people understand that you probably need significant musical skill (which may or may not be true, depending on the genre of music you want to create). And if you're not actually making music, you probably don't need a DAW. The result is that an app like Blender has a user base at least as large as that of several DAWs put together (probably not all DAWs, but several of them). This changes the nature of the type of ecosystem (development, funding, user community) you can build around the software.