6 ms·
China again boosts R&D spending by more than 10%
- rvba 6y agoCan those numbers be trusted? https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/21/nobody-knows-anything-about-china/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/21/nobody-knows-anything-a...
- bserge 6y agoAt the very least we know Chinese companies (and by extension, the government) do indeed spend a lot on research, development and production. The sheer amount of tech made and shipped from China is astonishing. And the quality has massively improved, while prices stay low. Everything from amazing BGA reballing stations to high quality solar panels and power tools.
- gamblor956 6y agoA lot of that IP was stolen from US and EU companies. Cost isn't the only reason that manufacturing is moving out of China; companies are finally realizing that using Chinese factories is tantamount to giving the PRC access to all of your technical IP.
- 0_____0 6y agowas the same not true with Japan? at some point China may move past Western nations in practical sophistication, and start making better stuff. example: you want a photography drone? Like, the best commerical one available? It's a Chinese product. Most of the other stuff on the market doesn't come close. The closest we had domestically in the US was 3D systems, and then went under if I recall correctly.
- moreorless 6y ago> A lot of that ip was stolen from US and EU companies You can even go as far as ALL of that IP was stolen. Not only from US and EU, but Japanese, Peruvian, Jamaican, Mexican, as well as Brazilian. We all know that Chinese are NOT capable of innovation.
- dang 6y ago> "We all know that Chinese are NOT capable of innovation" That's a slur, you can't do that here, and we've banned this account. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. That means, at minimum, not posting unsubstantive comments and not posting nationalistic (or other) flamebait, both of which your account was unfortunately doing a lot of. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- fakeslimshady 6y agoLike 5G LOL. All knowledge and engineering is built on previous works of many others. Seems like Tesla and Apple have been successful there
- arcticbull 6y agoThat's an incredibly short-sighted way of looking at what's happening. If you want to become a Chef, you don't start by inventing new Michelin star dishes de novo. You copy your betters. Over and over and over. Then, once you learn how they do what they do, you innovate. Japan did this. Do not underestimate China.
- xenospn 6y agoThere's one major difference - Japanese companies took mediocre western tech (autos, transistor radios) and made it better. Chinese companies just copy.
- chillacy 6y agoEverybody copies at first, then they start making state of the art improvements. It takes time though, Toyota was founded in 1937, they started by reverse engineering Chrystler cars (they were surprisingly open about this in the Toyota museum). Chinese companies got started maybe around the 1980s with market reforms.
- gamblor956 6y agoThe difference is that a chef-in-training works for the Michelin-star chef in the "better" chef's restaurant, and then leaves to start their own restaurant. China's game plan has been to encourage companies to use Chinese factories based on artificially low prices (subsidized with massive PRC spending), and then to (usually openly) steal the IP and begin making competing products. This cycle has already happened to over a dozen former clients. I went in-house years ago, but even before then my firm had begun discouraging companies from opening manufacturing facilities in China for any product with any sort of valuable technical IP.
- arcticbull 6y ago> The difference is that a chef-in-training works for the Michelin-star chef in the "better" chef's restaurant, and then leaves to start their own restaurant. > China's game plan has been to encourage companies to use Chinese factories based on artificially low prices (subsidized with massive PRC spending), and then to (usually openly) steal the IP and begin making competing products. "working for" then "starting their own" yeah. See, you get it. Your analogy gets even better, just not in ways you expected, in that people who go work at Michelin starred restaurants in the kitchen do so for low-to-zero wages because the real benefit is the experience they're gaining initially.
- justicezyx 6y agoThis rhetoric is becoming more and more false with time... https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/10/16/china-intellectual-property-theft-progress/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/10/16/china-intellectual-prop...
- godelski 6y agoYour source seems to support the gp's argument. It was written just under a year ago and is talking about a deal not struck. > According to some reports, Chinese IP theft has cost the United States $225 billion to $600 billion a year. No wonder, then, that getting China to better protect IP is a point of rare consensus among both the White House and the Democratic leadership. This isn't a small chunk of change. In fact, this is comparable to the R&D budgets the main article is talking about. It then says > But history tells us to be cautious; Washington’s demands are unrealistic. Countries do not enact strong IP rights systems until their ability to innovate at home displaces reliance on outside knowledge. The United States’ own century long drift toward strong protections is a case in point. Which the tldr is: don't expect it to work. So I'm not sure why this becomes less true over time, as this is very recent and doesn't seem to have changed anything. Sure, other countries did it too, but why does that matter? Doesn't make it right.
