3 ms·
Looking at different ideologies, the Republican has many fascists, the Democrats has no communists and only a tiny minority dare criticize capitalist. That pret
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Looking at different ideologies, the Republican has many fascists, the Democrats has no communists and only a tiny minority dare criticize capitalist. That pretty much settles it, the US has no leftist party.
The generally accepted definition of a leftist is someone that opposes capitalism. There is no real political force in the US that opposes capitalism, so the US doesn't have a left. It has a center, and a right-to-far-right,
- crunksht 6y agoWhat fascists? All of our elected officials are either left-flavored neoliberals or right-flavored neoliberals. The only exceptions I can think of are one self proclaimed socialist (Sanders) and one libertarian (Paul). Certainly no elected communists. Europe has a much greater variety of politicians (right and left) than America. The center/left/right paradigm doesn't make much sense here (as much as compressing all possible political positions into a 1-dimensional spectrum makes sense anyway.)
- sudosysgen 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_King https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_King As requested, as provided. Anyone who preaches the supremacy of the white race I think can be fairly characterized as fascist. The majority of Republicans are indeed neoliberals, but there are and have been avowed white supremacists and fascists. Various republican-aligned groups in the US actually cooperated with the NSDAP.
- Chlorus 6y agoThe guy who was repeatedly reprimanded by his own party for it & stripped of his assignments? By this standard, the Democrats are socialists since they won't reprimand AOC. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/14/us/politics/steve-king-white-supremacy.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/14/us/politics/steve-king-wh... > Various republican-aligned groups in the US actually cooperated with the NSDAP. If we're bringing up stuff from the 1930s, you're not going to like what the Democrats were doing from then until 70s.
- sudosysgen 6y agoSteve King isn't the only one, and as far as I know he is still a member of the Republican party. When AOC shows support to a Marxist-Leninist State and party, and when she loudly claims for the seizure of the means of production, you'll have a point. So far, the most extreme thing she's advocating for is Nationalized Healthcare and investment in infrastructure. I don't really think you can equate that with complaining about the white genocide. Her policies and rhetoric are at the very most that of a left-leaning liberal anywhere else in the world. So no, your argument doesn't really hold up. If you're going to claim that the Democrats were collaborating with the Soviets, I'd like to remind you that Mccarthy was a Democrat.
- AlexTWithBeard 6y ago> economic security for all who are ... unwilling to work. goes slightly beyond investment into infrastructure
- sudosysgen 6y agoEconomic security for people who are unwilling to work is a basic feature of most advanced economies. See the BS in Québec, the RSI in France, and so on. There was a time in the US when it was a thing too.
- AlexTWithBeard 6y agoRegardless of whether it's implemented in certain countries, the idea that society must support those unwilling to work seems to be quite far on left side of the spectrum. The "you don't work - you don't eat" idea is not "rightists". It's just a basic law of nature.
- sudosysgen 6y ago"You don't work - you don't eat" isn't a reality anywhere in the world today. It's not a basic law of nature, it's a delusion. The world doesn't actually work like that. Do you think that the Republicans are quite far on the left side of the spectrum? Because last I've heard they haven't repealed food stamps yet.
- a1369209993 6y agoWhile racial supremacism and facism obviously work well together (especially if you can confuse racial identity with national identity), they aren't actually related and King only seems to support the former. He seems like a rather revolting person from what I bothered to read of the Wikipedia page, but I don't see anything to support "the Republican has many fascists", unless you're going by a suffiently broad definition of "facist" as to include most of the US congress, Democrat or Republican, which doesn't seem to be what you're asserting.
- sudosysgen 6y agoRacial supremacy leads to the conclusion that fixing America requires the removal of lesser classes. Steve King vocally advocates for the theory of White Genocide, according to which some group is attempting to import racially inferior people in order to dilute and genetically ruin the white race and this country. The only logical conclusion from these beliefs is ethnic cleansing, there is no other. It is fascist. Moreover, I don't need to speculate; Steve King has voiced support for Viktor Orban, who ran on an ethno-nationalist platform to destroy Hungarian democracy. If you want to know just how hard this goes into the Republican Party, do some research on QAnon. Go to the website from which this theory came from, 8kun.top . Go to the board /pnd/, and /qresearch/ and tell me what you see. This is where the theories that multiple people in the Republican Party openly subscribe to come from. But of course, their support for the theories of White Genocide, the Confederate imagery (the Confederate state that, by the way, did explicitly merge racial identity with national identity) is more than enough to draw conclusions. I don't think this is an unreasonable definition of fascism. The Italian fascists weren't even this racist.
- anm89 6y agoThe definition of fascist is not person you don't like.
- Bekwnn 6y ago> The generally accepted definition of a leftist is someone that opposes capitalism. This is a very broken and poor working definition. You can be leftist without being anti capitalist. Leftists don't believe in the "free market fixes things" or trickle down rhetorics. Speaking as a left leaning Canadian. Leftist capitalism would see government regulation over industry which is of vital societal importance. America has bodies regulating food, medicine, construction, and others. Leftist capitalism often seeks to extend regulations to the benefit of the average citizen. One example is Canada recently forcing telecoms to unlock phones. Another might be provincial transportation services being either government owned or privately owned with a high degree of government oversight. Their prices then remain low with moderate levels of profitability instead of high prices seeking higher levels of profit. I'd say the majority of leftists believe capitalism needs to be carefully kept in check, with only more extreme believing it should be abolished. Though many do believe certain industries require far more government oversight than they currently have, or that certain things like health care or education should be made into a social service.
- sudosysgen 6y agoDo you believe that capitalism is the best economic system possible that will ever be, and that simply adjusting it will forever be the limit of economic theory? And by capitalism, I mean capitalism, not just markets. If so, I'd say you are a left-leaning liberal, not a leftist. Economically, you are firmly in the center.
- reddog 6y agoIts too bad that, for many people, fascist has just become the default insult for people you don't agree with politically. It actually has a very specific meaning. Read the wikipedia article on fascism and you will he hard pressed to find an actual fascist in the public sphere on any political level.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere are people in the Republican party that believe in the white Genocide, that Jewish billionaires are financing genetic warfare against white people. Their solution is essentially fascism. Read up a bit about fascism. You'll find that's it's not just the Nazis in 1942.
- hairofadog 6y agoI agree that the words "fascist" and "fascism" have practically been worn out by misuse and overuse, but Trump has mutated the Republican Party into something that, to my eyes, meets most common definitions of Fascism, and looking at the wikipedia article you mention seems to confirm my thoughts on this: they describe fascism as "a form of far-right, authoritarian, ultranationalism" and mention protectionism, and economic interventionism, and opposition to liberal democracy, among other things. I would be interested to hear how the Trump administration is different in concept from the description outlined by the wikipedia page.