6 ms·
In principal this is good for humanity so long as the research isn’t directed towards tools to improve efficiency of repression.
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
In principal this is good for humanity so long as the research isn’t directed towards tools to improve efficiency of repression.
- ardy42 6y ago> In principal this is good for humanity so long as the research isn’t directed towards tools to improve efficiency of repression. I wouldn't say it's that clear cut. Even if the R&D is not directly for technology for repression, it increases that power and prestige of a state that has few qualms with using repression for political ends. Those increases could mean that other states will come under its influence or emulate its repressive example (when they would have otherwise emulated less-repressive or non-repressive examples).
- free_rms 6y agoCan you give an example of a significant power, any time in history, that did have a lot of qualms with using repression for political ends? Even the Athenians had slaves.
- detritus 6y agoThe EU?
- free_rms 6y agoThat's actually a decent answer, thanks. But they're an economic-only organization. The EU didn't bomb Libya, France and Britain did.
- exdsq 6y agoOne of the arguments for Brexit was that they’re becoming far more than an economic-only organisation
- free_rms 6y agoYeah, and the handling of the Greece situation a few years ago proved that politics abound over justice or sanity in all arenas. It'll be interesting to see how it develops, they're clearly more of a governing body than the UN, but also seem to have steered clear of anything close to a security issue.
- im3w1l 6y agoI think a reason that the EU is so well behaved is that the politicians know that they don't just compete with each other, they compete also with the non-existence of the EU. With time, as it entrenches and everyone believes in their hearts that the EU is going nowhere, then it will be less nice.
- detritus 6y agoI'd wager that it's more of a Political Union (hence Brexit, to a degree?) and is still too young to have meddled much in an overall coherent military strategy. Time will tell.
- aloisdg 6y agoEach country of the EU has some dark corners, but I am still trusting them more than I would trust the USA, China or Russia.
- StreamBright 6y agoI used to think I could trust the EU more than he rest. No more. Wirecard story shows how much this trust is misplaced.
- bilekas 6y agoWell this is a ridiculous statement. That's like saying you don't trust the US anymore because ENRON messed up. Nonsense. The Germans are investigating it, and as always they will make changes to prevent the nonsense again. Ironically enough, it stemmed from the US model of too many lobbyists. :D
- StreamBright 6y agoHow is it going to help those people who lost their income in the middle of the COVID outbrake? Should I just trust the German authorities with the same trust as 1 year ago? Sorry but no.
- gpm 6y agoThe US? They do it, but they have a lot of qualms about it.
- sudosysgen 6y agoNah, the US only has qualms at all at repressing their domestic citizens. No issues repressing foreigners and some minorities since ever.
- ardy42 6y ago> Nah, the US only has qualms at all at repressing their domestic citizens. No issues repressing foreigners and some minorities since ever. No, that's false. An easy example is waterboarding. One administration used it (on foreigners), but it was enormously controversial domestically.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoWhataboutism.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- free_rms 6y ago"What about Iraq" would have been whataboutism. "What about literally everyone else, in all of time" is what I said.
- wintermutestwin 6y agoI wonder if anyone has tried to measure repression's "drag coefficient" effect on creativity.
- fleischhauf 6y agoThis is a very interesting question and one would hope that non repressive societies are more creative and have a higher scientific output. Im not 100 % sure thats the case, however.
- wintermutestwin 6y agoIt seems to me that it would have to. If your society punishes/limits/eliminates divergent behavior and thought, you are throttling your innovation lever. I think that rising D&I budgets are a recognition of this truth. It seems like common sense to me, but I'd be interested to know if it has been studied/measured...
- free_rms 6y agoIn China, professors have to periodically write essays about how they're ideologically committed to the party goals in order to keep funding and not be fired. These goals are all nice sounding things about national prosperity and such, everyone knows what they're supposed to write, it's a minor chore. In the US, they're only doing this at hire time for D&I so far. We'll see where it goes from there.
- whoevercares 6y agoDon’t exaggerate it, people use template to do it. In China most of those are just a process thing, nobody even look at it
- free_rms 6y agoSame in the US for the pro-diversity essays as I understand it -- I was trying to make a comparison.
- ComodoHacker 6y agoIs improvement in quality of face recognition 'good for humanity'?
- bilekas 6y agoThis is one of those technologies that if in the hands of good faith actors could provide some positive results, like criminal tracking etc. But in the real world, its never just in the right hands.. Sigh yet it will still be perfected.. :|
- 8note 6y agoThat doesn't sound like the good actor value. The most obvious value I'd see is getting rid of the scan in for the amazon stores, so it's a real walk, in walk out experience
- alfalfasprout 6y agoOne thing I’ve noticed is that although eg; investing in R&D and STEM education in China has skyrocketed in the last 5-ish years in practice tech there still doesn’t seem extremely polished and talent coming to the US has been iffy on average (with the exception of the very top talent which is still excellent). A good proportion of Chinese research is still rampantly fraudulent and of the legitimate research only a small fraction ends up being truly innovative. This implies a low return on R&D investment. The same applies to software projects. At least in the OSS world you rarely see quality projects coming from China nowadays. The ones that do are almost always from companies with a US presence. Perhaps collaboration is difficult? Re: Face recognition— this is something that is so clearly going to be used as a tool for oppression yet when I speak to those currently in the mainland they sing its praises in dealing w/ COVID. We will see how the cards fall when COVID is over. My guess is you won’t see ethnic Uyghurs living in mainland China 15 years from now. Of course, every time a post about China comes up someone goes “oh but the US is the same”. No, it’s really not. The US has its fair share of issues with domestic spying and definitely some degree of repression but we still have a free and open internet, open discourse is permitted, and tools like strong encryption are widely available and even assisted in development by the government (eg; Tor).
- bilekas 6y ago> there still doesn’t seem extremely polished and talent coming to the US has been iffy on average What does this matter ? Can't they stay in China ? > This implies a low return on R&D investment. Whatever about the ethics of it, the work has been done by others they are stealing it from, im not sure how that's a low return.. > from companies with a US presence. Perhaps collaboration is difficult? Or easier to do business in the US with offices there.. Honestly your whole point just seems to look for stereotype-ish grievances to air.
- 8note 6y agoThe ethnic Uyghurs bit is the same though? The US has a lot of places with names like Sioux Falls, but where there's no Sioux living there anymore
- xster 6y ago