- justicezyx 6y agoThe subtitle literally writes: The country is making the transition from net importer of ideas to net innovator, and as it does, it is finding that good patent laws matter.
- rococode 6y agoYeah, the specific numbers don't matter so much as the desired narrative behind the numbers. Clearly, the government wants to boost R&D. Regardless of whether or not they have to "adjust" their numbers for one specific year, the fact is that they've set their goalposts at double the R&D growth of the west (both US and EU are at around 5% R&D growth [1]). Unless in reality they're not even halfway reaching their goals, they're going to overtake the US and EU in spending at some point, probably pretty soon. The graph in the link below (published by the US gov) is quite clear. One of those lines is obviously not like the others. [1] https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsb20201/global-r-d https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsb20201/global-r-d
- Aperocky 6y agoMost R&D are gov sponsored and comes with receipts, so they are mostly true. Of course a decent amount get lost due to corruption, but that's always the case.
- BurningFrog 6y agoNot really.
- fakeslimshady 6y agoMore than anything from Trump's mouth
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIn principal this is good for humanity so long as the research isn’t directed towards tools to improve efficiency of repression.
- ardy42 6y ago> In principal this is good for humanity so long as the research isn’t directed towards tools to improve efficiency of repression. I wouldn't say it's that clear cut. Even if the R&D is not directly for technology for repression, it increases that power and prestige of a state that has few qualms with using repression for political ends. Those increases could mean that other states will come under its influence or emulate its repressive example (when they would have otherwise emulated less-repressive or non-repressive examples).
- free_rms 6y agoCan you give an example of a significant power, any time in history, that did have a lot of qualms with using repression for political ends? Even the Athenians had slaves.
- Taek 6y agoI think this is a very good move for China and think the US should match it.
- Proven 6y agoWhy not 20%? Or 7.34%? Of course you have no clue if an increase of 20% is too much or too little. Maybe even 7.34% is too much. Since you have no clue and no proof of any kind, perhaps it would be wise to not support a 10% increase, or not be against any other increase or even a cut?
- _6fmb 6y agoIf you actually read the article we already outspend them on R&D. We spent 2.8% of GDP vs their 2.2% of GDP. They failed to meet their target of 2.5% of GDP despite steadily increasing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cma 6y agoBut their purchasing power parity is way higher so presumably they get more for less, other than stuff they have to import to support research.
- sudosysgen 6y agoI don't understand why this is downvoted. Money goes further in China than in the US, and the Chinese GDP PPP is indeed higher than the US, although barely.
- newen 6y ago$27.8 trillion vs $20.3 trillion is not barely.
- sudosysgen 6y ago
- Proven 6y agoWaste of money... They have no idea how much, if at all, RD spending should change. For example, how could they tell if it ought to be decreased? Too many patents or published research papers? It's enormously entertaining to watch the HN readers' continuous support for increased government spending because it supposedly fits some modern economic theories or matches fake research papers without having any clue as to how economics actually works.
- tresCommatoso 6y agoWhat if - we hypothetical assume that china one day would become a normal nation, ruled by a democratic elected government - with power divided by checks and balances, and a rule of law. Now lets further assume that any company, that lost ip to the "old regime" gained a title in a international court that upholds, no matter the current regime. These titles would have value - that even would increase (after all its parked money). Thus a company, making a loss due to ip theft, could sell of those future earnings - for example to a bank. A bank, could hold on to the title and use it to for example collect the owned money of the title from people who are involved in the ownership of the title - as ccp members or parts of a company owned by the ccp. That way ip-theft, would be nothing, but debt taken from the international community.. and as the title collection would make it rather bad for those taking the debt..the accumulating debt would make the regime go bankrupt.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]