3 ms·
The author seems to know (well, was involved in) the history of Self and Strongtalk but seems disappointed that the people involved went on to work on and perfe
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
The author seems to know (well, was involved in) the history of Self and Strongtalk but seems disappointed that the people involved went on to work on and perfect what they see as inferior technology (Java, JavaScript).
In reality I think if we do an honest accounting of the situation we can see that these have been the more pragmatic engineering solutions for their times, and so that's where the $$ was. I worked in Java for years, but didn't particularly like it, but it is, I think, what the marketplace needed and could handle at the time.
And I think JS/ECMAScript etc. is a reasonable practical solution for the imperfect world that evolved out of Internet/browser tech.
Unlike the author I don't think Sun's fortunes would have been any different if Self/Strongtalk or some other Smalltalk-world inspired/derived tech had been pushed hard. The market didn't need or want it.
IBM did a similar pivot with their VisualAge line, and they did it for pragmatic reasons.
Finally, let's look at the bigger picture: in the end, what we have with the browser + modern JS on V8/SpiderMonkey etc. is a dynamic object oriented programming language that allows for dynamic manipulation of its environment, is accessible to any user, can be edited and inspected live, can present interactive media to users, and has a large community of authors.
Is this really that far off from what Alan Kay and Dan Ingalls originally wanted? Purists will gag, but I think as much as I hate front end dev in JS that there's actually a lot here that is Smalltalk inspired.
EDIT: I spent much of the 90s and early 2000s cringing at what was evolving. I was really into PL research and really liked the Self-inspired world of prototype OO languages. I really dug LambdaMOO and spent time writing my own shared-world multi-author persistent-world object oriented virtual machine type systems. But there's no way any of that would pay the bills. I still avoid JS work really, but I can see the niche that this filled. It's imperfect ... but that's the world. I'm grateful to V8 & friends for making it suck a lot less. And that work in V8 is a direct descendant of some of the really neat pioneering stuff in the 80s&90s.
There's a good response the original article here: http://www.wirfs-brock.com/allen/posts/914 http://www.wirfs-brock.com/allen/posts/914