3 ms·
The comments on this blog entry scare me. Fanboyism and groupthink pushed to the limit. EDIT: ah well, I see that this opinion is shared. It kind of cheers me
by simias 16y ago
The comments on this blog entry scare me. Fanboyism and groupthink pushed to the limit.
EDIT: ah well, I see that this opinion is shared. It kind of cheers me up. Kind of.
- tuhin 16y agoAwesome Sony. Hope you gave it to him good. Is this for real? The moment I read the comments I was like, "this is so different from the view people have on HN". Also I am sure these are kids who just swear by their consoles. Sadly they are Sony's biggest chunk of consumers.
- kenkam 16y agoAt first I was taken back by the comments but then I realised that they are the opposing camp. HN readers support Geohot while Playstation.com readers support... Sony. Just 2 sides of the story.
- simias 16y agoI can motivate my support for geohot, I'd like to hear their reasons (besides all the FUD spread everywhere by sony & friends). I thought that hackers and playstation 3 "owners" would be on the same side, given that the ultimate question here is whether they really own the console or not.
- smhinsey 16y agoI am not sure reasoned justification comes into it. It's football with words and you have to root for your team.
- saurik 16y agoand, unfortunately, it is also "more fun" to root for the "winning team", so when there are shifts in the balance of power you see shifts in the demographics of agreement. :(
- fleitz 16y agoIt's likely the perception that geohotz hacks have something to do with 'cheaters'.
- sycren 16y agoI think its also the stigma attached to the word hacker. geohot may have had more support from the owners if he had called himself a freedom fighter..
- eli 16y agoMy guess is that among video game enthusiasts, "hacking" is linked to cheating in online gameplay, which I think we can all agree is really annoying. It also depends on what motivations you assign to geohot. I wouldn't have much sympathy for him if I thought his intention was to pirate video games.
- redthrowaway 16y agoActually, given the ps3-owning demographic, the widespread impression that geohot was trying to enable piracy may actually have increased support for him. Gamers are a notoriously piratey bunch, so if the story had been "George Hotz wants you to be able to play games from bittorrent", he might have enjoyed wider support.
- jsnell 16y agoMost PS3 owners care about playing games, watching DVDs, maybe playing some streaming media, etc. As long as those things work, they'll have no interest in who actually controls the machine. They'll certainly have no interest in hacking the guts of the console to turn it into a flaky general purpose computer. There's a good chance they already have plenty of those around. And since they get no utility from the hacks but do pay some costs, it seems perfectly rational to pick the "wrong" side from your perspective. Which isn't to say that Sony has handled this well: they're still incompetent and Evil.
- tzs 16y agoGiven the choice between paying $X for a console that comes with restrictions so that you can only use it for playing games, or paying $Y for a console that you can do anything you want with, where $Y is greater than $X by up to a couple hundred dollars, most PS3 buyers would take the former. I can see how people might worry that if using PS3s for non-gaming becomes widespread, Sony might feel the need to raise the price to make up for the loss.
- etcet 16y ago> I thought that hackers and playstation 3 "owners" would be on the same side Apparently, Anonymous took down the PSN for some time in protest to the litigation. I'm sure that galvanized the viewpoint of some Playstation users who may not have even been aware of the bigger picture.
- henrikschroder 16y agoThere's a belief among some gamers that the cracking of a console somehow, magically, enables people to cheat in online games. And driven by that belief and a hate for cheaters, they go after the wrong target.
- Macuyiko 16y agoThe belief is mostly correct however, although it is true that the targets are indeed wrong. People doing the initial grunt work of cracking a console are not the same people as the ones developing cheats.
- bbatsell 16y agoThe cheating on PSN, up until now at least, has been entirely through exploits of binary saved game data (which can be transferred to and from the console freely). There was widespread hacking long before any jailbreak. Don't get me wrong, jailbreaking certainly opens up other avenues, but Sony (and developers) had been doing a very poor job of anti-cheat for a long time. With the jailbreak, they simply found a scapegoat that they hoped would take the heat off of them.
- jcarreiro 16y agoMany of the commenters at Ars Technica (which has been following this story closely) have similar opinions of Sony and of Mr. Hotz. Those praising the actions of Sony don't seem to understand any of the larger issues here. It doesn't matter to them that free inquiry is being destroyed in order to shield the embarrassing secrets of a huge corporation from public view, as long as they can boot up their game console and play their shiny new video game without any inconvenience.
- citricsquid 16y agocan we blame them?
- alexqgb 16y agoFor what? Their own lack of perspective? Interesting to see, however, that the side people take is an efficient indicator of their intelligence level - not as in IQ, but as in CIA (on its better days).
- ascendant 16y agoI could hardly hear my own thoughts over the bleating of all those sheep.
- JonnieCache 16y ago>sheep Someone who trots out such hackneyed clichés should be careful criticising others for following the crowd.
- ascendant 16y agoNo, I won't back down from that. Those people all sound like they've gleefully sucked down the kool-aid that Sony spoon-fed them. I'll burn a few karma points to stand by my opinion.
- JonnieCache 16y agoI agree with your view, that's not what I was criticising. It was your choice of words. Describing people as "sheep" is a horribly overused phrase and it has associations of angsty teenagers raging against the machine. It is also not generally a good idea to attack others for following the crowd, as we all do it. Those who consider themselves contrarian are typically simply choosing to highlight the areas where they reject society, while ignoring the myriad ways in which they toe the line every day. People who really do question all of society's assumptions get locked away in mental hospitals. Also, we all follow what others tell us because it would be impossible not to. To do otherwise would require independently researching and validating each and every position one holds, and there simply isn't enough time in the day. If you really questioned everything, you would achieve nothing.
- akanet 16y agoListen, sheep means what it means. When the shoe fits...
- jorsh 16y agoWelcome to the glorious world of consumer culture. This is what ever huge corporation has been fighting to achieve for the past 50 years.
- adestefan 16y agoMuch like the comments that I see on HN, ArsTechnica, reddit, ...
- ascendant 16y agoTo a degree, yes. Fanboy-ism creeps up on the best of us. I'd like to think that at least in some places (like HN), the commentators are more educated on the topics they're discussing.
- zyb09 16y agoJust wait until Apple sues someone and lets see for which side HN roots in that case :o
- marshray 16y agoApparently the great majority of visitors to Sony's PlayStation blog haven't experienced the joy of developing their own firmware and operating system for their home supercomputer appliance. Poor souls. I always knew video games would destroy the mind and the ability to appreciate the finer things in life.