4 ms·
The goal of the left isn't to divide the population on gender and class, it is to make the already existing divisions apparent as that is a pre-requisite to act
by sudosysgen 6y ago
The goal of the left isn't to divide the population on gender and class, it is to make the already existing divisions apparent as that is a pre-requisite to actually fix them. Which is why leftists would call it ...-consciousness, because the goal is just to make people conscious of the already existing differences and then to heal them.
The basic idea of modern leftism is that strongest, base distinction in society is class, but that there are other existing divisions that need to be bridged before class itself can be fixed.
If it is not readily apparent to you, the US is already divided based on gender, class, and race, and the right party (really both of them) promote policies that would actually increase these gaps. They would ignore them in their rhetoric, but augment them in practice. Whereas the left augments them in their rhetoric, but seeks to minimize them in practice.
- username90 6y ago> The goal of the left isn't to divide the population on gender and class, it is to make the already existing divisions apparent as that is a pre-requisite to actually fix them. Republicans are officially against racism, pro black etc. So look at what people do, not what they say.
- sudosysgen 6y agoSure. Then look at what the left actually does, and tell me how it makes racial, class, and gender divisions worse. The democrats in the US don't qualify as leftists, as I stated above.
- username90 6y agoUSA really need a political party that isn't 50% lawyers. No other country has such low diversity among politician backgrounds to my knowledge.
- sudosysgen 6y agoI agree. I think some Islamic theocracies have around the same amount of diversity, though :P Though, the wave of Justice Democrats coming from working class background such as nurses and so on is encouraging
- amznthrwaway 6y agoDemocrats are a center-right party. Republicans are a far-right authoritarian party. The USA has no left-wing parties.
- AWildC182 6y agoI think that is the point that OP is making, and though I think the overall post is rather salient there might be a better direction for them to take that argument... Perhaps a better way to look at that particular note is while that's how the right views the left (depending on the camp) the issue within the left is the rampant infighting. Sort of like https://xkcd.com/1095/ https://xkcd.com/1095/ . None of these are hard rules obviously but there are a lot of cliques within just LGBT where bi people are hated/excluded from lesbian/gay circles, trans people are excluded from all of the above. Stuff like vegans vs vegetarians, environmentalists vs those focused on social issues, and on and on. I think the saying "the left fights while the right falls in line" is something that needs to be really driven home.
- sudosysgen 6y agoAgreed. There is indeed massive infighting amongst the left, and obviously a lot of misguided people. But generally and in theory I still disagree on the GP's point that the left aims to divide our society.
- AWildC182 6y agoYea, I don't think it's really accurate even if it's sometimes the unintentional result. It's frustrating because I really appreciate the rest of the perspective they're offering.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIt may not be that they intend to divide. It may be the inevitable result of their current strategy. If the way you tell people to think about society is to categorize people by race, sex, gender, etc., then that's... not very unifying. If the central point of your message is that certain groups treat members of other groups badly, that's not just not unifying, that's dividing. (It may be necessary dividing, but it's still dividing.)
- sudosysgen 6y agoEmpirical analysis of our current society shows that there are divides and power relations along racial, gender and class lines. If you can't acknowledge them, there is no way to fix them. And most importantly, in practice the left reduces the divide. If you have a better idea of how to fix it, I'm all ears. But fixing a problem without recognizing it exists is, well, not typically accepted as solid practice.
- roenxi 6y ago> They would ignore them in their rhetoric, but augment them in practice. Whereas the left augments them in their rhetoric, but seeks to minimize them in practice. I'm going out on a limb I suppose, but that isn't how political parties work. Outing myself as an engineer, if I wanted to increase/minimise something in practice I would start with a survey of the academic literature on times where the thing changed radically. Then I would attempt to replicate those conditions. Then I would assess the outcomes using pre-defined measures of success. No political party works that way. Both wings of policies work near-exclusively with sounds-good-to-people-who-vote strategies. In particular, speaking cheerfully from the right, I've never seen a leftist "minimise [divides] in practice" strategy that looks like it started from a historic survey of what worked. I expect there are similar complaints about the right. I've never seen a political solution assessed for effectiveness, and most of them aren't effective.
- AWildC182 6y agoI would argue both sides do attempt "literature surveys" but they're often tainted by the desire to justify their goals. It turns out you can twist numbers to mean whatever you want and both sides are guilty of this to some extent, though at the moment the pants-on-fire award seems to go to the right. If taken far enough, however, one gets to the level of trying to debate truth itself and "what is objective fact" which gets hairy...
- sudosysgen 6y agoIf you read leftist literature, there are many attempts to do exactly that. It's just that in the US the left has essentially no power, it's shared between a centrist Democratic party and a right Republican party. That being said, there are a lot of ineffective tactics in the left, because there is a lot of infighting (see the XKCD article on standards, as another commenter suggested), and very loose organization.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoWell, I'm not really all that concerned with what the leftists do in literature. I'm concerned with what they do in power. If we don't actually have any in power in the US, then the only answer is "no data". (And "literature" is a pretty poor way to try to refute the claim, which is what leftists do "in practice".)
- thinkingemote 6y ago> and then to heal them. Not any more. The left used to be about what different people have in common. Now it's about what different people have different than others. The first had healing. The second keeps the wounds open and festering.
- sudosysgen 6y agoHow did the left shift from what people have in common to what they have apart? The left has always talked about existing divisions, ever since the late 1800s. Is making the distinction between owner and worker known not highlighting differences? And of course, once those differences are well known, the left pushes to fix them.
- anm89 6y agoI agree that many people hold this well intentioned goal. The reality I have seen is VERY different.
- sudosysgen 6y agoCare to give examples? US Democrats aren't leftists, they are just normal neoliberals.
- anm89 6y agoParaphrasing you back to yourself: "the goal of the left isn't to divide on gender and class, it's to highlight existing divisions" So we agree then.
- sudosysgen 6y agoNo. The goal of the left is to fix the existing divisions. In order to do so, their existence and extent needs to be laid bare.