10 ms·
Your mind will not be uploaded (2014)
- marcusestes 6y agoUnless it already has been.
- athorax 6y agoWe are all already uploaded to the simulation!
- hinkley 6y agoIf you have not watched the animated short, "The World of Tomorrow" you really should. It has a very pointed reference to the potential horrors of having your mind uploaded by someone who is trying to control costs.
- deinoberherr 6y agoI saw this a while ago and I haven’t been able to remember the name for the life of me, thank you. It’s a really, really good short.
- LukaCEnzo 6y agoDid you mean this: https://youtu.be/IFe9wiDfb0E https://youtu.be/IFe9wiDfb0E
- hinkley 6y agoNo, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_of_Tomorrow_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_of_Tomorrow_(film) The child's doodles make it seem like a lighthearted thing. It is not. A grownup is attempting to explain some fairly dark things to a very young child. Mercifully, the child cannot absorb what it is being told. You may not be so lucky. But there is some biting social commentary and the absurdity of the whole thing makes it work.
- FK3LRnamzX 6y agoCare to share a link?
- hinkley 6y agoThe creator has a Vimeo on-demand page, where I learned he's turning it into a trilogy. I respect the work enough (I expect it's even harder to make money on short films than feature films) that I didn't bother tracking down any free copies. I know some people will, but I don't have to help. I saw it on Netflix, but I doubt it's still there.
- ncmncm 6y agoAnd if it were, it wouldn't be you. But it might be enough like you that it could convince your bank to give it your money.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoNow, that's an interesting philosophical question. The early ones (where “early” is perhaps around the 2200s), probably not – but are you still “you” after heavy brain damage? Why would a bad copy and unfaithful simulation be much different?
- Retric 6y agoBecause philosophy focuses on artifacts of language over reality.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoPhilosophers, perhaps, but I maintain that philosophy is genuinely useful. (Just not philosophising about epistemically solved problems.)
- Retric 6y agoHah, that’s perfect. After all why would philosophy be what philosophers did.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoIt used to be, and some philosophers still do. But, increasingly, philosophy actually requires knowing things about the world – you need to have at least a basic understanding of what's been experimentally verified if you want to just sit around thinking about how you'd design the universe – at least, if you want to have any success, like Einstein did.
- Jtsummers 6y agoGreg Egan's short story collection Axiomatic has some stories dealing with the issue of identity after upload. It probably comes up in some of his other stories as well, but that's all I've read so far of his works.
- sonofgod 6y agodatapoint, to update to 2020: we can now map a third of a fly brain. https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/22/21076806/google-janelia-flyem-fruit-fly-brain-map-hemibrain-connectome https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/22/21076806/google-janelia-f...
- aeternum 6y agoThis is probably the most convincing evidence that your mind likely can be uploaded in the near future.
- bognition 6y agoDepends on how you define the near future. There's a bunch of reasons to be skeptical that we'll fully digitize a human connectome anytime soon. First the fruit fry brain is very small. You can image the entire thing at the microscopic level with a single image. The human brain is massive by comparison. Getting a coherent image that traces an axon from the tip of frontal lobe to the back off the occipital lobe is going to be a huge challenge. Second the fruit-fly brain has 25,000 neurons while the human brain has more than 10,000,000,000. There's 6 orders of magnitude difference there. Third, it's highly likely that glia (non-neurons) in the brain play a major role in neural computation so we'll have to image those too. Humans have way more glia than most other animals. Lastly the connectivity of neurons in the human brain is very high. Getting those little connections right is key in all this as we aren't just going for the neurons but the connections between them.
- nick_kline 6y agoIf you can handle 25k neurons today that's roughly 19 binary orders of magnitude to 10 billion or less than 38 years of Moore's law type doubling, calling it 2 years instead of 18 months per double. So not that scary. There are different kinds of doubling and who knows if it will keep on keeping on.
- trhway 6y ago>Second the fruit-fly brain has 25,000 neurons while the human brain has more than 10,000,000,000. There's 6 orders of magnitude difference there. >Lastly the connectivity of neurons in the human brain is very high. yep, the human brain is 100B neurons and has 10e4 connections per neuron while the fly brain has 10e3 connections/neuron. So we need to emulate 10e15 connections of the human brain. GPT-3 has 175B of weights.
- benibela 6y agoYou could freeze your brain and keep it frozen for a few hundred years, till they have nanobots to repair the freezing damage and scan the brain
- jodrellblank 6y agoYou could imagine doing that. It's much much less certain that you could do that.
- bigodbiel 6y agoWith GPT-3 I think we are rushing towards the Black Mirror episode Be Right Back, where through someone's recorded presence an AI avatar and later a full bodied android could be created.
- hesdeadjim 6y agoI can only begin to imagine the uncanny valley that is an AI version of me outputting GPT-3 text.
- gsich 6y agoOr White Christmas ...
- 29athrowaway 6y agoIf your mind is uploaded, the entity that transcends is a copy of you rather than yourself.
- lostmsu 6y agoTL;DR: the claim is that some quantum process is fundamental to brain functioning, and that makes upload impossible. Well, really, there's no proof to that hypothesis. And I find the argument weak. The complex processes necessary for cells to live might have nothing or just a tiny bit to do with our consciousness.
- vertbhrtn 6y agoThe HN crowd tends to confuse the human's mind with the human's identity. We think that the final destination of human development is some sort of "super intelligence" - a mind with insane processing power and unlimited ability to memorize and recall things. That's understandable because our life today revolves around knowledge, but one day ability to think will yield to ability to see ideas directly. If we could see a theorem's statement and its proof visibly connected like a tree's roots and its leaves, we wouldn't need to "think".
- zaarn 6y agoFinally a friend I can trust to complete my prep work for DnD sessions. Tbh I don't need the philosophy, the upload is a copy but it's also a person. I might treat it as me, depending on how good the upload it. If the upload is destructive I would consider myself to be myself, functionally I continue to exist beyond death. Making it more complicated for no good reason is just draining the fun out of it.
- scipute68 6y agoThe valuable part of you in the ML/AI and state sponsored sense are your memories. Not how you experienced them. Replicating individual consciousness as 'you' would be cruelty unless embodied somehow. Not saying it could not be done I just don't see the point.